Closed Prathit-tech closed 3 months ago
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
๐ Security concerns | No explicit security vulnerabilities are introduced in the PR code. However, the lack of validation for environment variables (like API keys) could potentially lead to issues if not handled properly. It's recommended to add checks to ensure that necessary environment variables are set before proceeding with their usage. |
โก Key issues to review |
Code Consistency: The PR includes a mix of single and double quotes for strings across different files. It's recommended to maintain consistency, preferably using double quotes as per Python's PEP 8 guidelines. |
Comment Clarity: Some comments are vague, such as 'this is a step_callback function -->'. More descriptive comments could enhance understandability. | |
Error Handling: There is no explicit error handling in the new action classes and methods. Consider adding try-except blocks or checks to handle potential exceptions gracefully. | |
Logging: The use of logging is inconsistent. Some files use the logger object, while others use print statements. It's advisable to standardize logging practices across all modules for better maintainability and debugging. | |
Security Concerns: The script includes reading API keys from environment variables but does not check if these keys are actually provided or valid. This could lead to runtime errors or security issues if the keys are not set properly. |
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Maintainability |
Improve variable naming for clarity and maintainability___ **Use a more descriptive variable name thantmpl to enhance code readability and maintainability.** [python/examples/swe/evaluation/run_evaluation.py [75-82]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-f43b915affdcb62ed07dc2588916a62a970eedb5254be51ee1b86e860c789513R75-R82) ```diff -tmpl = "" +message_template = "" if hints: - tmpl = f"Here are few hints to solve the issue described in problem_statement {hints}" -tmpl += f"""\n\n + message_template = f"Here are few hints to solve the issue described in problem_statement {hints}" +message_template += f"""\n\n Here is the issue, that you have to solve all ob your own {problem_statement} """ ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using a more descriptive variable name like `message_template` significantly enhances code readability and maintainability, making it easier for future developers to understand the code. | 9 |
Use a variable for the current time to reduce redundancy and potential errors___ **Replace the direct string manipulation for formatting the date and time in the file pathwith a variable that can be reused to avoid redundancy and potential errors in multiple uses.** [python/examples/swe/evaluation/run_evaluation.py [96-97]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-f43b915affdcb62ed07dc2588916a62a970eedb5254be51ee1b86e860c789513R96-R97) ```diff -task_output_dir = script_dir / Path(TASK_OUTPUT_PATH + "_" + datetime.datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d_%H-%M-%S")) +current_time = datetime.datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d_%H-%M-%S") +task_output_dir = script_dir / Path(f"{TASK_OUTPUT_PATH}_{current_time}") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion improves code maintainability by reducing redundancy and potential errors, making the code easier to read and modify. | 8 | |
Refactor the code to separate environment variable retrieval from object instantiation___ **Refactor the instantiation ofChatOpenAI to separate the retrieval of environment variables from the object creation for better code clarity and maintainability.** [python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py [13-15]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-2fd10c07a280c49da2044f711aecd1b837b99dfb6bc6400e2ea91f3b15d611c6R13-R15) ```diff +openai_api_key = os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key") llm = ChatOpenAI( - openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key"), model_name="gpt-4o" + openai_api_key=openai_api_key, model_name="gpt-4o" ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion enhances code readability and maintainability by separating concerns, although it does not address critical issues. | 6 | |
Improve readability by using multiline strings for long messages___ **To enhance readability and maintainability, consider using a multiline string for longmessages in the system_message parameter.**
