Unable to play ogg streams, flac ogg playing but no sound

CelliesProjects / ESP32_VS1053_Stream

A streaming library for Arduino esp32 with a vs1053 mp3/aac/ogg/flac decoder. Plays http, https (insecure mode) and chunked streams and parses the metadata. Also plays ogg and mp3 from sdcard.

MIT License

53 stars 10 forks source link

Unable to play ogg streams, flac ogg playing but no sound #8

Closed Sentinel8000 closed 2 years ago

Sentinel8000 commented 2 years ago

When i try play ogg streams with the library i get false to streamisrunning and codec: unknow and code fail to play ogg streams, no sound.

Tested normal ogg streams:

http://retro.dancewave.online/retrodance.ogg https://icast.connectmedia.hu/4765/mr2.ogg https://www.jazzradio.hu:8000/jazzradio_192.ogg
https://icast.connectmedia.hu/4765/mr2.ogg http://dancewave.online/dance.ogg

If i try flac ogg (maybe not supported), library detect codec: ogg and streamisrunning true but no sound.

Tested Flac type ogg stream: http://retro.dancewave.online/retrodance.flac.ogg

Im not sure, the problem is with the library or the ogg format not supported.

CelliesProjects commented 2 years ago

An Ogg stream can be two things:

Ogg: a container format for multimedia files. The Ogg container can contain several stream formats including FLAC.
Ogg-Vorbis: a codec similar to mp3.

This library only plays files and streams encoded with the Ogg-Vorbis codec. So no FLAC encoded files.

Any Ogg files containing streams that are not mp3, aac, aac+ or Ogg-Vorbis will not be recognised or played.

CelliesProjects commented 2 years ago

See https://www.vlsi.fi/en/support/software/vs10xxpatches.html

Sentinel8000 commented 2 years ago

I know flac type ogg need extra patch for vs1053 library to use, i have just tested.

But if we talk about flac, i know about these patches, if i have this in a header format and im include this in code. Stream will be played or will be problem because this library is a extension for the vs1053 library?

https://github.com/schreibfaul1/ESP32-vs1053_ext/blob/master/src/vs1053b-patches-flac.h

Im reverse the ogg vorbis part of your answer/my question, if my shared ogg streams was not ,,standard" (lookslike all what i have found) can you give a example ogg stream what can handle the vs1053 stream?

CelliesProjects commented 2 years ago

Just pushed 99eec8a which should fix at least some of the above streams. Some more work might be needed. http://retro.dancewave.online/retrodance.flac.ogg does not play, but in debug mode I see data being pumped to the codec, but no sound.