Editorial Meeting 12 Jan

[bumblefudge]

PRs to refine/move to close

• LAST LAST CALL on 179
  • _ removed on purpose or error of merge conflict resolution?
  • merge once _ is approved by joel and pedro
• Update on DagJWS - waiting to refactor until 196 is merged

Ongoing projects/topics

• Has everyone seen ligi's PR or Discussion?
  • remove blocks and tokens, add them back in as a separate extension CAIP if at all?
    • blocks? (versus block)
    • tokens? redundant to address/contract interface?
    • Juan: I will open that separate CAIP once this has shaken out a bit and I've seen how this was received/refined by implementers
  • Pedro: Removing better than adding
  • Ligi: original EIP is stagnant?
    • Pedro: Isn't an EIP that depends on it (wallet_add_ethereum) final? Nope, stagnant as well even though widely adopted in practice...
    • Ligi: regardless of fate of EIP, CAIP should be the current-state/used state
  • Bumblefudge posting to discord for more eyes
• Joel's CACAO update, with breaking changes and relying on varsig and multidid
  • timeline-- can we leave it in DRAFT until varsig and multidid are v1?
  • have reached out to Spruce for initial feedback; anyone else who should be reached out to proactively?
  • Pedro - this is feeling like a v2, not a v1.1... isn't there a version string for this?
    • Juan: Separate/new CAIP #?
    • Rocco: the 4 versions of EIP712? 4 versions withing on EIP?
    • Rocco: With SIWE EIP, we tried to freeze the grammar itself cuz everything else could be a minor breaking changes if it broke...
    • Pedro: Process versus Reality: cAIP-19 isn't final but there are huge implementations using it
    • Consensus --> new CAIP -
• CAIP-25 update: stable Draft last month, now focusing efforts on CAIP-27 and CAIP-171 (as needed)
• CI for CAIPs - no progress on juan's side, let me know if urgent
  • req: FINAL CAIPs should not accept PRs!
• Metamask/EVM signing of IPLD objects thread in IPFS

Backlog

• namespaces
  • algorand/caip-2 just added last night!
  • stacks - PR open, on me
  • tezos/caip10 & caip122 - One review, on me
  • StarkNet - on me
  • sui - proceeding
  • zcash - Juan dropped email thread, restarted earlier today
  • filecoin - on me, will continue
  • outreach still appreciated for cosmos, polkadot, monero, chainlink, and radicle
• clean up jekyll publication and test/fine-tune workflow for CAIP PRs
  • in partic a sidebar with table-of-contents within long CAIPs would be killer
  • how urgent, relative to namespaces and CAIPs themselves?
• varsig and multidid - Juan is a little resource-constrained but will get to it this month - V2
  • Pedro - are the authors really waiting on you here?