Charcoal-SE / metasmoke

Web dashboard for SmokeDetector.
https://metasmoke.erwaysoftware.com
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
43 stars 34 forks source link

Repeated identical reports of one same post #724

Closed user12986714 closed 4 years ago

user12986714 commented 4 years ago

Due to various reasons, we have repeated identical reports of one post. Example. Repeated reports may be caused by another answer on the same question being edited, or the post being reported manually by !!/allspam, which will cause SD to send reports to MS without inspecting if it has already been reported.

One may want to implement some checks on MS, in an effort to discard identical reports.

Reasons: identical reports are incredibly annoying, is a waste of review effort, and causes inaccuracies when evaluating tp/fp percentages using search.

teward commented 4 years ago

This... is always how MetaSmoke has worked.

Identical reports also show trends-over-time and revisions/edits of the same post. This is how SmokeDetector has always worked and how Metasmoke has always worked.

Consider an example:

SPAMMER posts something that is bad as an edit to a post per Vandalism on a stolen account. Someone reverts it. Spammer comes back in and edits it again, adding the same spam content.

That would trigger two separate reports for two separate incidents of the same spam. This is by-design behavior so we can track all the cases of such spam on the post, especially when edit spammers hit the same post multiple times.

user12986714 commented 4 years ago

(@teward ) Yes, that is true. However, the problem is that MS seems to keep duplicated reports even when the original post is not edited (no revision history), but another post on the same question get edited; or when the original post is not edited but someone reported it again with !!/allspam

Edit: Maybe this is a SD issue that should be addressed on SD side rather than MS side?

user12986714 commented 4 years ago

Closed as this is due to SD, not MS.