search

CatxFish / obs-v4l2sink

obs studio output plugin for Video4Linux2 device
GNU General Public License v2.0
930 stars 99 forks source link

Output doesn't work with Discord and Skype #50

Open GermainGirndt opened 4 years ago

GermainGirndt commented 4 years ago

Hello guys! I've installed obs-v4l2sink plug-in to OBS (v. 25.0.8) on my Ubuntu 20.04 LTS.

After that, I created a new virtual cam with v4l2loopback:

sudo modprobe v4l2loopback devices=1 video_nr=10 card_label="OBS Cam" exclusive_caps=1

and used the new installed plug-in to output to it (note: the program keep crashing if I set YUV420 as videoformat): image

The Problem:

Although I sucessfully managed to output OBS to OBS itself and to Google Chrome (https://meet.jit.si/), some applications like Skype and Discord get no output from it, though they recognize the virtual cam.

Discord: image

Skype: image

Any hints for fixing it?

katsar0v commented 4 years ago

Skype shows black screen as soon as I go over 720p. With 1280x720 it should be fine

rdlmda commented 4 years ago

I have the same issue, output is totally black.

katsar0v commented 4 years ago

It would be great if some of the devs could take a look or could just confirm that these apps can only use 720p streams

rdlmda commented 4 years ago

I was able to get it working by changing the video format to YUY2 on the format dropdown on the properties dialog. I tried 320 x 240, 640 x 480, 800 x 600 and 800 x 450 resolutions on Zoom.

katsar0v commented 4 years ago

Yeah, I also get all resolutions up to 1280x720 working. Full hd and up does not on my side

rdlmda commented 4 years ago

I managed to get a 1920 x 1080 video to show up on Zoom. So we probably can rule out this plugin being unable to deal with full HD streams.

katsar0v commented 4 years ago

I managed to get a 1920 x 1080 video to show up on Zoom. So we probably can rule out this plugin being unable to deal with full HD streams.

I am not sure it is because of the plugin directly. V4l2 directly streamed with ffmpeg, does not work in full hd resolution for discord and Skype. Zoom works fine, jitsi too, but Skype and discord are far more used.

jktjkt commented 4 years ago

Just for the record, I've been pushing 1920x1080p@25fps and 1280x720p@25Hz via OBS and this v4l2sink plugin to Zoom on Linux just fine. The end result of course sucks because the "Group HD" got disabled for almost everyone, so you'll get a wonderful 640x350px video stream (yay). But that's not really any problem with OBS or obs-v4l2sink or v4l2.

katsar0v commented 4 years ago

Just for the record, I've been pushing 1920x1080p@25fps and 1280x720p@25Hz via OBS and this v4l2sink plugin to Zoom on Linux just fine. The end result of course sucks because the "Group HD" got disabled for almost everyone, so you'll get a wonderful 640x350px video stream (yay). But that's not really any problem with OBS or obs-v4l2sink or v4l2.

Thank you for confirming that this works in zoom. As mentioned above, the issue is with discord and skype

AZMCode commented 4 years ago

Actually, I have tried it with Zoom on Ubuntu and I have the same problem, Chief

What's more, I've found, using a second loopback device, that using ffmpeg to pipe my camera directly to the loopback works, and piping the output of this plugin doesn't.

I have also tried all different settings I could think of, including all output modes in the plug-in. No idea if any settings in OBS itself affect the result, but I've fiddled with those asw.

Note: I've had to build OBS and the plugin from source to even boot both without a segfault

Edit: Nevermind, using the resolutions listed above for zoom worked

JVictorV commented 4 years ago

On discord i had to downgrade my resolution to 1920x1080 and restart to make it work

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

I'm using YUY420 on /dev/video2 without the exclusive_caps=1. It only started working when I downscaled the output resolution to 1280x720. However afterwards I could stop the sink, and then go back and rescale to 1920x1080, and then start the sink again, and it continued to work.

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

Problem is the output is flipped because the skype thinks it is a webcam.

JVictorV commented 3 years ago

Problem is the output is flipped because the skype thinks it is a webcam.

Did you check if the other people on the call also see your webcam flipped? it's flipped for me too, but it looks ok for everyone else

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

Oh... in that case that might be fine then. I was hoping v4l2sink might add a flipping option.

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

And then when I closed skype and reopened it while my sink was running. The 1920x1080 resolution continued to work. That's pretty cool.

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

How strange, after messing around with v4l2loopback thinking I could create 2 devices one that has no exclusive caps and one that does, now no matter what I do, I always end up with a black screen. Nothing else changed, so now it just stopped working.

CMCDragonkai commented 3 years ago

After hours of testing. I have found a consistent behaviour between OBS, Skype, Zoom, and Google Chrome. This is done on NixOS on 4.19 kernel.

Experiment:

boot.extraModprobeConfig = ''
  options v4l2loopback video_nr=10,11 card_label="virtualcam,virtualcam-chrome" exclusive_caps=0,1
'';

This should end up creating 2 devices /dev/video10 and /dev/video11.

The /dev/video10 is the virtualcam that will be usable by Skype and Zoom.

Prior to starting the sink, you must set the resolution. Assuming your base resolution is 1920x1080.

For using Skype, the output resolution must be 1280x720.

For using Zoom, the output resolution can be set to 1920x1080.

Set the resolution first, then start the sink, and then go into the video settings of the respective program.

If you get a black screen. Stop the sink and restart OBS studio and then do it again.

You do not need to restart Skype or Zoom at all, just reopen the video settings.

For using Google chrome, the output resolution can be 1920x1080. Start the sink on /dev/video11 instead.

So if you want to be compatible with everything Skype, Zoom, Chrome, you just need to set to 1280x720 and switch between /dev/video10 or /dev/video11 and if there is a black screen, then just stop sink, restart obs and start sink again and restart the video settings or video tab on Chrome.

One trick on Skype is once you have the 1280x720 working, you can stop the sink, change the output resolution back to 1920x1080 and start the sink again. Skype will continue working, but the output resolution is now at 1920x1080 and so if you record, you still get a 1080p output.

Yes the whole thing is very flaky.