Grading Criterion 🏆

[vivi365]

Mandatory

• [x] The protocol is hosted on GitHub, publicly available.
• [x] The GitHub repository must have a root README file.
• [x] The protocol can be automatically executed from a test suite
• [x] The usage of the protocol is well documented
• [x] The length of the presentation is 15 minutes (hard limit)

Optional

Need 9 checked to pass.

Protocol and Documentation

• [x] The protocol is clearly motivated
• [x] The README gives enough background
• [x] The protocol is original & the README discusses closely related work

Presentation

• [x] The presentation focuses on the technical aspects of the protocol
• [x] The structure of the presentation is announced and graphically visible
• [x] The presentation contains valuable and readable code snippets
• [x] The presentation contains a reflective part
• [ ] There is one good slide positioning the presentation in the state of the art
• [x] The last slide contains a good and concise take-home message
• [ ] The speakers engage with the audience
• [ ] The speakers are fun, have humour or the protocol contains an Easter egg
• [x] The slides do not have too much text

Bonus

• [ ] Bonus: Verification beyond testing (mutation testing with Gambit, formal verification)
• [x] Bonus: The protocol has 100% statement coverage <-- statement coverage via hardhat
• [ ] Bonus: Fuzzing/symbolic execution: the protocol has a harness for fuzzing or symbolic execution <-- Echidna
• [ ] Bonus: Protocol is deployed on mainnet and IPFS
• [ ] Bonus the protocol contains user interface application <-- with react/or template stuff