CommonsBuild / Token-Log-Hatch-Params

A tool to collect community opinions on the proper parameterization of the Token Engineering Commons
https://params.tecommons.org/hatch
MIT License
9 stars 8 forks source link

Do QA on the Github outputs #241

Closed GriffGreen closed 3 years ago

GriffGreen commented 3 years ago
laurenluz commented 3 years ago

Yeah I like Griff's suggestions and propose the following example flow:

BEGIN:

I designed an economy using the Hatch Dashboard. Think you can do better? Click here to fork my params.

Results image

Impact Hour Rate Impact Hour Rate is the hourly wage of TECH tokens awarded to TEC Community members that contributed work hours before the Hatch.

image

Backer's Rage Quit Backer’s Rage Quit % is the % of funds invested that is redeemable by the Backers if they decide to “rage quit” and leave the Commons before the Hatch.

image

image

Redeem-ability of the DAO's wxDai The amount of the DAO’s wxDai that is redeemable by backers, by builders, and the amount that is not redeemable is represented in the following pie charts.

image

Minimum Support and Quorum Accepted for Proposals to Pass Minimum support is the percentage of tokens used in the vote that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass. Minimum quorum is the percentage of the total supply of tokens that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass.

image

Summary Table image

My Parameters image

Comments image

Thanks for reading! Improve upon these results by clicking here to fork my params.

END

laurenluz commented 3 years ago

@divine-comedian @GriffGreen want to review and if you like we can pass to Vitor or Fabio to implement the changes?

GriffGreen commented 3 years ago

This is Great!

I love the sentences above each chart!

Not sure about the opening sentences or the order tho... I'll try another one

divine-comedian commented 3 years ago

This is my proposal forked from lauren's proposal.

BEGIN:

I just designed a DAO using the Hatch Dashboard. Try and iterate on my design if you think you can do better:

Results

image

Impact Hour Rate

The hourly wage of TECH tokens awarded to TEC Community members that contributed work hours before the Hatch.

image

Backer's Rage Quit %

The percent of funds invested that is redeemable by the Backers if they decide to “rage quit” and leave the Commons before the Hatch.

image

image

Redeem-ability of the DAO's wxDai

The amount of the Hatch’s wxDai that is redeemable by backers or builders if they rage quit and the amount that is not redeemable is represented in the following pie charts.

image

Minimum support and Minimum quorum

The percentage of tokens used in the vote that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass and the percentage of the total supply of tokens that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass.

image

Summary Table

image

My Parameters

image

Comments

image

Improve upon these results by clicking here to fork my params.

END

laurenluz commented 3 years ago

@divine-comedian I like the updated text at the beginning and end, and the edits to make the defining intros a bit shorter.

However, I don't love the breakdown for minimum support/quorum. I think it is confusing to have the title as two things and then two definitions concatenated below. I think it's better to have it like "minimum quorum is THIS. minimum support is THIS"

divine-comedian commented 3 years ago

SUGGEST -

Minimum Support

The percentage of tokens used in the vote that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass.

Minimum Quorum

The percentage of the total supply of tokens that must choose “yes” in order for a proposal to pass.

Also to move the 'Results' text at the top to the bottom with the comments text so all text blocks are together.

laurenluz commented 3 years ago

Ok SO. Because we are limited by time and we can't live the dream, here is the best I can come up with, given the circumstances. Re-arranged the order based on the way results are currently being spat out. See below:

Also ... please include the title of the pie charts above the pie charts.... "Redeem-ability of the Dao's wxDai"

START:

I just designed a DAO using the Hatch Configuration Dashboard. Try and iterate on my design if you think you can do better:

Results

image

Summary Table

image

Explanation

Comments

My Parameters

Parameters Values
Target raise (wxDai) 10,000,000.00
Maximum raise (wxDai) 25,000,000.00
Minimum raise (wxDai) 1,250,000.00
Impact hour slope (wxDai/IH) 351.00
Maximum impact hour rate (wxDai/IH) 300.00
Hatch oracle ratio (wxDai/CSTK) 50.00
Hatch period (days) 14.00
Hatch exchange rate (TECH/wxDai) 1,000.00
Hatch tribute (%) 18.00
Support required (%) 62.00
Minimum accepted quorum (%) 8.00
Vote duration (days) 3.00
Vote buffer (hours) 3.00
Rage quit (hours) 12.00
Tollgate fee (wxDai) 500.00

Improve upon these results by clicking here to fork my params.

