CodeYourFuture / tech-products-demo

Example app for tech products interview experiment
https://tech-products-demo-d1182e30f280.herokuapp.com/
ISC License
3 stars 20 forks source link

Add resource details page #41

Closed Ikamrava closed 4 months ago

Ikamrava commented 4 months ago

This is a:

Description

Add resource details page

Links

Link to the Page

Description

Add filter based on resource topic

Links

Link to the Page

Author checklist

Ikamrava commented 4 months ago

I have added a resource details page based on the screen shot provided. Purpose : See the details of every resource . How to check: By clicking the title of the resource in the main page, you should be able to see the details Link to the Page

I have added a new feature : Filter resources by topic Purpose : filter the resource list by topic How to check: I have added a drop down list where you should be able to see the topics and by selecting the topic the content should be filtered. Link to the Page

Ikamrava commented 4 months ago

Hi @Ikamrava , can you please fill in the template of your PR. It is there for a reason.

I have done it to the best of my knowledge :)

kfklein15 commented 4 months ago

Hi @Ikamrava , can you please fill in the template of your PR. It is there for a reason.

I have done it to the best of my knowledge :)

I am still missing 2 fields on it: Purpose - How to check -

Can you fill these in, please?

Ikamrava commented 4 months ago

Hi @Ikamrava , can you please fill in the template of your PR. It is there for a reason.

I have done it to the best of my knowledge :)

I am still missing 2 fields on it: Purpose - How to check -

Can you fill these in, please?

Should I add them to the PR comment ?

kfklein15 commented 4 months ago

I have added a new feature : Filter resources by topic Purpose : filter the resource list by topic How to check: I have added a drop down list where you should be able to see the topics and by selecting the topic the content should be filtered. Link to the Page

Thanks. Can you please add this directly to your template?

textbook commented 4 months ago

Please edit the PR description to complete the template content, as requested above - which issue are you implementing, how should someone check that it is working correctly? Otherwise review cannot proceed.

Also please note that all feature PRs should be based on and target the main branch - feature/resource-page is only for the "Review a PR" task. It looks like you're also doing #18, in which case it's especially inappropriate to build on top of feature/resource-page - did it not seem odd that the resource details page was already there?

textbook commented 4 months ago

@farzaneh-haghani this is not the PR you're supposed to be reviewing. You need to create a PR in your fork from feature/resource-page to main, then review it there. You should see just a single commit, authored by me.

Ikamrava commented 4 months ago

Please edit the PR description to complete the template content, as requested above - which issue are you implementing, how should someone check that it is working correctly? Otherwise review cannot proceed.

Also please note that all feature PRs should be based on and target the main branch - feature/resource-page is only for the "Review a PR" task. It looks like you're also doing #18, in which case it's especially inappropriate to build on top of feature/resource-page - did it not seem odd that the resource details page was already there?

Sure, I apologize for the mistakes; somehow I got confused about the tasks. I have updated the profile.

textbook commented 4 months ago

I don't know what it is you're trying to do here @Ikamrava. You have two separate tasks to do:

  1. Review a PR from feature/resource-page to main, using pull_request.md as the whole description (note that it is laid out exactly like the PR template - that is very much on purpose), within your fork of the repository.

  2. Create a pull request from a feature branch in your fork to main in this repository, implementing one of the stories listed in the backlog, and filling out the PR template accordingly.

Right now you've created one single PR, containing the implementation of #18 you're supposed to be reviewing, plus your own implementation of #18, plus your own implementation of #30, from a feature branch to a feature branch. That makes it incredibly difficult to review.

I'm going to close this out for now - I expect to see two separate PRs, one within your repo (review PR task) and one from your repo into this repo (create PR task).