search

Clozure / ccl

Clozure Common Lisp
http://ccl.clozure.com
Apache License 2.0
850 stars 103 forks source link

long form define-method-combination problem #492

Open yitzchak opened 4 months ago

yitzchak commented 4 months ago

CCL is unable to use the latest ansi-test because it fails in the long form of define-method-combination. The issue appears to be that long-form-define-method-combination uses destructuring-bind to parse the lambda list which is not sufficient since the lambda list to define-method-combination is not a destructuring lambda list, but an ordinary lambda list.

$ ccl --load doit.lsp 
;Compiler warnings for "home:Documents;git;ansi-test;auxiliary;ansi-aux.lsp.newest" :
;   Clause (SINGLE-FLOAT SINGLE-FLOAT-EPSILON) ignored in ETYPECASE form - shadowed by (SHORT-FLOAT SHORT-FLOAT-EPSILON) .
;   Clause (LONG-FLOAT LONG-FLOAT-EPSILON) ignored in ETYPECASE form - shadowed by (DOUBLE-FLOAT DOUBLE-FLOAT-EPSILON) .
;   Clause (SINGLE-FLOAT SINGLE-FLOAT-NEGATIVE-EPSILON) ignored in ETYPECASE form - shadowed by (SHORT-FLOAT SHORT-FLOAT-NEGATIVE-EPSILON) .
;   Clause (LONG-FLOAT LONG-FLOAT-NEGATIVE-EPSILON) ignored in ETYPECASE form - shadowed by (DOUBLE-FLOAT DOUBLE-FLOAT-NEGATIVE-EPSILON) .
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/eval-and-compile/declaration.lsp" :
;   In an anonymous lambda form inside an anonymous lambda form at position 847: Unused lexical variable C
;Compiler warnings for "home:Documents;git;ansi-test;data-and-control-flow;flet.lsp.newest" :
;   In (COMPILER-MACRO-FUNCTION FLET.74): Unused lexical variable FORM
;Compiler warnings for "home:Documents;git;ansi-test;data-and-control-flow;labels.lsp.newest" :
;   In (COMPILER-MACRO-FUNCTION LABELS.52): Unused lexical variable FORM
;Compiler warnings for "home:Documents;git;ansi-test;data-and-control-flow;macrolet.lsp.newest" :
;   In (COMPILER-MACRO-FUNCTION MACROLET.52): Unused lexical variable FORM
;Compiler warnings for "home:Documents;git;ansi-test;auxiliary;defclass-aux.lsp.newest" :
;   In DEFCLASS-WITH-TESTS: Unused lexical variable ALLOCATION
;   In DEFCLASS-WITH-TESTS: Unused lexical variable INITARG-LIST
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/with-slots.lsp" :
;   In (SLOT-UNBOUND (T WITH-SLOTS-CLASS-01 T)) inside an anonymous lambda form: Unused lexical variable SLOT-NAME
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" :
;   In an anonymous lambda form inside an anonymous lambda form at position 4336: Unused lexical variable IGNORED-METHODS
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" :
;   In an anonymous lambda form inside an anonymous lambda form at position 4336: IGNORABLE declaration for unknown variable IGNORED-METHODS
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" :
;   In an anonymous lambda form inside an anonymous lambda form at position 5414: Unused lexical variable IGNORED-METHODS
;Compiler warnings for "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" :
;   In an anonymous lambda form inside an anonymous lambda form at position 5414: IGNORABLE declaration for unknown variable IGNORED-METHODS
> Error: The value (Y1 :Y1 Y1-SUPPLIED) is not of the expected type SYMBOL.
> While executing: CCL::LONG-FORM-DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION, in process listener(1).
> Type :GO to continue, :POP to abort, :R for a list of available restarts.
> If continued: Skip loading "doit.lsp"
> Type :? for other options.
1 > :b
*(7F0D50A17380) : 0 (LONG-FORM-DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL ((METHOD-LIST *)) ((LIST* # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 402
 (7F0D50A17430) : 1 (FUNCALL #<Compiled-function DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION Macroexpander #x3000009AAF5F> (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL (#) (:ARGUMENTS X1 &OPTIONAL # &REST ...) ...) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 149
 (7F0D50A17460) : 2 (MACROEXPAND-1 (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL (#) (:ARGUMENTS X1 &OPTIONAL # &REST ...) ...) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 261
 (7F0D50A17490) : 3 (NX-TRANSFORM (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL (#) (:ARGUMENTS X1 &OPTIONAL # &REST ...) ...) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD> #<HASH-TABLE :TEST EQ size 903/1031 #x30200177733D>) 2453
