Closed kaavee315 closed 1 month ago
⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 3 |
🧪 Relevant tests | No |
🔒 Security concerns | No |
⚡ Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The default value for entity_id in collections.py might not be suitable for all use cases. It's set to "default", which could lead to unexpected behavior if not properly handled in all calling contexts. |
Refactoring Concern: In swe.py , the removal of entity initialization and direct use of composio_client could lead to issues if the composio_client is not properly initialized or configured elsewhere in the code. | |
Data Range Adjustment: The change in data range in get_issues_dataset from "test[23:33]" to "test[31:32]" significantly reduces the dataset size, which might affect the evaluation results or performance testing. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible issue |
Add exception handling for
___
**The | 8 |
Add exception handling for the
___
**The | 8 | |
✅ Ensure the updated import paths are correct to prevent import errors___Suggestion Impact:The suggestion was to ensure the import paths are correct. The committed patch adjusted the import paths, which aligns with the intention of the suggestion to prevent import errors. code diff: ```diff +from composio_swe.composio_swe.agent.swe import CoderAgent, CoderAgentArgs +from composio_swe.composio_swe.config.constants import KEY_API_KEY from composio_swe.composio_swe.config.context import Context, set_context -from composio_swe.composio_swe.config.constants import KEY_API_KEY -from composio_swe.composio_swe.agent.swe import CoderAgent, CoderAgentArgs ```modules exist in the specified locations to avoid import errors.** [python/composio_swe/benchmark/run_evaluation.py [6-8]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/202/files#diff-d97c3a8fcc8931e4bc7bd8a5fd22231faf0ffd60133f65afb29ce91ee372ca87R6-R8) ```diff -from composio_swe.composio_swe.config.context import Context, set_context -from composio_swe.composio_swe.config.constants import KEY_API_KEY -from composio_swe.composio_swe.agent.swe import CoderAgent, CoderAgentArgs +from composio_swe.config.context import Context, set_context +from composio_swe.config.constants import KEY_API_KEY +from composio_swe.agent.swe import CoderAgent, CoderAgentArgs ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The suggestion is valid as incorrect import paths can lead to runtime errors. However, the suggestion incorrectly proposes reverting to old paths instead of verifying the new ones. | 5 | |
Best practice |
Add type hints for dictionary keys and values to improve code readability and type safety___ **Consider adding a type hint for theparams argument to specify the types of keys and values it should contain. This will improve code readability and help catch potential type errors.** [python/composio/client/collections.py [946]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/202/files#diff-4bae1393a4b5e1f07b5b87855fed9d56811d949225a47921cad5d4cc75c71e13R946-R946) ```diff -params: t.Dict, +params: t.Dict[str, Any], ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding type hints for dictionary keys and values enhances readability and type safety, which is a good practice, although not critical for functionality. | 7 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix
Description
entity_id
parameter in theexecute
method ofcollections.py
.run_evaluation.py
to ensure proper module resolution.get_issues_dataset
function to load a different subset of data.swe.py
, and updated method calls to usecomposio_client
directly.Crew
initialization and kickoff with direct task execution inswe.py
.Changes walkthrough 📝
collections.py
Set default value for `entity_id` in `execute` method
python/composio/client/collections.py - Set default value for `entity_id` parameter in `execute` method.
swe.py
Remove entity initialization and update method calls
python/composio_swe/composio_swe/agent/swe.py
composio_client
directly.Crew
initialization and kickoff, replaced with direct taskexecution.
run_evaluation.py
Correct import paths and modify dataset split range
python/composio_swe/benchmark/run_evaluation.py
Context
,set_context
,KEY_API_KEY
,CoderAgent
, andCoderAgentArgs
.get_issues_dataset
function.