search

ChrisMarinos / FSharpKoans

A simple, fun, and interactive way to learn the F# language through testing.
Other
1.28k stars 671 forks source link

Discussion: possible move to fsprojects #53

Open dsyme opened 7 years ago

dsyme commented 7 years ago

Continuing a previous discussion in a new thread:

@dsyme said

If you like we could move this project over to http://github.com/fsprojects to help allow the community to maintain the koans collectively? thanks!

@ChrisMarinos said

I'm not opposed to the move if it helps, but I'm not sure why it makes a difference in terms of allowing the community to maintain the koans since we're both collaborators on this repo, and I've been more than happy to moderate and approve any pull requests as they come in. My preference would be to keep the location the same to maintain the repository history, links, etc. that point to this location. Let me know if I'm missing something, though!

@dsyme said

My experience is that locating projects in organizations (rather than individual accounts) encourages co-ownership, and sometimes allows orthogonal issues like this to be addressed by different owners (one looks after content, another looks after quality etc.). When using a personal repo, there seems to be a default expectation that the individual will address everything. That expectation can be changed, but somehow I rarely see multiple active owners for long-term projects in personal spaces. By placing it in an organization, co-ownership seems to end up the default. This repo is also one where people might be interested in co-owning, helping to shape its future, e.g. by extending the Koans to cover new constructs, presenting the koans in new ways, adding CI to the repo to make sure the Koans run across all platforms (including Fable), and so on. Sergey Tihon has been a great co-owner of many fsprojects projects in this way. Not all projects benefit however - it kind of depends.

If you move a project, Github automatically forwards all URL accesses, so you get web link continuity and repo history. You can also rename the project and forwarding works. One option might be to move it and rename it to "FSharpKoansByChris" or the like, to keep the personal recognition (which I know can be useful as a CV element too), with a note in the header

Anyway, think it over. Seeing this issue pop up just made me wonder :)

normanhh3 commented 6 years ago

I found this project to be incredibly useful to me in getting started with some actual F# code. I am now so excited I am working through my first big contribution!

I think Don makes good points Chris. I also think that this is really an important treasure for promoting the F# language.

Have you applied to become a Microsoft F# evangelist yet? ;-)

I really do see how this could be extended quite a bit to cover even more functional topics that could really help bring more developers to the fold.

If at some point Chris you get tired of maintaining this, it sounds like this project has a few folks that might be willing to jump in. :-)