 (7F0D50A17508) : 4 (NX-TRANSFORM-ARGLIST (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER '*DMC-LONG-11* (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL # # ...) NIL) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD> #<HASH-TABLE :TEST EQ size 903/1031 #x30200177733D>) 221
 (7F0D50A17568) : 5 (NX-TRANSFORM (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER '*DMC-LONG-11* (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL # # ...) NIL) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD> #<HASH-TABLE :TEST EQ size 903/1031 #x30200177733D>) 1013
 (7F0D50A175F0) : 6 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :RETURN (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER '*DMC-LONG-11* (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL # # ...) NIL) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 101
 (7F0D50A17620) : 7 (NX1-FORM :RETURN (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER '*DMC-LONG-11* (DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION MC-LONG-11 NIL # # ...) NIL) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 493
 (7F0D50A17688) : 8 (NX1-PROGN-BODY :RETURN ((CCL::%DEFPARAMETER # # NIL))) 405
 (7F0D50A176C8) : 9 (NX1-COMBINATION :RETURN (PROGN (EVAL-WHEN # #) (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER # # NIL)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 549
 (7F0D50A17730) : 10 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :RETURN (PROGN (EVAL-WHEN # #) (CCL::%DEFPARAMETER # # NIL)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 333
 (7F0D50A17788) : 11 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :RETURN (PROGN (DEFPARAMETER *DMC-LONG-11* #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 261
 (7F0D50A177E8) : 12 (NX1-FORM :RETURN (PROGN (DEFPARAMETER *DMC-LONG-11* #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 493
 (7F0D50A17850) : 13 (FUNCALL #'#<CCL::NX1-RETURN-FROM> :VALUE (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 581
 (7F0D50A178D0) : 14 (NX1-COMBINATION :VALUE (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 549
 (7F0D50A17938) : 15 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :VALUE (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 333
 (7F0D50A17990) : 16 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :VALUE (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 261
 (7F0D50A179F0) : 17 (NX1-FORM :VALUE (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEABD>) 493
 (7F0D50A17A58) : 18 (NX1-ENV-BODY :VALUE ((RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D> T) 189
 (7F0D50A17A90) : 19 (FUNCALL #'#<CCL::NX1-LET*> :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D>) 1221
 (7F0D50A17B88) : 20 (NX1-COMBINATION :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D>) 549
 (7F0D50A17BF0) : 21 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D>) 333
 (7F0D50A17C48) : 22 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :VALUE (LET (#) (DECLARE #) (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D>) 261
 (7F0D50A17CA8) : 23 (NX1-FORM :VALUE (LET (#) (DECLARE #) (RETURN-FROM #:G15340 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEB6D>) 493
 (7F0D50A17D10) : 24 (NX1-CATCH-BODY :VALUE ((LET # # #))) 213
 (7F0D50A17D58) : 25 (FUNCALL #'#<CCL::NX1-CATCH> :VALUE (CATCH #:G15341 (LET # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEEFD>) 205
 (7F0D50A17DA8) : 26 (NX1-COMBINATION :VALUE (CATCH #:G15341 (LET # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEEFD>) 549
 (7F0D50A17E10) : 27 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :VALUE (CATCH #:G15341 (LET # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEEFD>) 333
 (7F0D50A17E68) : 28 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :VALUE (CATCH #:G15341 (LET # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEEFD>) 261
 (7F0D50A17EC8) : 29 (NX1-FORM :VALUE (CATCH #:G15341 (LET # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FEEFD>) 493
 (7F0D50A17F30) : 30 (NX1-ENV-BODY :VALUE ((CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D> T) 189
 (7F0D50A17F68) : 31 (FUNCALL #'#<CCL::NX1-LET*> :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 1221
 (7F0D50A18060) : 32 (NX1-COMBINATION :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 549
 (7F0D50A180C8) : 33 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 333
 (7F0D50A18120) : 34 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 261
 (7F0D50A18180) : 35 (NX1-FORM :VALUE (LET* (#) (DECLARE #) (CATCH #:G15341 #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 493
 (7F0D50A181E8) : 36 (NX1-FORMLIST :RETURN ((LET* # # #))) 101
 (7F0D50A18220) : 37 (NX1-LAMBDA-BIND :RETURN (CONDITION) ((LET* # # #)) ((PRINC CONDITION) (TERPRI) (WHEN *REPORT-AND-IGNORE-ERRORS-BREAK* #) (VALUES NIL CONDITION)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 965
 (7F0D50A18368) : 38 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :RETURN ((LAMBDA # # # # ...) (LET* # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 333
 (7F0D50A183C0) : 39 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :RETURN ((LAMBDA # # # # ...) (LET* # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 261
 (7F0D50A18420) : 40 (NX1-FORM :RETURN ((LAMBDA # # # # ...) (LET* # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF24D>) 493
 (7F0D50A18488) : 41 (FUNCALL #'#<CCL::NX1-BLOCK> :RETURN (BLOCK #:G15340 (# #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF66D>) 613
 (7F0D50A18520) : 42 (NX1-COMBINATION :RETURN (BLOCK #:G15340 (# #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF66D>) 549
 (7F0D50A18588) : 43 (NX1-TRANSFORMED-FORM :RETURN (BLOCK #:G15340 (# #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF66D>) 333
 (7F0D50A185E0) : 44 (NX1-TYPED-FORM :RETURN (PROGN (LET NIL #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF66D>) 261
 (7F0D50A18640) : 45 (NX1-FORM :RETURN (PROGN (LET NIL #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF66D>) 493
 (7F0D50A186A8) : 46 (NX1-ENV-BODY :RETURN ((PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF70D> T) 189
 (7F0D50A186E0) : 47 (NX1-LAMBDA NIL ((PROGN #)) NIL) 1477
 (7F0D50A187B8) : 48 (NX1-COMPILE-LAMBDA NIL (LAMBDA NIL (PROGN #)) #<CCL::AFUNC #x3020019FF75D> NIL #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF82D> #<CCL:COMPILER-POLICY #x3020001D1A7D> NIL) 2373
 (7F0D50A18A70) : 49 (COMPILE-NAMED-FUNCTION (LAMBDA NIL (PROGN #)) :NAME NIL :ENV #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF9DD> :FUNCTION-NOTE #<SOURCE-NOTE "/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp":10584-10927 "(report-and-ignore-errors (defparameter *dmc-long-11* (define-method-combination mc-long-11 () ((method-list *)) (:argum..."> :KEEP-LAMBDA NIL :KEEP-SYMBOLS T :SOURCE-NOTES #<HASH-TABLE :TEST EQ size 903/1031 #x30200177733D>) 2733
 (7F0D50A18CF0) : 50 (CHEAP-EVAL-FUNCTION NIL (LAMBDA NIL (PROGN #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF9DD>) 229
 (7F0D50A18D20) : 51 (CHEAP-EVAL-IN-ENVIRONMENT (LET NIL (COMMON-LISP:HANDLER-CASE # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FF9DD>) 3205
 (7F0D50A18D48) : 52 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::PROGN-IN-ENV CCL::CHEAP-EVAL-IN-ENVIRONMENT)> ((REPORT-AND-IGNORE-ERRORS #) (REPORT-AND-IGNORE-ERRORS # # #)) #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020017773CD> #<CCL::LEXICAL-ENVIRONMENT #x3020019FFB7D>) 325
 (7F0D50A18D90) : 53 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM)>) 781
 (7F0D50A18E08) : 54 (CALL-WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT #<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE (:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM) #x7F0D7137D45F> :OVERRIDE NIL) 197
 (7F0D50A18E50) : 55 (LOAD-FROM-STREAM #<BASIC-FILE-CHARACTER-INPUT-STREAM ("/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp"/8 UTF-8) #x302001777E8D> NIL) 397
 (7F0D50A18E90) : 56 (%LOAD #P"/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" NIL NIL :ERROR :DEFAULT NIL) 5565
 (7F0D50A18FD8) : 57 (LOAD "define-method-combination-long-form.lsp" :VERBOSE NIL :PRINT NIL :IF-DOES-NOT-EXIST :ERROR :EXTERNAL-FORMAT :DEFAULT :PRESERVE-OPTIMIZATION-SETTINGS NIL) 1061
 (7F0D50A19080) : 58 (FUNCALL #'#<Anonymous Function #x30200148E63F>) 1597
 (7F0D50A190A8) : 59 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM)>) 781
 (7F0D50A19120) : 60 (CALL-WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT #<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE (:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM) #x7F0D7137D7AF> :OVERRIDE NIL) 197
 (7F0D50A19168) : 61 (LOAD-FROM-STREAM #<BASIC-FILE-CHARACTER-INPUT-STREAM ("/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/load.lsp"/7 UTF-8) #x30200144BFFD> NIL) 397
 (7F0D50A191A8) : 62 (%LOAD #P"/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/objects/load.lsp" NIL NIL :ERROR :DEFAULT NIL) 5565
 (7F0D50A192F0) : 63 (LOAD "objects/load.lsp" :VERBOSE NIL :PRINT NIL :IF-DOES-NOT-EXIST :ERROR :EXTERNAL-FORMAT :DEFAULT :PRESERVE-OPTIMIZATION-SETTINGS NIL) 1061
 (7F0D50A19398) : 64 (CALL-CHECK-REGS LOAD "objects/load.lsp") 229
 (7F0D50A193D0) : 65 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM)>) 781
 (7F0D50A19448) : 66 (CALL-WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT #<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE (:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM) #x7F0D7137DB2F> :OVERRIDE NIL) 197
 (7F0D50A19490) : 67 (LOAD-FROM-STREAM #<BASIC-FILE-CHARACTER-INPUT-STREAM ("/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/gclload2.lsp"/6 UTF-8) #x30200115C9CD> NIL) 397
 (7F0D50A194D0) : 68 (%LOAD #P"/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/gclload2.lsp" NIL NIL :ERROR :DEFAULT NIL) 5565
 (7F0D50A19618) : 69 (LOAD "gclload2.lsp" :VERBOSE NIL :PRINT NIL :IF-DOES-NOT-EXIST :ERROR :EXTERNAL-FORMAT :DEFAULT :PRESERVE-OPTIMIZATION-SETTINGS NIL) 1061
 (7F0D50A196C0) : 70 (FUNCALL #'#<Anonymous Function #x302000E82C1F>) 853
 (7F0D50A196F0) : 71 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM)>) 781
 (7F0D50A19768) : 72 (CALL-WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT #<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE (:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM) #x7F0D7137DE7F> :OVERRIDE NIL) 197
 (7F0D50A197B0) : 73 (LOAD-FROM-STREAM #<BASIC-FILE-CHARACTER-INPUT-STREAM ("/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/init.lsp"/5 UTF-8) #x302000E7D33D> NIL) 397
 (7F0D50A197F0) : 74 (%LOAD #P"/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/init.lsp" NIL NIL :ERROR :DEFAULT NIL) 5565
 (7F0D50A19938) : 75 (LOAD "init.lsp" :VERBOSE NIL :PRINT NIL :IF-DOES-NOT-EXIST :ERROR :EXTERNAL-FORMAT :DEFAULT :PRESERVE-OPTIMIZATION-SETTINGS NIL) 1061
 (7F0D50A199E0) : 76 (FUNCALL #'#<Anonymous Function #x302000E7D7AF>) 269
 (7F0D50A19A18) : 77 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM)>) 781
 (7F0D50A19A90) : 78 (CALL-WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT #<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE (:INTERNAL CCL::WITH-COMPILATION-UNIT-BODY CCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM) #x7F0D7137E1CF> :OVERRIDE NIL) 197
 (7F0D50A19AD8) : 79 (LOAD-FROM-STREAM #<BASIC-FILE-CHARACTER-INPUT-STREAM ("/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/doit.lsp"/4 UTF-8) #x302000E7F1AD> NIL) 397
 (7F0D50A19B18) : 80 (%LOAD #P"/home/yitzi/Documents/git/ansi-test/doit.lsp" NIL NIL :ERROR :DEFAULT NIL) 5565
 (7F0D50A19C60) : 81 (LOAD "doit.lsp" :VERBOSE NIL :PRINT NIL :IF-DOES-NOT-EXIST :ERROR :EXTERNAL-FORMAT :DEFAULT :PRESERVE-OPTIMIZATION-SETTINGS NIL) 1061
 (7F0D50A19D08) : 82 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::LOAD-FILE CCL::STARTUP-CCL)> "doit.lsp") 501
 (7F0D50A19D50) : 83 (STARTUP-CCL ("home:ccl-init" "home:\\.ccl-init")) 1773
 (7F0D50A19DB0) : 84 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL (CCL:TOPLEVEL-FUNCTION (CCL::LISP-DEVELOPMENT-SYSTEM T)))>) 69
 (7F0D50A19DD0) : 85 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::MAKE-MCL-LISTENER-PROCESS)>) 661
 (7F0D50A19E68) : 86 (RUN-PROCESS-INITIAL-FORM #<TTY-LISTENER listener(1) [Active] #x302000482EBD> (#<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE # #x3020004829EF>)) 717
 (7F0D50A19EF0) : 87 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL (CCL::%PROCESS-PRESET-INTERNAL (CCL:PROCESS)))> #<TTY-LISTENER listener(1) [Active] #x302000482EBD> (#<CCL:COMPILED-LEXICAL-CLOSURE # #x3020004829EF>)) 581
 (7F0D50A19F98) : 88 (FUNCALL #'#<(:INTERNAL CCL::THREAD-MAKE-STARTUP-FUNCTION)>) 277
1 >
xrme commented 4 months ago

