Closed sohamganatra closed 1 week ago
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The use of os.environ["OPENAI_API_KEY"] and os.environ["COMPOSIO_API_KEY"] directly in the code without checking if the environment variables exist could lead to KeyError if the variables are not set. Consider adding checks or default values. |
Code Duplication: There is significant duplication in the initialization and configuration of agents across different files. Consider creating a utility function or class to handle common setup tasks. | |
Hardcoded Values: The task descriptions and some configurations like model names are hardcoded, which reduces flexibility. Consider externalizing these to configuration files or environment variables. | |
Error Handling: There is a lack of error handling around external calls and file operations which could lead to unhandled exceptions during runtime. |
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible issue |
Add error handling for missing
___
**Consider handling the case where the | 9 |
Improve the safety of environment variable access___ **To avoid potential runtime errors when accessing environment variables, it is recommendedto use a safer access method that provides a default value or handles the case where the variable might not be set.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py [16]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-5f00512c590cfa2dc94ef768cc2701c550f77cc5422d603db8369ab2aeb8b8edR16-R16) ```diff -BOT_USER_ID = os.environ['SLACK_BOT_ID'] +BOT_USER_ID = os.environ.get('SLACK_BOT_ID', 'default_bot_id') ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential runtime error by providing a default value if the environment variable is not set, which is crucial for robust code. | 9 | |
Enhancement |
Improve accessibility by providing descriptive alternative text for images___ **Consider providing alternative text that describes the content of the images for betteraccessibility. This is important for users who rely on screen readers or when the image fails to load.** [python/examples/pr_agent/readme.md [6-9]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-209a367275a3412505a062d5dbbdc14fdadd8ca6f17da1ecd5459b10005e6779R6-R9) ```diff -![alt text](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/blob/feat/slack-assistant/python/examples/pr_agent/schematic.png?raw=true) -![alt text](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/blob/feat/slack-assistant/python/examples/pr_agent/adding_slack_bot.gif?raw=true) +![Schematic of PR Agent](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/blob/feat/slack-assistant/python/examples/pr_agent/schematic.png?raw=true) +![Adding a Slackbot to the workspace](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/blob/feat/slack-assistant/python/examples/pr_agent/adding_slack_bot.gif?raw=true) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion enhances accessibility by providing descriptive alt text for images, which is important for users relying on screen readers or in cases where images fail to load. This is a significant improvement for inclusivity and usability. | 9 |
Prevent the bot from responding to messages that only contain the bot tag___ **To ensure that the bot does not respond to messages containing only the bot tag withoutany other text, add a check to ignore messages that do not contain additional text.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py [47-49]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-5f00512c590cfa2dc94ef768cc2701c550f77cc5422d603db8369ab2aeb8b8edR47-R49) ```diff -if RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED and f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>" not in message: - print("Bot not tagged, ignoring message") +if RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED and (f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>" not in message or message.strip() == f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>"): + print("Bot not tagged or message empty, ignoring message") return ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion enhances the bot's functionality by ensuring it does not respond to empty messages, which is a useful improvement. | 8 | |
Check if the virtual environment directory exists before creating it___ **Add a check to ensure the virtual environment directory does not already exist beforeattempting to create it, to avoid overwriting existing environments.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_autogen/setup.sh [5]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-779a23b54df98bdfbbc5203f3572ef9458f0e67c6b5ef3f72f5771f45266ed13R5-R5) ```diff -python3 -m venv ~/.venvs/slack_agent +if [ ! -d "~/.venvs/slack_agent" ]; then + python3 -m venv ~/.venvs/slack_agent +else + echo "Virtual environment already exists. Skipping creation." +fi ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This enhancement prevents overwriting an existing virtual environment, which can save time and avoid potential issues with existing setups. It is a useful check to add. | 8 | |
Error handling |
Add error handling for the
___
**Add error handling for the `composio login` command to manage login failures gracefully.**
[python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_autogen/setup.sh [17]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-779a23b54df98bdfbbc5203f3572ef9458f0e67c6b5ef3f72f5771f45266ed13R17-R17)
```diff
-composio login
+if ! composio login; then
+ echo "Failed to login to Composio. Please check your credentials."
