search

Cloud-CV / Origami

:unlock: :key: :closed_lock_with_key: Origami: Artificial Intelligence as a Service
171 stars 108 forks source link

Enable user to give feedback to the demo owner. #198

Open gupta-utkarsh opened 6 years ago

gupta-utkarsh commented 6 years ago
vpn1997 commented 6 years ago

Hey rather than one to one feedback , I think we should provide something like a comment section where users can give their reviews ,ask their doubts etc which should be visible to other users as well as to the demo creator. :smile:

gupta-utkarsh commented 6 years ago

@deshraj What do you think about this?

vpn1997 commented 6 years ago

@uttu357 hey can i work on this ? Clicking on comment button will take us to comment section.

screenshot 4

fristonio commented 6 years ago

My thoughts on this are :

deshraj commented 6 years ago

I would like to go with the idea of threads like comments rather than one to one feedback.

@fristonio I agree with your point that we should keep the comments in threads.

For the implementation, I think it would be better to have a sidebar having the comment threads, this sidebar can have hidden and visible state. S rather than a comment button we will have a comment icon on top right corner which on clicking will open the sliding sidebar on the right, making everything else out of focus.

Instead of putting the comments in the sidebar, I think we should put the comments section at the bottom on the demo instead of putting it in the sidebar. Not everyone wants to see the comments related to a demo. People are more interested in seeing the demo. We can utilize the sidebar for something else like showing other details/analytics or something else.

Starring the demo should come under origami-insights section and I am currently working on it.

Starring the demo can come on the main demo page itself on the top similar to github.

There should not be upvote downvote or stars feature for comment. We should keep it as simple as it can be with the sole purpose of feedback.

Yeah, I agree. Lets keep it simple.

fristonio commented 6 years ago

Instead of putting the comments in the sidebar, I think we should put the comments section at the bottom on the demo instead of putting it in the sidebar. Not everyone wants to see the comments related to a demo. People are more interested in seeing the demo. We can utilize the sidebar for something else like showing other details/analytics or something else.

I was thinking that a separate view like a portal or something would be better suited for analytics. For the comment section, since the two sections(demo and comments) are better off separate I thought that we can have a different section entirely for comments which do not interfere with the flow of the demo. Though the flow you described also seems like a good approach and we can work on those lines too. :)

gupta-utkarsh commented 6 years ago

@vpn1997 @fristonio I would like you to complete the work you are doing currently before taking up another issue. Plus adding new features is not the priority. Fixing UI bugs and making UI stable is. It would be preferable if that is completed first so that we have a stable Origami application before we start adding new features.

deshraj commented 6 years ago

I totally agree with @uttu357 that we should try to complete the existing moving parts and get them done and make the project more stable before start implementing new features. Let's make sure that we are more focused on improving the current project instead of adding new features.

deshraj commented 6 years ago

@vpn1997 the features that you are suggesting are really good but they are overkill at the moment. We should first try to have basic complete functionalities and then, later on, we can try to add more things on top of it.

Isha1233 commented 2 weeks ago

I'm thinking to implement :- Feedback Form:

Dashboard for Demo Owners:

Optional Features: