DEV Systema Dipterorum: DD vs GO

[yroskov]

Original file Systema Dipterorum ver. 4.5, 2023-11-16

Two versions:

Systema Dipterorum - DD ver (id 1101) - version processed via TW https://www.dev.checklistbank.org/dataset/1101/about

Systema Dipterorum - GO ver (id 277710) - version processed by GO converter https://www.dev.checklistbank.org/dataset/277710/about

Comparison on DEV: https://www.dev.checklistbank.org/dataset/1101/diff?attempts=25..26

Red = GO, Green = DD

Original website: http://www.diptera.org/Nomenclator

[yroskov]

Detected classes of disparities between GO vs DD

• year in the authorstring (it's only happened in this conversion; correct in SD of May@CoL

GO	DD	SD on Web
Abaristophora (Antipodiphora) austrophila (Schmitz, 1927)	Abaristophora (Antipodiphora) austrophila (Schmitz, 1939)	Abaristophora (Antipodiphora) austrophila (Schmitz, 1939: 68)
Anthrax seriepunctatus (Osten Sacken, 1877)	Anthrax seriepunctatus (Osten Sacken, 1886)	Anthrax seriepunctatus (Osten Sacken, 1886: 103)
Ablabesmyia digitata (Kieffer, 1910)	Ablabesmyia digitata (Kieffer, 1923)	Ablabesmyia digitata (Kieffer, 1923: 193)

• different authors & year in authorstrings

GO	DD	SD on Web

• authorstings with uninomials

GO	DD	SD on Web
Abacantha	Abacantha Hall, 1938	Abacantha Hall, 1938: 173
Docidiadia	Docidiadia Blagoderov & Grimaldi, 2004	Docidiadia Blagoderov & Grimaldi, 2004: 6

• brackets in authorstrings

GO	DD	SD on Web
Ablabesmyia aurea (Johannsen, 1907)	Ablabesmyia aurea Johannsen, 1907	Ablabesmyia aurea Johannsen, 1907: 10
Anthrax pudicus (Lynch Arribálzaga, 1878)	Anthrax pudicus Lynch Arribálzaga, 1878	Anthrax pudicus Lynch Arribálzaga, 1878: 275
Onesia viridulans (Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830)	Onesia viridulans Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830	nesia viridulans Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830: 369

[yroskov]

• [ ] epithet gender

Example names:

GO	DD	SD on Web
Ablabesmyia punctulata (Philippi, 1865)	Ablabesmyia punctulatus (Philippi, 1865)	Ablabesmyia punctulata (Philippi, 1865: 599)
Anthrax zonabriphagus (Portschinsky, 1895)	Anthrax zonabriphaga (Portschinsky, 1895)	Anthrax zonabriphagus (Portschinsky, 1895: 14)
Anthrax solitus (Walker, 1849)	Anthrax solita Walker, 1857	Anthrax solita Walker, 1857: 140
Anthrax plurinotus (Bigot, 1892)	Anthrax plurinota (Bigot, 1892)	Anthrax plurinotus (Bigot, 1892: 350)
Oniromyia pachycerata (Bigot, 1892)	Oniromyia pachyceratus (Bigot, 1892)	Oniromyia pachycerata (Bigot, 1892: 371)
Onychaspidium longiscutellatum (Enderlein, 1911)	Onychaspidium longiscutellatus (Enderlein, 1911)	Onychaspidium longiscutellatum (Enderlein, 1911: 229)

[yroskov]

• [ ] Difference in total species numbers

GO	DD	SD on Web
172,818	181,767	+ 8,949 via TW
Abbemyia baylaci Bickel, 1994	shown as missing in DIFF, but present in DD	Abbemyia baylaci Bickel, 2002: 77
Dobrogiella phallogreciana Lehrer & Oprișan, 2013	--	Dobrogiella phallogreciana Lehrer & Opri?an, 2013: 45

Geoff's examples (@proceps, export pipe into CLB interprets (Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym names as accepted. Are they fine in TW?):

GO	DD	SD on Web
--	Acemya angulicornis (Zetterstedt, 1844); ! NomStatus in the spreadsheet '(Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym'	Not present on SD website!
--	Agromyza krousianica (Černý, 2011); ! NomStatus in the spreadsheet '(Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym'	Not present on SD website!
--	Dohrniphora cleghorni (Bigot, 1890); ! NomStatus in the spreadsheet '(Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym'	Not present on SD website!