+ exit 1
+fi
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
| 9 |
Robustness |
Add exception handling around OpenAI API calls___ **To improve the robustness of the message processing, consider adding exception handlingaround the API calls to handle potential failures gracefully.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/slack_agent_openai.py [102-103]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-f94d2817598276b8bdc12cc0f37606cf78bc3531c26535990680b9b35206351dR102-R103) ```diff -thread = openai_client.beta.threads.create() -active_threads[ts] = thread.id +try: + thread = openai_client.beta.threads.create() + active_threads[ts] = thread.id +except Exception as e: + print(f"Failed to create thread: {e}") + return ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding exception handling around API calls is a good practice to ensure that the application can handle potential failures gracefully, improving its robustness and reliability. | 8 |
Best practice |
Ensure that
___
**Consider checking if | 8 |
Use
___
**Replace the use of | 7 | |
Improve variable naming for clarity___ **Use a more descriptive variable name thants for the timestamp to enhance code readability.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/slack_agent_openai.py [97]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-f94d2817598276b8bdc12cc0f37606cf78bc3531c26535990680b9b35206351dR97-R97) ```diff -ts = payload.get("event", {}).get("ts", "") +timestamp = payload.get("event", {}).get("ts", "") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using a more descriptive variable name enhances code readability, making it easier for other developers to understand the purpose of the variable. | 6 | |
Maintainability |
Refactor message filtering logic into a separate function___ **Refactor theprocess_message function to separate concerns by moving the message filtering logic (checking if the bot is tagged) to its own function. This improves readability and maintainability.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/slack_agent_openai.py [92-94]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-f94d2817598276b8bdc12cc0f37606cf78bc3531c26535990680b9b35206351dR92-R94) ```diff -if RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED and f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>" not in message: +if should_ignore_message(RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED, message, BOT_USER_ID): print("Bot not tagged, ignoring message") return +def should_ignore_message(respond_only_if_tagged, message, bot_user_id): + return respond_only_if_tagged and f"<@{bot_user_id}>" not in message + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This refactoring improves code readability and maintainability by separating concerns, making the `process_message` function easier to understand and modify. | 7 |
Use more descriptive variable names___ **To enhance the readability and maintainability of the code, consider using a moredescriptive variable name than llm for the ChatOpenAI instance.**
[python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py [13]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-5f00512c590cfa2dc94ef768cc2701c550f77cc5422d603db8369ab2aeb8b8edR13-R13)
```diff
-llm = ChatOpenAI(model="gpt-4-turbo")
+chat_openai_instance = ChatOpenAI(model="gpt-4-turbo")
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using more descriptive variable names improves code readability and maintainability, but it is a minor enhancement. | 6 | |
Performance |
Combine checks for bot user ID and tag into a single conditional to enhance efficiency___ **To improve the efficiency and readability of the code, consider combining the two separatechecks for the bot user ID and the bot tag into a single conditional statement.** [python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py [41-49]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-5f00512c590cfa2dc94ef768cc2701c550f77cc5422d603db8369ab2aeb8b8edR41-R49) ```diff -if user_id == BOT_USER_ID: - return -if RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED and f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>" not in message: - print("Bot not tagged, ignoring message") +if user_id == BOT_USER_ID or (RESPOND_ONLY_IF_TAGGED and f"<@{BOT_USER_ID}>" not in message): + print("Ignoring message from bot or untagged message") return ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Combining the checks into a single conditional improves code efficiency and readability, but it is a minor optimization. | 7 |
Clarity |
Clarify the applicability of setup instructions to specific operating systems___ **It's recommended to specify the operating system for which the instructions areapplicable, especially when mentioning commands that might differ across platforms, such as making a script executable.** [python/examples/pr_agent/readme.md [28]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/241/files#diff-209a367275a3412505a062d5dbbdc14fdadd8ca6f17da1ecd5459b10005e6779R28-R28) ```diff -On Linux or macOS, you might need to make the setup.sh script executable: +If you are using Linux or macOS, you might need to make the setup.sh script executable. These instructions are specific to Unix-like operating systems: ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves clarity by specifying that the instructions are for Unix-like operating systems, which helps users understand the context better. This is a minor but useful enhancement for readability and user guidance. | 7 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Documentation, Configuration changes
Changes walkthrough ๐
15 files
main.py
Add image search script using Autogen framework
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/main.py
main.py
Add image search script using CrewAI framework
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/main.py
image_search_frontend.py
Add image search frontend using LangChain framework
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/image_search_frontend.py
main.py
Add image search script using LangChain framework
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/main.py
main.py
Add image search script using LlamaIndex framework
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/main.py
main.py
Add PR agent script using Autogen framework
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_autogen/main.py
main.py
Add PR agent script using CrewAI framework