[python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/main.py [12-15]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-47d12c8abd79df328719bc90d24b396b4df88f78eac36d601cadff56db769b09R12-R15)
```diff
chatbot = AssistantAgent(
"chatbot",
- system_message="Reply TERMINATE when the task is done or user's content is empty",
+ system_message=("Reply TERMINATE when the task is done or "
+ "user's content is empty"),
llm_config=llm_config,
)
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion improves code readability and maintainability by making long strings easier to read and manage. However, it is not crucial for functionality. | 6 | |
Security |
Improve security by removing the hardcoded default API key___ **Consider using a more secure method to handle the default API key. Using a hardcodeddefault key in the source code can lead to security risks if the code is exposed. Instead, it's better to handle such cases through environment configurations or secure vault solutions.** [python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py [13-15]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-2fd10c07a280c49da2044f711aecd1b837b99dfb6bc6400e2ea91f3b15d611c6R13-R15) ```diff llm = ChatOpenAI( - openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key"), model_name="gpt-4o" + openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY"), model_name="gpt-4o" ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a significant security concern by removing the hardcoded default API key, which could lead to potential exposure if the code is compromised. | 9 |
Improve the security of API key handling by using dotenv for environment variables___ **Consider using a more secure method to handle sensitive information like API keys, insteadof directly accessing them through os.environ . Utilizing dotenv to load environment variables and then accessing them securely can prevent accidental exposure.** [python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/main.py [8-9]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-47d12c8abd79df328719bc90d24b396b4df88f78eac36d601cadff56db769b09R8-R9) ```diff +dotenv.load_dotenv() # Ensure environment variables are loaded llm_config = { - "config_list": [{"model": "gpt-4o", "api_key": os.environ["OPENAI_API_KEY"]}] + "config_list": [{"model": "gpt-4o", "api_key": os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY")}] } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion enhances security by preventing accidental exposure of sensitive information like API keys. Using `dotenv` to load environment variables is a best practice for handling such data securely. | 9 | |
Possible bug |
Add error handling for missing OPENAI_API_KEY environment variable___ **The instantiation ofChatOpenAI should explicitly handle the case where the environment variable OPENAI_API_KEY is not set. This can prevent runtime errors in environments where the variable might be missing.** [python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py [13-15]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-2fd10c07a280c49da2044f711aecd1b837b99dfb6bc6400e2ea91f3b15d611c6R13-R15) ```diff +api_key = os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY") +if not api_key: + raise ValueError("OPENAI_API_KEY environment variable is not set.") llm = ChatOpenAI( - openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key"), model_name="gpt-4o" + openai_api_key=api_key, model_name="gpt-4o" ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion improves robustness by ensuring that the application fails gracefully if the required environment variable is not set, preventing potential runtime errors. | 8 |
Possible issue |
Add error handling for environment variable access to prevent runtime errors___ **It's recommended to handle potential exceptions when accessing environment variables whichmight not be set, to avoid KeyError .**
[python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/main.py [26]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-47d12c8abd79df328719bc90d24b396b4df88f78eac36d601cadff56db769b09R26-R26)
```diff
-composio_toolset = ComposioToolSet(api_key=os.environ["COMPOSIO_API_KEY"])
+try:
+ api_key = os.environ["COMPOSIO_API_KEY"]
+except KeyError:
+ print("Error: 'COMPOSIO_API_KEY' not found in environment variables.")
