Closed pierretoussing closed 4 years ago
In the nature paper, they used the following time shifts:
1-2 months
2-4 months
4-8 months
8-16 months
16-32 months
32-64 months
64-128 months
@pierretoussing What is the interpretation of the delay ranges, e.g. 1-2, 2-4? Does it make sense in our case to define delay in that way?
@pawelbielski The delay ranges in the nature paper mean that they used all of this delays for the similarity computation e.g 2-4 means they used the delays 2, 3, and 4 for this one map. This has something to do with the similarity measures they used: Wavelet multi-scale correlation. This measure is designed for such this purpose. Using standard similarity measures, we would then have to define a method to combine the similarity values for 2, 3 and 4 months in order to combine them into one value for the delay range 2-4 months. So using standard similarity measures (and also implementing the approach Peter suggested), we define the time delays as a simple integer and then shift the whole map by this delay. I used 1, 3 and 12 months as delays. It means that the similarity is computed between the actual reference series and the whole map shifted by the respective time delay. I used the mean as fill value to assure the time series still have the same length (to avoid problems with similarity calculations). This delays act as example, I don't know if they are meaningful or if we should use other delays? I thought that the climate scientists would provide us with the delays they want to look at.
Peter suggested that it would be better to drop points in order to keep the length of the time series equal, than filling up with the mean.
Another possibility is to look for dependencies over time.
[x] Write a function that computes the similarity of the reference series to the data shifted by a given amount of time. It takes in a list of integers that indicate how much to shift the data. The output is a plot with the similarity maps for each time shift in one column.
[x] Look at the nature paper for relevant time shifts (1 month, 3 months, 12 months,...)