For ease of reference, copied from https://gitlab.common-lisp.net/ansi-test/ansi-test/-/blob/master/objects/define-method-combination-long-form.lsp?ref_type=heads#L316

(defparameter *dmc-long-11*
  (define-method-combination mc-long-11 () ((method-list *))
    (:arguments x1 &optional (y1 :y1 y1-supplied) &rest r1 &key (z1 :z1 z1-supplied))
    `(vector ,x1 ,y1 ,y1-supplied ,r1 ,z1 ,z1-supplied
             ,@(mapcar #'(lambda (m) `(call-method ,m)) method-list))))

(defgeneric dmc-long-gf-11a () (:method-combination mc-long-11))
(defgeneric dmc-long-gf-11b (x1 &optional y1 &key z1) (:method-combination mc-long-11))
(defgeneric dmc-long-gf-11c (x1 &optional y1 &rest r1) (:method-combination mc-long-11))
xrme commented 4 months ago

We're checking that the lambda list in (:arguments . lambda-list) contains all symbols for some reason. https://github.com/Clozure/ccl/blob/3cdcedae9f8097eb2b2dafc06746a69a8cb23642/lib/method-combination.lisp#L569-L576 If I remove that check, then it looks like many of the tests mentioned above work (but at least one fails).

yitzchak commented 4 months ago

Yes, that appears to make the tests load for me also. They crash later in the UPGRADED-ARRAY-ELEMENT-TYPE tests, but that is probably unrelated.

yitzchak commented 4 months ago

The test that is causing a crash for me is UPGRADED-ARRAY-ELEMENT-TYPE.NIL.1. On failure it prints a list of objects that fail a type predicate. One of the objects in *universe* is causing the printer to crash. I temporarily disabled the print in that test and got the following failures. So yes, your fix makes the tests load.

65 failures with 65 unexpected failures and 0 unexpected successes out of 21923 tests.
Failures: 
  MACROLET.36
  LOOP.1.39
  LOOP.1.40
  LOOP.1.41
  LOOP.1.42
  LOOP.1.43
  CLASS-04.ERROR.5
  MAKE-LOAD-FORM.ORDER.8
  MAKE-LOAD-FORM.ORDER.13
  MAKE-LOAD-FORM.ORDER.14
  DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION-LONG.11.3
  DEFINE-METHOD-COMBINATION-LONG.11.4
  MAKE-CONDITION.3
  MAKE-CONDITION.4
  UPGRADED-ARRAY-ELEMENT-TYPE.8
  UPGRADED-ARRAY-ELEMENT-TYPE.NIL.1
  EXP.ERROR.8
  EXP.ERROR.9
  EXP.ERROR.10
  EXP.ERROR.11
  EXPT.ERROR.8
  EXPT.ERROR.9
  EXPT.ERROR.10
  EXPT.ERROR.11
  MAP.ERROR.11
  SUBTYPEP.CONS.43
  SUBTYPEP.CONS.44
  SUBTYPEP-COMPLEX.8
  STRING.FOLD.1
  CHAR-UPCASE.2
  CHAR-DOWNCASE.2
  PARSE-NAMESTRING.5
  ENSURE-DIRECTORIES-EXIST.8
  STREAM-ELEMENT-TYPE.2
  STREAM-ELEMENT-TYPE.3
  READ-BYTE.4
  FILE-LENGTH.4
  FILE-LENGTH.5
  FILE-POSITION.8
  OPEN.OUTPUT.19
  OPEN.IO.19
  PRINT-UNREADABLE-OBJECT.2
  FORMAT.F.5
  FORMAT.F.8
  FORMAT.F.45
  FORMATTER.F.45
  FORMAT.F.46
  FORMATTER.F.46
  FORMAT.F.47
  FORMATTER.F.47
  FORMAT.E.1
  FORMAT.E.2
  FORMAT.E.3
  FORMAT.E.4
  FORMAT.E.5
  FORMAT.E.7
  FORMAT.E.8
  FORMAT.E.9
  FORMAT.E.26
  FORMAT.JUSTIFY.33
  FORMAT.JUSTIFY.34
  FORMAT.JUSTIFY.36
  SET-SYNTAX-FROM-CHAR.SHARP.1
  SYNTAX.SHARP-COLON.ERROR.1
  COMPILE-FILE.16