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/main.py
main.py
Add PR agent script using LangChain framework
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/main.py
main.py
Add PR agent script using LlamaIndex framework
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_llama_index/main.py
main.py
Add PR agent script using OpenAI framework
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_openai/main.py
slack_agent_autogen.py
Add Slack bot script using Autogen framework
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_autogen/slack_agent_autogen.py
slack_agent_crewai.py
Add Slack bot script using CrewAI framework
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_crewai/slack_agent_crewai.py
slack_agent_langchain.py
Add Slack bot script using LangChain framework
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py
slack_agent_llamaindex.py
Add Slack bot script using LlamaIndex framework
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_llamaindex/slack_agent_llamaindex.py
slack_agent_openai.py
Add Slack bot script using OpenAI framework
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/slack_agent_openai.py
1 files
test.py
Add test script for image search using LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/test.py
29 files
setup.sh
Add setup script for image search using Autogen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for image search using CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for image search using LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for image search using LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for PR agent using Autogen
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_autogen/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for PR agent using CrewAI
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for PR agent using LangChain
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for PR agent using LlamaIndex
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_llama_index/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for PR agent using OpenAI
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_openai/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for Slack bot using Autogen
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_autogen/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for Slack bot using CrewAI
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_crewai/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for Slack bot using LangChain
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for Slack bot using LlamaIndex
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_llamaindex/setup.sh
setup.sh
Add setup script for Slack bot using OpenAI
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/setup.sh
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search using Autogen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/.env.example
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search using Autogen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/requirements.txt - Added requirements for image search using Autogen.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search using CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/.env.example - Added example environment variables for image search using CrewAI.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search using CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/requirements.txt - Added requirements for image search using CrewAI.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search using LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/.env.example
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search using LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/requirements.txt - Added requirements for image search using LangChain.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for image search using LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/.env.example
requirements.txt
Add requirements for image search using LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/requirements.txt - Added requirements for image search using LlamaIndex.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for PR agent using Autogen
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_autogen/.env.example - Added example environment variables for PR agent using Autogen.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for PR agent using Autogen
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_autogen/requirements.txt - Added requirements for PR agent using Autogen.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for PR agent using CrewAI
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/.env.example - Added example environment variables for PR agent using CrewAI.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for PR agent using CrewAI
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/requirements.txt - Added requirements for PR agent using CrewAI.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for PR agent using LangChain
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/.env.example - Added example environment variables for PR agent using LangChain.
requirements.txt
Add requirements for PR agent using LangChain
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/requirements.txt - Added requirements for PR agent using LangChain.
.env.example
Add example environment variables for PR agent using LlamaIndex
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_llama_index/.env.example - Added example environment variables for PR agent using LlamaIndex.
8 files
readme.md
Add README for image search using Autogen
python/examples/image_search/image_search_autogen/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for image search using CrewAI
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for image search using LangChain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for image search using LlamaIndex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for image search
python/examples/image_search/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for PR agent using Autogen
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_autogen/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for PR agent using CrewAI
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/readme.md
readme.md
Add README for PR agent using LangChain
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/readme.md