+ api_key = None # or handle as appropriate
+composio_toolset = ComposioToolSet(api_key=api_key)
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion addresses a potential runtime issue by adding error handling for environment variable access, which can prevent the application from crashing due to a missing environment variable. | 8 |
Best practice |
Improve path handling by using
___
**Replace the string concatenation with a more robust path handling using | 7 |
Enhancement |
Enhance flexibility by externalizing the model name configuration___ **TheChatOpenAI constructor call uses a hardcoded model name, which could limit flexibility. Consider externalizing this configuration to an environment variable or a configuration file.** [python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py [13-15]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-2fd10c07a280c49da2044f711aecd1b837b99dfb6bc6400e2ea91f3b15d611c6R13-R15) ```diff llm = ChatOpenAI( - openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key"), model_name="gpt-4o" + openai_api_key=os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY", "default_key"), model_name=os.getenv("OPENAI_MODEL_NAME", "gpt-4o") ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion increases the flexibility of the code by allowing the model name to be configured externally, which can be useful in different deployment environments. | 7 |
Performance |
Suggest using a more efficient data structure for metadata and document storage___ **Consider using a more compact and normalized data structure for storing metadata anddocument information. The current structure is deeply nested and repetitive, which could lead to higher memory usage and slower access times. A relational or tabular format might be more efficient, especially if the data size grows.** [python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/animals/docstore.json [1]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/228/files#diff-14e0cccb36e51e401c26421e2c086b14f14a8d87c68bc23b8d862b49cf5cabd8R1-R1) ```diff -{"docstore/metadata": {"dbbd562e-6d1e-49d1-a378-4d90b6834387": {"doc_hash": "3ea8b9498c8bbae9b13a03c40dfe8e93c8b29d010147ef93c78c5a8492dd11d5"}, "0634b310-e7b2-4a0c-8db5-6bd1da939beb": {"doc_hash": "a0b9decc518f0bcc039e97e6f000f9a77f328521f8f6afff2ee41dcec20683f2"}, ...}} +{"docstore": {"metadata": [{"doc_id": "dbbd562e-6d1e-49d1-a378-4d90b6834387", "doc_hash": "3ea8b9498c8bbae9b13a03c40dfe8e93c8b29d010147ef93c78c5a8492dd11d5"}, {"doc_id": "0634b310-e7b2-4a0c-8db5-6bd1da939beb", "doc_hash": "a0b9decc518f0bcc039e97e6f000f9a77f328521f8f6afff2ee41dcec20683f2"}, ...]}} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion to use a more compact and normalized data structure addresses potential performance issues related to memory usage and access times. However, it does not provide a concrete implementation or consider the specific requirements and constraints of the existing system. | 7 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Formatting, Documentation, Configuration changes, Dependencies, Tests
Description
QueryVectorstore
andCreateVectorstore
for querying and creating vector stores.Changes walkthrough ๐
13 files
run_evaluation.py
Code formatting and comment style update.
python/examples/swe/evaluation/run_evaluation.py
evaluation.py
Code formatting and string style update.
python/examples/swe/evaluation/evaluation.py
run_on_single_issue.py
Code formatting and comment style update.
python/examples/swe/evaluation/run_on_single_issue.py
main.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
main.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/research_assistant/main.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
main.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/news_summary/main.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
arxiv_research_reporter.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/arxiv-research-reporter/arxiv_research_reporter.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
crewai_ci_chart.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/crewai_ci_chart.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
main.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_llama_index/main.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
benchmark_script.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/swe/benchmark_script.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
evaluation.py
Code formatting and string style update.
python/examples/benchmark/evaluation.py
autogen_math.py
Code formatting update.
python/examples/local_tools/autogen_math.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
__init__.py
Code formatting update.
python/composio/tools/__init__.py - Reformatted code for better readability.
20 files
query_vectorstore.py
New action class for querying vector stores.
python/composio/local_tools/embedtool/actions/query_vectorstore.py
QueryVectorstore
for querying vector stores.image_search_frontend.py
New Streamlit frontend for image search.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/image_search_frontend.py - Added a new Streamlit frontend for image search using LangChain.
create_vectorstore.py
New action class for creating vector stores.
python/composio/local_tools/embedtool/actions/create_vectorstore.py
CreateVectorstore
for creating vector stores.main.py
New image search script using CrewAI.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/main.py - Added a new script for image search using CrewAI.
main.py
New image search script using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/main.py - Added a new script for image search using LangChain.
main.py
New image search script using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/main.py - Added a new script for image search using LlamaIndex.
main.py
New image search script using Autogen.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/main.py - Added a new script for image search using Autogen.
main.py
New SQL agent script using Autogen.
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/main.py - Added a new script for SQL agent using Autogen.
local_handler.py
Added EmbedTool to local tools.
python/composio/client/local_handler.py - Added `EmbedTool` to the list of local tools.
tool.py
New tool class for embedding images.
python/composio/local_tools/embedtool/tool.py
EmbedTool
for embedding images and findingimages with text.
__init__.py
Added imports for vector store actions.
python/composio/local_tools/embedtool/actions/__init__.py - Added imports for `CreateVectorstore` and `QueryVectorstore`.
__init__.py
Added import for EmbedTool.
python/composio/local_tools/embedtool/__init__.py - Added import for `EmbedTool`.
docstore.json
Add docstore JSON with image metadata and data
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/animals/docstore.json
horse, and squirrel.
image__vector_store.json
Add empty image vector store JSON for CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/animals/image__vector_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for image vector store.
image__vector_store.json
Add empty image vector store JSON for AutoGen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/animals/image__vector_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for image vector store.
image__vector_store.json
Add empty image vector store JSON for LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/animals/image__vector_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for image vector store.
graph_store.json
Add empty graph store JSON for LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/animals/graph_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for graph store.
graph_store.json
Add empty graph store JSON for CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/animals/graph_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for graph store.
graph_store.json
Add empty graph store JSON for AutoGen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/animals/graph_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for graph store.
graph_store.json
Add empty graph store JSON for LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/animals/graph_store.json - Added an empty JSON file for graph store.
1 files
test.py
New test script for image search using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/test.py - Added a new test script for image search using LangChain.
10 files
setup.sh
New setup script for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/setup.sh - Added a setup script for image search using LlamaIndex.
setup.sh
New setup script for SQL agent using Autogen.
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/setup.sh - Added a setup script for SQL agent using Autogen.
setup.sh
New setup script for image search using CrewAI.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/setup.sh - Added a setup script for image search using CrewAI.
setup.sh
New setup script for image search using Autogen.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/setup.sh - Added a setup script for image search using Autogen.
setup.sh
New setup script for image search using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/setup.sh - Added a setup script for image search using LangChain.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for SQL agent plotter
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/.env.example
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search with LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/.env.example
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search with CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/.env.example
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search with AutoGen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/.env.example
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search with LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/.env.example
14 files
docstore.json
New docstore JSON file for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/animals/docstore.json - Added a new docstore JSON file for image search using LlamaIndex.
docstore.json
New docstore JSON file for image search using CrewAI.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/animals/docstore.json - Added a new docstore JSON file for image search using CrewAI.
docstore.json
New docstore JSON file for image search using Autogen.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/animals/docstore.json - Added a new docstore JSON file for image search using Autogen.
docstore.json
New docstore JSON file for image search using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/animals/docstore.json - Added a new docstore JSON file for image search using LangChain.
index_store.json
New index store JSON file for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/animals/index_store.json
index_store.json
New index store JSON file for image search using CrewAI.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/animals/index_store.json - Added a new index store JSON file for image search using CrewAI.
index_store.json
New index store JSON file for image search using Autogen.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/animals/index_store.json - Added a new index store JSON file for image search using Autogen.
index_store.json
New index store JSON file for image search using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/animals/index_store.json
requirements.txt
New requirements file for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/requirements.txt - Added a new requirements file for image search using LlamaIndex.
image__vector_store.json
New image vector store JSON file for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/animals/image__vector_store.json
LlamaIndex.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search with CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/requirements.txt
sentence-transformers.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search with LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/requirements.txt
sentence-transformers.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search with AutoGen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/requirements.txt
sentence-transformers.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for SQL agent plotter with AutoGen
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/requirements.txt
langchain-openai.
6 files
readme.md
New README file for image search using LlamaIndex.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/readme.md - Added a new README file for image search using LlamaIndex.
readme.md
New README file for image search using CrewAI.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/readme.md - Added a new README file for image search using CrewAI.
readme.md
New README file for image search using Autogen.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/readme.md - Added a new README file for image search using Autogen.
readme.md
New README file for image search using LangChain.
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/readme.md - Added a new README file for image search using LangChain.
readme.md
New README file for image search.
python/examples/image_search/readme.md - Added a new README file for image search.
readme.md
New README file for SQL agent using Autogen.
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_autogen/readme.md - Added a new README file for SQL agent using Autogen.