search

CatsAndBoats / catseyexi

:sailboat: LandSandBoat - a server emulator for Final Fantasy XI. Just an X-34 landspeeder out for a drive.
https://landsandboat.github.io/server/
GNU General Public License v3.0
12 stars 13 forks source link

Gungnir does not proc 2.5x dmg #303

Closed discord-bug-reports[bot] closed 4 months ago

discord-bug-reports[bot] commented 7 months ago

Submitter: aelt Author: zed596

I've noticed for a long time that Gungnir procs 2x and not 2.5x like it's suppose to, so I figured I'll finally do a report. After testing todays change to dmg augs, I can show right away that the proc is 2x and not 2.5x. Here is a picture of me doing a 1530 crit. At 109 dmg, Gungnir can crit up to 800~. Based on the dmg range for 109 dmg + a proc, the dmg for a crit proc at 2x is about 1480-1604, while 2.5x is 1835-2005, so it's clearly 2x proc.

Also a friend looked at the websites database and noticed that gugnir is set to "occ do extra dmg 200", when something like ragnarok which is also 2.5x is set to "occ do extra dmg 250". So rag is correct and thats what gungnir should be. I'll put a picture of that as well <:cactaur:995891581364207636>.

github-actions[bot] commented 7 months ago

✨ Thanks for the report! ✨

This is a friendly automated reminder that the maintainers won't look at your report until you've properly completed all of the checkboxes in the pre-filled template.

TracentEden2 commented 5 months ago

Submitter: aelt Author: zed596

I've noticed for a long time that Gungnir procs 2x and not 2.5x like it's suppose to, so I figured I'll finally do a report. After testing todays change to dmg augs, I can show right away that the proc is 2x and not 2.5x. Here is a picture of me doing a 1530 crit. At 109 dmg, Gungnir can crit up to 800~. Based on the dmg range for 109 dmg + a proc, the dmg for a crit proc at 2x is about 1480-1604, while 2.5x is 1835-2005, so it's clearly 2x proc.

Also a friend looked at the websites database and noticed that gugnir is set to "occ do extra dmg 200", when something like ragnarok which is also 2.5x is set to "occ do extra dmg 250". So rag is correct and thats what gungnir should be. I'll put a picture of that as well <:cactaur:995891581364207636>.

Someone reported a similar issue on another private server so I had someone do a retail parse with 75 Gungnir last month. An analysis of that data shows that out of 400 normal hits, the ratio between the average damage of high damage hits to low damage is 2.0048, thus confirming the 2.0 value. The 2.5 value on any English wikis seems to be a mistake (JP wiki for example has it at 2.0) or it was changed at some point but there does not seem to be evidence for a change. Can see more discussion on this issue