ClassicWoWCommunity / cata-classic-bugs

This is a place for Cataclysm & Wrath of the Lich King Classic bug reports and research
66 stars 6 forks source link

Earthbind not affected by spell penetration #1396

Open traktorch0 opened 5 months ago

traktorch0 commented 5 months ago

1. Current Behavior

1.1. Description

currently earthbind is not affected by spell penetration so it can resist if u are facing a target with nature resistance even if you are above the spell penetration cap

1.2. How to Reproduce

     place earthbind while wearing above 200 spell penetration and use it against a target with some spell penetration like shaman wearing healing stream glyph (195 spell pen) or resto druid buff mark of the wild and you will ocasionally see resists

1.3 Source Material

https://gyazo.com/5a860b9def75f57893aa8c991edd10ab you can see it resisting while im wearing 200 spell penetration https://gyazo.com/32c8201d6a6e0ec8e69387c195637177 https://gyazo.com/8bbbb4f607018752ebb0d3c456ebb4f4 and the shaman having 195 nature resistance

2. Expected Behavior

it shouldnt resist if you having higher spell penetration than nature resistance

Xar22 commented 5 months ago

Saw this happen to me where Earthbind would resist even on targets with no resistance at all. Worth looking into

raethkcj commented 5 months ago

For additional context, this also affects Searing Totem. Here are two logs of a level 85 Shaman's Searing Totem attacking a level 80 Shaman with Elemental Resistance Totem active (130 Fire Resistance at level 80). In the first encounter, the level 85 player is wearing 0 Spell Penetration. In the second, the level 85 attacker is wearing 150 Spell Penetration, which should bring the target's resistance to 0:

https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/J3pR28XwQrhg1Nm9#fight=1&type=damage-taken&source=1&view=events https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/J3pR28XwQrhg1Nm9#fight=2&type=damage-taken&source=1&view=events

However, both encounters show the same amount of partial resists.

Pets began inheriting their owner's Spell Penetration in Patch 3.2.0:

All pets now receive 40% of their master's resilience and 100% of their master's spell penetration. In addition, if a player is at their appropriate spell hit chance or hit chance maximum, their pet will be at the maximum for spell hit chance, hit chance, and expertise. If they are below the maximum, their pet will be proportionately below those maximums.

SimonBpvp commented 4 months ago

I noticed similar issue with druid mushrooms. They always say 'resist' when you detonate them, no matter what. But I don't know if this is related

Artemishowl commented 3 months ago

Ticket created o7