This name is missing in the old version, and is present in the TW version: Amaurosoma indotatum (Engelmark, 1999) with status '(Available, Valid) Changed Combination / Rank' in the original dataset.

Amblyonychus macquartii is another name not in the old version but in the new version. It has 2 lines in the original dataset one with status '(Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym' and the other with status '(Available, Invalid) Junior Synonym; junior primary homonym'

[yroskov]

• [ ] Species rank vs infraspecific rank

GO	DD	SD on Web
Abebaiodacus angolanus Munro, 1984	Abebaiodacus fuscatus f. angolanus Munro, 1984	Abebaiodacus fuscatus f. angolanus Munro, 1984: 110
Abebaiodacus euchlorus Munro, 1984	Abebaiodacus fuscatus f. euchlorus Munro, 1984	Abebaiodacus fuscatus f. euchlorus Munro, 1984: 110
Dohrniphora basalis Santos Abreu, 1921	Dohrniphora divaricata var. basalis Santos Abreu, 1921	Dohrniphora divaricata var. basalis Santos Abreu, 1921: 11
Dohrniphora obscura Santos Abreu, 1921	Dohrniphora divaricata var. obscura Santos Abreu, 1921	Dohrniphora divaricata var. obscura Santos Abreu, 1921: 11

[yroskov]

• Duplicated entry for the genus (?). Perhaps, the case when the name once is an accepted genus, second time it is a "synonym" to the subgenus.

GO	DD	SD on Web
Ablabesmyia	2 x Ablabesmyia Johannsen, 1905	Ablabesmyia Johannsen, 1905: 135
Dohrniphora	2 x Dohrniphora Dahl, 1898	Dohrniphora Dahl, 1898: 188

[yroskov]

• [ ] Missing species epithet in DD - for @proceps attention Geoff: There is some bad data in the TW version although probably caused by bad data in SD:

5086 + Aedes subsp. carteri Edwards, 1936 5087 + Aedes subsp. holocinctus Edwards, 1941 5088 + Aedes subsp. karooensis Muspratt, 1961 5089 + Aedes subsp. leonis Colless, 1958 5090 + Aedes subsp. mesostictus Harbach, 2018 5091 + Aedes subsp. pallens Ross, 1943

5146 + Aedes var. var.andrewsi Edwards, 1926 5147 + Aedes var. var.dunni Evans, 1928 5148 + Aedes var. var.hebrideus Edwards, 1926 5149 + Aedes var. var.kivuensis Edwards, 1941 5150 + Aedes var. var.maculicosta Edwards, 1936 5151 + Aedes var. var.nigrescens Edwards, 1929

Dohrniphora var. var.pachycera Schmitz, 1918 Dohrniphora var. var.pachycera Schmitz, 1918

[yroskov]

• [ ] Possibly missing subspecies in DD (but I didn't find them also on SD website) - @proceps, another case to check

GO	DD	SD on Web
Dolichopeza (Dolichopeza) katoi katoi Alexander, 1912	Dolichopeza (Dolichopeza) katoi Alexander, 1938	Dolichopeza katoi Alexander, 1938: 109
Dolichopeza (Dolichopeza) katoi rufula Savchenko, 1968	Dolichopeza (Dolichopeza) katoi Alexander, 1938	Dolichopeza katoi Alexander, 1938: 109

[yroskov]

• [ ] Different epithets (misspelled in DD?) - @proceps, curious case

GO	DD	SD on Web
Dolichophaonia catamcla (Snyder, 1957)	Dolichophaonia catamacla (Snyder, 1957)	Dolichophaonia catamcla (Snyder, 1957: 483)

[proceps]

the last one, is an inconsistency in the original DB between original and current name. One is a misspelling

[proceps]

All data in TW are based on protonyms (original combinations)