search

CodeDead / DeadLock

Unlock files and folders!
https://codedead.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
138 stars 23 forks source link

Portable version #4

Open r15ch13 opened 7 years ago

r15ch13 commented 7 years ago

Hi, will the next release also include a portable version? I would like to add DeadLock to Scoop as an replacement for Unlocker (https://github.com/lukesampson/scoop-extras/issues/356). A simple .zip or .7z file would be easier to install than the current setup executable. :smile:

CodeDead commented 7 years ago

Definitely! We've discussed software portability in a blog post here: http://codedead.com/?p=1294

r15ch13 commented 7 years ago

Nice! Watching the repo to add it as soon it's released 👍

CodeDead commented 6 years ago

This will be made possible in the upcoming WPF remake!

BinToss commented 2 years ago

As far as I know, a .NET portable app can be made in two ways with a stable SDK release: A. Require the system already have .NET Framework and its dependencies. Framework 4.8 is pre-installed and continually updated on most Windows systems. It can run .NET Framework apps compiled for any previous 4.x runtime with minor differences where the API had a breaking change. I an imagine that some domain/organization-managed systems might not have the Framework installed for NUCs. B. The app is published its own copy of the .NET runtime via Self-Contained.

[One problem with the latter is trim-incompatibility] of WPF and WinForms](https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/core/deploying/trimming/incompatibilities). Without IL trimming, the entire .NET Runtime is included with the build artifacts and leads to a 100MiB+ deployment. This might change with .NET 7 .NET 8(?) if these libraries are updated to use trim-compatible code.

Note: .NET 7 appears to be introducing native-code Ahead Of Time compilation. I haven't looked into it enough to know if the resulting assemblies could be considered portable or if they would still have platform-specific runtime prerequisites.

Symbai commented 2 years ago

NET 7 appears to be introducing native-code Ahead Of Time compilation.

WPF does not support AOT and it's very unclear if it will be supported in the future at all. Winforms support AOT unofficial with some workarounds according to users. Avalonia (WPF-like cross platform UI) however supports AOT already. Unfortunately the portable AOT version of an Avalonia app is quite big in size.

CodeDead commented 2 years ago

I'm thinking more of a radically different approach. In the sense that something like Tauri + Rust and a React frontend are perfectly capable of providing small binaries, which are portable, in addition to providing the same (or slightly different) user interface that our users are already used to. It would completely remove the requirement of .NET and be modern and maintainable.

A dotnet library for DeadLock could also be made available, and I'm working on one right now for developers as a NuGet package.