CodeForPhilly / chime

COVID-19 Hospital Impact Model for Epidemics
https://codeforphilly.github.io/chime/
MIT License
205 stars 151 forks source link

#560 Limit forecasting window to one month #561

Closed mangalap123 closed 4 years ago

mangalap123 commented 4 years ago

Limit forecasting window to one month #560 Setting "number of days to project" min is 1, max is 30

Link to issue

Changelog entry

Additional info


Pull Request Checklist

For Reviewer

DougManuel commented 4 years ago

I couldn't find the reason for this change. It will be difficult for us and I expect others who use the app for longer range counterfactual examples of the effectiveness of social distancing.

BrianThomasRoss commented 4 years ago

I couldn't find the reason for this change. It will be difficult for us and I expect others who use the app for longer range counterfactual examples of the effectiveness of social distancing.

Hi there, @DougManuel so I would encourage you to check out the repository here.

My basic understanding, and I'd welcome correction by members of the Penn team if I'm handing out bad information, is that currently they have parameters being utilized by the model that essentially represent a single snapshot in time. Using that snapshot a forecast is then generated by using those limited points to outline generally course that could be expected from the "snapshot". So I think of this like trying to do facial recognition with a very low quality video camera.

The model at the repo linked above makes tremendous strides in improving the accuracy and utility of the forecasts.

DougManuel commented 4 years ago

Thanks for the explanation. From a user's perspective, what has been helpful from this repo's model has been for us has been:

The effect of social distancing dwarfs all other parameters outside the R0, etc. There are many models available that focus on various improvements, but all models come to the same conclusion about the role of social distancing.