search

Cloudslab / cloudsim

CloudSim: A Framework For Modeling And Simulation Of Cloud Computing Infrastructures And Services
http://www.cloudbus.org/cloudsim/
807 stars 488 forks source link

******** Many errors in the code, and the future of this project? ******** #121

Open douglasleer opened 5 years ago

douglasleer commented 5 years ago

After looking into the code of this project, I found many errors/bugs, just like all the people that have already reported many issues/errors/bugs.

The errors/bugs definitely affect the correctness of the simulation results. The reported issues are not resolved and the limited pull requests are not accepted.

Besides, the latest update of the project was 2 years ago. It seems that this project lacks too much support from the original authors and the community.

Anyone has any idea on how to make it a reliable toolkit?

itconsultore commented 5 years ago

the idea is to make forks and if someone finds an error then work in the fork, test it, check with the community (a couple of reviewers) and then apply for a push request.

I check something in 2016 for my thesis, found some errors and improvement, but one test didn't pass. I couldn't find the cause, because it was more in deep.

Best wishes, Francisco

On Fri, Aug 17, 2018 at 9:01 AM, douglasleer notifications@github.com wrote:

After looking into the code of this project, I found many errors/bugs, just like all the people that have already reported many issues/errors/bugs.

The errors/bugs definitely affect the correctness of the simulation results. The reported issues are not resolved and the limited pull requests are not accepted.

Besides, the latest update of the project was 2 years ago. It seems that this project lacks too much support from the original authors and the community.

Anyone has any idea on how to make it a reliable toolkit?

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/Cloudslab/cloudsim/issues/121, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOnOzssEQySsFSJ6LPd2gsWSC5xBfvZxks5uRnhqgaJpZM4WBI4L .

AbderrahmanL commented 5 years ago

Go with cloudsim plus the developer supporting it is active, and it's more modular not spaghetti code like cloudsim (with all due respect and appreciation to cloudsim since it's the solid starting point) so it will be a bit easier to extend and contribute, not to mention that there are many fixes and features added to it .