CompPhysVienna / n2p2

n2p2 - A Neural Network Potential Package
https://compphysvienna.github.io/n2p2/
GNU General Public License v3.0
223 stars 82 forks source link

Extrapolation warning occurs when using my NNP in interface-LAMMPS. #189

Closed ANCHENMA closed 1 year ago

ANCHENMA commented 1 year ago

Hi,

I used my own dataset (300K, 1000K, density + 10%) to train the high-dimensional neural network potential of bulk water with RuNNer, and then used a randomly built 64-molecule water box to run 1ns NVT in lammps interface of n2p2, but there were extrapolation warnings (449EWPERSTEP) at 71.5ps. After that, there were more and more extrapolation warnings(428371EWPERSTEP at 73 ps), and the water molecular dispersed, the hydrogen and oxygen atoms gathered together respectively .

What should I do next, pick configurations with nnp-comp2?

md_lmp.txt input_nn.txt log_lammps.txt.txt

I would be very grateful indeed for any help you could give me. Zhaoan Chen

ANCHENMA commented 1 year ago

Initial data set was obtained from MD simulation in vasp of 64 water molecules in the NVT ensemble with a length of 8ps

philippmisof commented 1 year ago

Usually this is a sign of an insufficient training data set. Constructing a good data set is a non-trivial task. To get a feeling, look at the data set for bulk water at HDNNP training data set for H2O and its corresponding README.pdf

ANCHENMA commented 1 year ago

Thanks for your help,I solved the question.