CodeforKarlsruhe / farmshops.eu

Karte von HoflΓ€den, Milchautomaten und anderen Direktvermarktern
https://farmshops.eu
MIT License
39 stars 10 forks source link

Add quest for the app StreetComplete #16

Open stefangrotz opened 6 years ago

stefangrotz commented 6 years ago

This issue is in english to make colaboration with the team of StreetComplete easier. It is a app that sends it users on quests to find out things about incomplete parts of Openstreetmap. The app is perfect for our map.

https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md

ENT8R commented 6 years ago

Hi, I'm actually one of the developers/contributors of StreetComplete and I just wanted to ask if you have a specific use case of how StreetComplete could help to improve the data used by your application/map πŸ—Ί. Since you already opened a ticket 🎫 at westnordost/StreetComplete#1042 I wonder whether it would make sense to add the kind of things a vending machine tagged with amenity=vending_machine sells by asking the user of StreetComplete something like: "What things are selled at this vending machine?" :euro: and let the user select/input πŸ–Š one or more values of the list :page_with_curl: included here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dvending_machine This would make definitely sense to me and I think this would be pretty valuable data. πŸ˜„ If you have some other suggestions/ideas πŸ€” feel free to tell them to me here! πŸ‘

stefangrotz commented 6 years ago

Hi, this sounds great. Since there was no easy way to include shop=farm in a quest I stoped working on this issue. But vending machines could actualy work. There could be another query for opening hours of marketplaces.

ENT8R commented 6 years ago

There could be another query for opening hours of marketplaces.

This is already included in the existing opening hours πŸ•™ quest: see the code πŸ’» here

I will open a new issue in the next days over at StreetComplete where we can discuss the new (proposed) quest. I will tell you here when I did this!

stefangrotz commented 6 years ago

Great, I will assist you wherever I can. We should highlight, that vending=food does not mean vending snacks and sweets.

JensKorte commented 3 years ago

I am interested in this thread, too. Of course, the answer "undecidable" should always be available. Some thought to this:

If ... -> then ask ...

shop and (surrounding) landuse is farmland, farmyard, vineyard -> ask for shop=farm vending_machine and (surrounding) landuse is farmland, farmyard, vineyard -> ask for shop=farm shop=farm -> selling milk, raw milk shop=farm -> selling with a vending machine only, additional vending machine, no vending machine shop=farm -> organic=yes/no/only - describes if a shop or restaurant offers organic products Describe the diference between produce and product and ask for produce & products: milk, egg, vegetable, fruits, meat

joostschouppe commented 2 years ago

Especially for adding entirely new objects, a MapComplete theme might also be useful.