search

Card-Forge / forge

An unofficial rules engine for the world's greatest card game.
GNU General Public License v3.0
866 stars 510 forks source link

Multiple Bugs that make Forge MTG unplayable atm. #5467

Open Nymra opened 1 week ago

Nymra commented 1 week ago

I play EDH games against three AI.

A summary of issues:

  1. Commander tax BUG sometimes commander tax explodes out of nowhere, making my commander gost ridiculous amounts of mana for casting, even when it has been casted only once this game. Could not find a pattern for this bug, but it seems it is related to even clicking on the commander in the command zone to check the cost, but not only that.

  2. Game Freezes on occasional situations Game just freezes in "waiting for opponent". happens on multiple occasions. the only occasion that I noticed happened repeatedly is when one AI is losing, but there are more cases for this

  3. "Undo" and "Cancel" bugs often when I use Undo and or cancel, a multitude of stuff can happen like:

    • command tax explosion (see 1)
    • one or more AIs drop out of the game (like if they conceded. all their cards disappear)
    • I drop out of the game (rare)
Hanmac commented 1 week ago

"sometimes commander tax explodes out of nowhere"

Disable the Experimental Snapshot feature

Nymra commented 1 week ago

"sometimes commander tax explodes out of nowhere"

Disable the Experimental Snapshot feature

thank you, will try that!

Nymra commented 1 week ago

"sometimes commander tax explodes out of nowhere"

Disable the Experimental Snapshot feature

Do you mean "EXPERIMENTAL Undo restore" in Game Settings / Preferences? Because that I have already unchecked [ ] from the beginning, so the above still happens with this disabled.

tehdiplomat commented 22 hours ago

I just tried reproducing this "Commander tax bug" with Undo restore enabled and wasn't able to do so. Any other specifics?

Nymra commented 22 hours ago

I just tried reproducing this "Commander tax bug" with Undo restore enabled and wasn't able to do so. Any other specifics?

sadly no :( I could not successfuly reproduce this myself. Just noticed it happen randomly in my games along the noted series of other bugs. It was the least common of these bugs tho, the game freezing is much more likely.

The only time that I could see it happen when I saw it spiked to 17W already and then every time I clicked on the commander and then cancelled it got 2 more cost.