Closed sohamganatra closed 1 month ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Missing Validation The removal of API key input and setting without adding alternative validation might lead to unhandled exceptions if the environment variable is not set. Task Execution Change The change from direct task execution to using `Crew` for task management should be verified to ensure that the behavior of the system remains consistent. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Add API key initialization to the ChatOpenAI instance for secure API access___ **Consider initializing theChatOpenAI instance with an API key for authentication. This is crucial for accessing OpenAI's API services securely.** [python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/main.py [21]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/349/files#diff-0af62c19bb8748428193cbb27a3c9bcc6fe97912481ccc752085f222eb51b550R21-R21) ```diff -llm = ChatOpenAI(model="gpt-4o") +llm = ChatOpenAI(model="gpt-4o", api_key=os.environ["OPENAI_API_KEY"]) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding the API key is crucial for secure access to OpenAI's services, which enhances the security of the application. | 9 |
Best practice |
Add error handling for the
___
**It's recommended to handle exceptions for the | 8 |
Maintainability |
Ensure the .env file loads successfully to maintain correct environment settings___ **To prevent the application from running with potentially outdated or incorrectenvironment settings, add a check to ensure that the .env file was loaded successfully.** [python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/main.py [20]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/349/files#diff-8aed1cd585b907533b3071944ebbf2f90ae08423152644d639ef0c4f0bd93a37R20-R20) ```diff -dotenv.load_dotenv() +if not dotenv.load_dotenv(): + raise EnvironmentError("Failed to load .env file") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Ensuring the .env file loads successfully helps maintain correct environment settings, which is important for the application's reliability. | 8 |
Possible issue |
Validate the model availability before initializing the ChatOpenAI instance___ **Ensure that theChatOpenAI instance initialization includes handling for missing or invalid model specifications, which can lead to runtime errors.** [python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/image_search_frontend.py [40]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/349/files#diff-4d0a73df5172ed105e1e837da99680f362941e50da49f119e15d9f795fe90078R40-R40) ```diff +if "gpt-4o" not in available_models: + raise ValueError("Model gpt-4o is not available") llm = ChatOpenAI(model="gpt-4o") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Checking for model availability can prevent runtime errors, although it assumes the existence of an `available_models` list which is not shown in the provided code. | 7 |
PR Type
Documentation, Enhancement
Description
gpt-4o
across multiple files.Crew
for task execution in relevant files.Changes walkthrough ๐
17 files
main.py
Update model initialization and task execution
python/examples/image_search/image_search_crewai/main.py
gpt-4o
.Crew
for task execution.image_search_frontend.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/image_search_frontend.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
main.py
Update model initialization and remove manual API key input
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langchain/main.py
gpt-4o
.main.py
Update model initialization and remove manual API key input
python/examples/image_search/image_search_langgraph/main.py
gpt-4o
.main.py
Remove manual API key input
python/examples/image_search/image_search_llamaindex/main.py - Removed manual API key input and setting.
autogen_math.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/examples/local_tools/autogen_math.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
gmail_send_attachment_crew.py
Update model and task execution
python/examples/miscellaneous/gmail_send_attachment_crew.py
gpt-4o
.Crew
for task execution.main.py
Update model initialization and remove manual API key input
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_crewai/main.py
gpt-4o
.main.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_langchain/main.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
main.py
Update model initialization and remove manual API key input
python/examples/pr_agent/pr_agent_llama_index/main.py
gpt-4o
.autogen_demo.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/plugins/autogen/autogen_demo.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
julep_demo.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/plugins/julep/julep_demo.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
langchain_demo.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/plugins/langchain/langchain_demo.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
agent.py
Update model to gpt-4o
python/swe/examples/crewai_agent/agent.py - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
demo.ts
Update model to gpt-4o
js/examples/langchain/demo.ts - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
demo.mjs
Update model to gpt-4o
js/examples/langchain/demo.mjs - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
sample.mjs
Update model to gpt-4o
js/examples/langchain/sample.mjs - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
6 files
interpreter-agent.mdx
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
docs/guides/javascript/interpreter-agent.mdx - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
rag_agent.mdx
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
docs/guides/python/rag_agent.mdx - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
research-assistant.mdx
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
docs/guides/python/research-assistant.mdx - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
langchain.mdx
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
docs/javascript/langchain.mdx - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
README.md
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
python/plugins/autogen/README.md - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.
README.md
Update model to gpt-4o in documentation
python/plugins/julep/README.md - Changed model initialization to `gpt-4o`.