ClinGen / clincoded

This GCI/VCI 1.0 platform has now been retired, and replaced with our new 2.0 platform:
https://github.com/ClinGen/gene-and-variant-curation-tools/issues
MIT License
25 stars 9 forks source link

Provisional Classification Summary - Case Level Evidence #1411

Closed jimmyzhen closed 6 years ago

jimmyzhen commented 7 years ago

Create a table view for all Case Level evidence (Individual evidence primarily since other types of evidence can't be scored) associated with the provisional classification.

Table header title "Genetic Evidence: Case Level (variants, segregation)

Table columns include:

  1. Variant type
  2. Variant
  3. Reference
  4. Sex
  5. Age
  6. Ethnicity
  7. Phenotypes
  8. Associations
  9. Segregations (sub-column - Number of affected, Number of unaffected, LOD score)
  10. Previous testing
  11. Methods of detection
  12. Score (sub-column - Proband (default), Seg)

Sortable columns include:

  1. Variant type
  2. Variant
  3. Reference

Could they also include:

  1. Sex
  2. Age
  3. Ethnicity
  4. Methods of detection
  5. Score (depending on east of implementation)
selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen a bug 🐛 (dang): When "No Modification" become new value as the new Calculated Classification = last saved and I save without modifying, it saves as "No Modification" 🙀

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 4 04 13 pm

Great catch! 🎣

selinad commented 7 years ago

Change this blue text (in above screenshot) slightly: "Heads up! The Last Saved Classification below is based on the matrix above. You can edit this Classification based on the same Matrix, view the Evidence Summary page for it, or return to the Record Curation page." to "Heads up! The Last Saved Classification (below) is based on the above Classification Matrix. You may edit it by selecting "Edit Classification," click "Evidence Summary" to view all evidence associated with it, or return to the record by clicking "Record Curation page."

selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen @wrightmw do you think the red note should be here when you edit a classification (above one) and the setting is No Modification?

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 4 19 21 pm

selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen notice above that when I went to edit the one that incorrectly saved as "No Modification," it shows last saved as "Moderate" (see above comment screenshot)

selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen @wrightmw: should we add a note by the Print PDF button on Evidence Summary?

e.g. For best printing, choose "Landscape" for layout, 50% for Scale, "Minimum" for Margins, and select "Background graphics"

jimmyzhen commented 7 years ago

@selinad I am fine with adding such note.

selinad commented 7 years ago

@wrightmw @jimmyzhen I pounded some more -- looks great. Scored some of @wrightmw's data too, which I'd forgotten to do previously and everything behaves. A future request could be to enter curator associated with evidence (let's see if that will be something that is desired after they use it a bit). 👍 great job!

wrightmw commented 7 years ago

Me too @selinad wrt to the note about best printing option,

jimmyzhen commented 7 years ago

@selinad @wrightmw I have updated the same instance with the latest requested changes. Please give it another round of testing. Thanks!

selinad commented 7 years ago

Hi @jimmyzhen

Thanks for the updated instance!

[removed as I was confused]

selinad commented 7 years ago

[removed as I was confused]

@jimmyzhen I apologize, but I think the note I put in red was confusing:

"If you would like to 1) save the new "Calculated Classification" highlighted in blue or 2) change your Last Saved Classification value based on this new "Calculated Classification" value, make sure to edit the highlighted fields and click Save. You may also choose to mark your Classification as Provisional."

Can you please change to:
"Click Save to save the Calculated Classification (highlighted in blue) without modification, or modify the Classification value in the pull-down and hit Save. You may also choose to mark your Classification as Provisional."

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 9 48 16 pm
selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen -- I believe we can shorten the yellow message from:

"The Total Points shown above is based on the the set of saved evidence and accompanying scores that existed when the "View Classification Matrix" button was clicked. To save a Classification for this Gene Disease Record based on this evidence, please see the section below. Otherwise, click "Cancel" to return to your previous page."

to

"The Total Points shown above are based on the the set of saved evidence and accompanying scores existing when the "View Classification Matrix" button was clicked. To save a Classification for this Gene Disease Record based on this evidence, please see the section below."

wrightmw commented 7 years ago

@selinad I just took a screenshot of that! But happy for text to change ;-)

selinad commented 7 years ago

@wrightmw -- screenshot of what? :)

wrightmw commented 7 years ago

@selinad The Classification Matrix tables...but I'm obviously fine with text changes.

selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen so sorry -- text change to blue one as well:

"The Last Saved Classification (above) is based on the above Classification Matrix. You may edit it by selecting "Edit Classification," click "Evidence Summary" to view all evidence associated with it, or return to the record by clicking "Record Curation page."

to

"Select "Edit Classification" to edit the Last Saved Classification or click "Evidence Summary" to view all evidence associated with the saved Classification. If you don't wish to save, click "Record Curation page" to add more evidence."

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 10 43 37 pm

@wrightmw sorry --I think you are working on the help doc. Could you put a placeholder in those spots? thx.

selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen I like the new red text here. Any chance it could span more width? (e.g. start closer to the left). If not, no worries!

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 10 47 07 pm
selinad commented 7 years ago

@wrightmw do you think this message needs to be in red? I feel like it should be in blue...

screen shot 2017-10-11 at 10 49 33 pm
selinad commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen all is working great! Apologies for my original confusion, which my own text caused. The bug 🐛 is gone. If you are able to make the text changes, that would be great. The only other thing I might do is change the red text (above) to blue -- it is not so much a warning as instructions, although happy for @wrightmw to weigh in.

Thank you! Really. Great. Job.

snehitp commented 7 years ago

Go to bed, guys.

jimmyzhen commented 7 years ago

@selinad @wrightmw I've addressed the latest round of changes and updated the same instance. Please feel free to review it again.

Meanwhile, I will start the process of bringing up a release candidate.

wrightmw commented 7 years ago

@jimmyzhen Thanks so much for this work. Above and beyond! @selinad No worries, re. keep changing all the texts... we can always update any changed figures later. As for the blue vs red text debate, it should be blue because it's instructional rather than a warning ... but I don't think this should delay a release candidate.

selinad commented 7 years ago

Hi @jimmyzhen -- thank you! All the text changes look great. I appreciate the changes -- they are so much clearer for the user.

Also, thx @wrightmw -- @jimmyzhen has made it blue in his updates. Looks great!

@jimmyzhen I think it's good to go!

jimmyzhen commented 6 years ago

Included in R13 release.