Closed sohamganatra closed 1 month ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Schema Change The schema of `SqlQueryResponse` has been modified, replacing `result` with `response_data` and adding `execution_details`. Ensure that all dependent code correctly handles these changes, particularly the new dictionary structure in `execution_details`. API Key Handling The handling of the OpenAI API key has been removed, and the model initialization now does not include the API key. Ensure that the API key is being set globally or in another secure manner that complies with best practices. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Maintainability |
Replace hardcoded model name with a configurable environment variable___ **Replace the hardcoded model name with a variable or environment variable to alloweasier configuration changes without modifying the codebase.** [python/examples/research_assistant/main.py [12-13]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/348/files#diff-d0b9aa1a0515c318c3d50bded15ff2370d0dca1e6223f46b86ef73d4e723375fR12-R13) ```diff +model_name = os.getenv("MODEL_NAME", "gpt-4o") llm = ChatOpenAI( - model="gpt-4o" + model=model_name ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion improves maintainability by allowing configuration changes without modifying the codebase. It is a significant improvement and aligns with best practices for configuration management. | 9 |
Possible bug |
Add a secure method to fetch and pass the OpenAI API key to the
___
**It seems the | 9 |
Ensure the API key is securely provided to the
___
**The new code lacks the API key parameter for the | 9 | |
Reintroduce the API key parameter securely in the
___
**The removal of the API key parameter in the | 9 | |
Securely fetch and use the API key for
___
**The new code snippet lacks the API key parameter for the | 9 | |
Possible issue |
Add error handling for uninitialized variables in
___
**Ensure that the | 8 |
Enhancement |
Add validation check before printing the
___
**Add a check to ensure that the | 7 |
Best practice |
Improve variable naming for better readability and maintainability___ **Use a more descriptive variable name thanllm for the ChatOpenAI instance to improve code readability and maintainability.** [python/examples/research_assistant/main.py [12-13]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/348/files#diff-d0b9aa1a0515c318c3d50bded15ff2370d0dca1e6223f46b86ef73d4e723375fR12-R13) ```diff -llm = ChatOpenAI( +chat_openai_client = ChatOpenAI( model="gpt-4o" ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While improving variable naming is beneficial for readability and maintainability, it is a minor improvement compared to functional or security-related changes. | 6 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Documentation
Description
ChatOpenAI
andComposioToolSet
initialization in various scripts.Changes walkthrough ๐
28 files
sql_query.py
Update SqlQueryResponse schema with execution details
python/composio/tools/local/sqltool/actions/sql_query.py
execution_details
dictionary toSqlQueryResponse
result
toresponse_data
inSqlQueryResponse
main.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in calendar agent
python/examples/calendar_agent/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in commit agent
python/examples/commit_agent/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in image search crewai
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in image search langchain
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in image search langgraph
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langgraph/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in image search llamaindex
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in investment analysis
python/examples/investment_analysis/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationgmail_send_attachment_crew.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling and add Crew initialization
python/examples/miscellaneous/gmail_send_attachment_crew.py
Crew
initialization and task executionmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in PR agent crewai
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in PR agent langchain
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in PR agent llama index
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_llama_index/main.py
OpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in PR agent openai
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_openai/main.py
OpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in RAG agent
python/examples/rag_agent/main.py
ComposioToolSet
andChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling and add Crew initialization
python/examples/research_assistant/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationCrew
initialization and task executionmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in scheduler agent crewai
python/examples/scheduler_agent/schedule_agent_crewai/main.py
ChatOpenAI
andComposioToolSet
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in scheduler agent langchain
python/examples/scheduler_agent/scheduler_agent_langchain/main.py
ChatOpenAI
andComposioToolSet
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in scheduler agent llamaindex
python/examples/scheduler_agent/scheduler_agent_llamaindex/main.py
ComposioToolSet
initializationslack_agent_crewai.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in slack agent crewai
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_crewai/slack_agent_crewai.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationslack_agent_langchain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in slack agent langchain
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_langchain/slack_agent_langchain.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationslack_agent_llamaindex.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in slack agent llamaindex
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_llamaindex/slack_agent_llamaindex.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationslack_agent_openai.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in slack agent openai
python/examples/slack_bot_agent/slack_agent_openai/slack_agent_openai.py
OpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in SQL agent
python/examples/sql_agent/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in SQL agent plotter crewai
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_crewai/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in SQL agent plotter langchain
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_langchain/main.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationmain.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in SQL agent plotter llama index
python/examples/sql_agent/sql_agent_plotter_llama_index/main.py
ComposioToolSet
initializationcrewai_demo.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in crewai demo
python/plugins/crew_ai/crewai_demo.py
ChatOpenAI
initializationlangchain_demo.py
Simplify OpenAI API key handling in langchain demo
python/plugins/langchain/langchain_demo.py
ChatOpenAI
initialization8 files
calendar-agent.mdx
Update calendar agent guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/calendar-agent.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentationcommit-agent.mdx
Update commit agent guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/commit-agent.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentationcompetitor-researcher.mdx
Update competitor researcher guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/competitor-researcher.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentationinvestment-analyst.mdx
Update investment analyst guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/investment-analyst.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentationrag_agent.mdx
Update RAG agent guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/rag_agent.mdx
ChatOpenAI
andComposioToolSet
initialization indocumentation
research-assistant.mdx
Update research assistant guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/research-assistant.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentationsql-agent.mdx
Update SQL agent guide to simplify API key handling
docs/guides/python/sql-agent.mdx
ChatOpenAI
andComposioToolSet
initialization indocumentation
action-guide.mdx
Update action guide to simplify API key handling
docs/introduction/foundations/components/actions/action-guide.mdx
ChatOpenAI
initialization in documentation