search

Canadensys / vascan-data

VASCAN data issue management
0 stars 0 forks source link

authorities of synonyms #1993

Open sjmeades opened 9 years ago

sjmeades commented 9 years ago

[Originally posted on GoogleCode (id 2204) on 2014-05-25]

(This is the template to report a data issue for Vascan. If you want to report another issue, please change the template above.)

What is the URL of the page where the problem occurs? http://data.canadensys.net/vascan/taxon/4999?lang=en

What data are incorrect or missing? Carex rigida var. goodenovii L.H. Bailey Carex goodenovii var. strictiformis (L.H. Bailey) Kükenthal

What data are you expecting instead? Carex rigida var. goodenowii (J.Gay) L.H. Bailey Carex goodenowii var. strictiformis (L.H. Bailey) Kükenthal

Add: Carex goodenowii J.Gay Note spelling of C. goodenowii, with a 'w'.

If applicable, please provide an authoritative source. IPNI, Plant List, & French Synonymique have Carex goodenowii J.Gay – Ann. Sci. Nat. Bot. 1839 Tropicos has the same lit. citation, but just Gay. Since they both lived at the same time, it might be necessary to confirm from the original publication.

And in Bailey's publication, he mentions Carex goodenowii as a synonym with the same citation, but only uses the last name, Gay, which could be an oversight. But despite the spelling, he does list C. goodenowii as a synonym, so this name should be listed as the parenthetical authority of C. rigida var. goodenowii. Bailey also spells the specific epithet as goodenovii, but it was originally spelled as goodenowii. I'm not sure why both spellings are retained in IPNI and MBG. For the species, both IPNI and MBG use the spelling C. goodenowii, but some combinations are entered with both spellings - with a 'v' and 'w'

See L.H.Bailey: Writings on Carex, Volume 2, Carex rigida and its varieties. Originally in Journal of Botany - British and Foreign, pg 172

http://books.google.ca/books?id=_QYaAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA416-IA2&lpg=PA416-IA2&dq=Carex+rigida+var.+goodenovii&source=bl&ots=p7RDVoRoxF&sig=m9P0eKKW3mpoP9sxjz4gmY_Vfpc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=-2yCU7G4O-6n8QHTiYD4BQ&ved=0CDkQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Carex%20rigida%20var.%20goodenovii&f=false

brouille commented 1 year ago

Carex rigida var. goodenovii (J. Gay) L.H. Bailey - Bailey cites Gay in his protologue

spelling of goodenowii vs vii appears to be contentious. IPNI has vii - needs to check