Not compatible with .net standard

[ForgeColeColon]

https://github.com/Cinchoo/ChoETL.NACHA/blob/a48e7d37e07abae3608a714c439f289764edf1ab/ChoETL.NACHA.Core/ChoETL.NACHA.NETStandard.csproj#L5

This is targetting .net core, not .net standard. The moment you try to instantiate NachaWriter in a .netstandard library, it errors with System.Runtime incompatibility.

Took days to figure this out, because the name of the project is literally ChoETL.NACHA.NetStandard. Should be NetCore.

[chatbot702107]

So, are you saying you were able to fix the problem? Could you tell me a little more details about your code and which version of .NET you are using?

[ForgeColeColon]

Sure. I have a .csproj targeting netstandard2.0. I am not able to use NACHA.NetStandard because it is targetting netcoreapp2.1. If NACHA.NetStandard was targetting netstandard2.0, then it would be compatible with .net45, netstandard2.0, and all net core frameworks. I thought that might have been your goal with this version, but i could be wrong. So i was just throwing it out there that this is currently not compatible with netstandard2.0 projects.

[chatbot702107]

hmmm, do you know if its compatible with anything like .NET6, .NET 7 or .NET 8? Based on what you said, it sounds like its only meant to work with those older deprecated frameworks...and not the new .NET stuff??

Thanks for responding so quickly.

[ForgeColeColon]

Yes it is. This was what my work around was. Since the .csproj I was using it in was netstandard2.0, I had to create a new project in net6.0 and install NACHA.NetStandard there in order to keep my other project in netstandard2.0 for nuget packaging reasons.

[ForgeColeColon]

Pasted simple project i just created targeting netstandard2.0 on how to reproduce.

[chatbot702107]

I was bummed when my brand new .NET 8 project blew up when trying to use this ChoETL.Nacha nuget package in visual studio 2022. The C# code came from a .net 4.6.1 (4.6.2?) project that has worked fine for a while now. And after making the syntax changes to the .NET8 code, I tried to debug it and it blew up. Dang, it sounds like it might not be a lost cause.

I am so glad you are posting some stuff here. thank you!!!

[ForgeColeColon]

[ForgeColeColon]

I believe if you just make the following change to your .csproj

<TargetFramework>netstandard2.0</TargetFramework>

everything should be fine. Would you mind trying it?

[chatbot702107]

Oh wait a sec....the csproj file is set to<TargetFramework>net8.0</TargetFramework> since I created a brand new .NET8 project in visual studio, and just moved the old code into the new .NET8 project.

Because I wanted to move the old code into .NET8 while still using this choETL.NACHA. So when I changed target framework like this <TargetFramework>netstandard2.0</TargetFramework>

Then the compiler blows up, since there are .NET8 syntax/code changes made to some parts of the code (just like loops, declarations stuff like that, but the NACHA code didnt get changed yet).

So I am wondering if I can use this and still get this ChoETL.Nacha to work with: <TargetFramework>net8.0</TargetFramework>

[ForgeColeColon]

i meant the ChoETL.NACHA.NETStandard.csproj should be netstandard2.0. that will fix problems with all projects referencing it.

[chatbot702107]

i meant the ChoETL.NACHA.NETStandard.csproj should be netstandard2.0. that will fix problems with all projects referencing it.

so are you talking about downloading the code (including the ChoETL.NACHA.NETStandard.csproj ) from github (not the nuget package that I am referencing now) and changing that target framework in that downloaded github code to be like this <TargetFramework>netstandard2.0</TargetFramework> and then recompile that code and use it in the .NET8 project?

PS Also, I opened up that file and see this:

[ForgeColeColon]

correct, the netcoreapp2.1 is why it is currently not working.

[chatbot702107]

OK, I see. Normally I dont download and use directly from github, since visual studio has some nuget packages available for the ChoETL stuff. But in this case, I see there is the sln file in github, and the files and folders etc. So I will give that a shot, download all of it, then (make the change) and recompile it in Visual studio.
PS Any thought on which version of vs.net I should use for compiling it?

Thanks!

[ForgeColeColon]

Yeah, sorry, i thought you were the code owner trying to fix this issue. This package works for me in .net 6. What breaks in .net 8?

[chatbot702107]

ahh, nope not owner. Just a new user and it sounded like you were having maybe similar problem, so i thought I should at least ask. I am thinking if its working for your .NET 6, then it should hopefully work for me too in .NET8. That would be very good!

I posted an issue here. Basically it dies as soon as it tries to execute this in the for loop foreach (var data in new ChoNACHAReader(filename)) https://github.com/Cinchoo/ChoETL.NACHA/issues/57

[ForgeColeColon]

try this: var builder = new StringBuilder(File.ReadAllText(fileName)); foreach (var data in new ChoNACHAReader(builder)) {

        }

[chatbot702107]

thanks. Will give it a try and let you know. :-)

[ForgeColeColon]

Did that end up working? I believe it should have, cause it bypasses the GetEncoding call that was causing your error.

[chatbot702107]

Thanks again!.....So, been testing it, seems to have worked. Need to do more testing tomorrow though. I am wondering why GetEncoding was blowing up. Did you encounter issues with it blowing up in your .NET 6 app?