To see the value of your individual Impact Hours, click here to go to the Hatch Config Dashboard with these parameters and explore the Impact Hour Results table.

END

@divine-comedian @GriffGreen - can you review?

divine-comedian commented 3 years ago

START:

I just designed a DAO using the Hatch Configuration Dashboard. Try and iterate on my design if it can improve:

Results

image

Parameter References

Summary Table

image

Explanation

Comments

My Parameters

Parameters Values
Target raise (wxDai) 10,000,000.00
Maximum raise (wxDai) 25,000,000.00
Minimum raise (wxDai) 1,250,000.00
Impact hour slope (wxDai/IH) 351.00
Maximum impact hour rate (wxDai/IH) 300.00
Hatch oracle ratio (wxDai/CSTK) 50.00
Hatch period (days) 14.00
Hatch exchange rate (TECH/wxDai) 1,000.00
Hatch tribute (%) 18.00
Support required (%) 62.00
Minimum accepted quorum (%) 8.00
Vote duration (days) 3.00
Vote buffer (hours) 3.00
Rage quit (hours) 12.00
Tollgate fee (wxDai) 500.00

Improve upon these results by clicking here to fork my params.

To see the value of your individual Impact Hours, click here to go to the Hatch Config Dashboard with these parameters and explore the Impact Hour Results table.

END

Just added a little header for the parameter references so they don't get lost in the melee. Capitalized some parameter names.

Looks great! :+1:

GriffGreen commented 3 years ago

Love what Mitch and Lauren came up with. There were some changes in our Sunday call so I updated this to match:

It should my comment below:

GriffGreen commented 3 years ago

Check out my proposal for the Hatch! Click here to preload the Hatch Configuration Dashboard with my parameters if you think you can do better.

Graphical Summary

image

Graph Descriptions

Simulated Outcomes

image

Hatch Strategy

To use the defaults... Technocracy for the win

DAO Strategy

To use the defaults... Technocracy for the win

        <h1>Summary</h1>

Hatch Details

TEC Hatch DAO Voting Details

Iterate on my parameters here.

If you have Impact Hours, you can see how much money you will get with my configuration here, just check out the Impact Hour Results table.

My Hatch Configuration

Parameter Value
Minimum Goal (wxDai) 100000
Maximum Goal (wxDai) 50000000
Target Goal (wxDai) 2500000
Impact Hour Rate at Target Goal (wxDai/IH) 150
Impact Hour Rate at Infinity (wxDai/IH) 500
Hatch Period (days) 15
Hatch Tribute (%) 5
Membership Ratio (wxDai/CSTK) 10
Hatch Minting Rate (TECH/wxDai) 10000
Support Required (%) 60
Minimum Quorum (%) 2
Vote Duration (days) 3
Vote Proposal Buffer (hours) 8
Ragequit (hours) 1
Tollgate Fee (wxDai) 1000
GriffGreen commented 3 years ago

Ok, had to remove spaces to make space!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ViRu34v5zX9kpOfL0xgHohc0BrOJikjLYlP3GIy5Pfs/edit?usp=sharing

GriffGreen commented 3 years ago

Check out my proposal for the Hatch! Click here to preload the Hatch Configuration Dashboard with my parameters if you think you can do better.

image

Graphical Summary

image

Graph Descriptions

Simulated Outcomes

image

Hatch Strategy

We need to put lots of text here

DAO Strategy

We should give them the space to explain their thoughts

Hatch Details

DAO Details

If you have Impact Hours, you can see what you will get with my configuration in the Impact Hour Results table on the Dashboard.

My Hatch Configuration

Parameter Value
Target Goal (wxDai) 2500000
Maximum Goal (wxDai) 5000000
Minimum Goal (wxDai) 700000
Impact Hour Rate at Target Goal (wxDai/IH) 60
Impact Hour Rate at Infinity (wxDai/IH) 180
Hatch Membership Ratio (wxDai/CSTK) 10
Hatch Period (days) 15
Hatch Minting rate (TECH/wxDai) 10000
Hatch Tribute (%) 5
Support Required (%) 93
Minimum Quorum (%) 2
Vote Duration (days) 3
Vote Buffer (hours) 8
Ragequit (hours) 18
Tollgate Fee (wxDai) 1000