Closed utkarsh-dixit closed 1 month ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Type Safety The `container` property in `DockerWorkspace` class is typed as `any | null`. It's better to use a more specific type instead of `any` to improve type safety and maintainability. Dynamic Module Loading The use of `nodeExternalRequire` for dynamic module loading could lead to issues if not handled properly. Ensure that error handling and module availability are adequately addressed. Dynamic Import Dynamic importing of `Sandbox` from `@e2b/sdk` using `nodeExternalRequire` might introduce runtime errors if the module or its exports are not available. Consider adding checks to ensure the module is correctly loaded. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Maintainability |
Use consistent module import strategy across the project___ **Replace the use ofrequire("node:net") with nodeExternalRequire("node:net") to maintain consistency with the modular import strategy used elsewhere in the project.** [js/src/env/docker/workspace.ts [14]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-32ee46b296bb6f8b6057a91d605dddb67bf44959fd07877e17e416e0dae339edR14-R14) ```diff -const server = require("node:net").createServer(); +const server = nodeExternalRequire("node:net").createServer(); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion improves code consistency and maintainability by using the same import strategy throughout the project. It aligns with the modular import strategy used elsewhere in the code. | 9 |
Improve type safety by specifying a more accurate type___ **Use a more specific type forcontainer property in DockerWorkspace class instead of any | null to improve type safety and code maintainability.**
[js/src/env/docker/workspace.ts [26]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-32ee46b296bb6f8b6057a91d605dddb67bf44959fd07877e17e416e0dae339edR26-R26)
```diff
-public container: any | null = null;
+public container: Docker.Container | null = null;
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Specifying a more accurate type for the `container` property enhances type safety and code maintainability, reducing potential runtime errors. | 8 | |
Reduce redundancy and improve code clarity by centralizing command execution___ **Replace the repeated calls tothis.sandbox!.process.start with a single function that handles command execution to reduce redundancy and improve code clarity.** [js/src/env/e2b/workspace.ts [41-61]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-cce7e4a1da429213dd54779e75908f66b0ba1d55a1a6019114b770ff9f4e96e6R41-R61) ```diff -await this.sandbox!.process.start({ - cmd: "composio apps update", -}); -await this.sandbox!.process.start({ - cmd: `sudo useradd -rm -d /home/${_ssh_username} -s /bin/bash -g root -G sudo ${_ssh_username}`, -}); -await this.sandbox!.process.start({ - cmd: `echo ${_ssh_username}:${_ssh_password} | sudo chpasswd`, -}); -await this.sandbox!.process.start({ - cmd: "sudo service ssh restart", -}); -await this.sandbox!.process.start({ - cmd: `_SSH_USERNAME=${_ssh_username} _SSH_PASSWORD=${_ssh_password} COMPOSIO_LOGGING_LEVEL=debug composio serve -h '0.0.0.0' -p ${this.port}`, -}); +const executeCommand = async (cmd) => { + await this.sandbox!.process.start({ cmd }); +}; +await executeCommand("composio apps update"); +await executeCommand(`sudo useradd -rm -d /home/${_ssh_username} -s /bin/bash -g root -G sudo ${_ssh_username}`); +await executeCommand(`echo ${_ssh_username}:${_ssh_password} | sudo chpasswd`); +await executeCommand("sudo service ssh restart"); +await executeCommand(`_SSH_USERNAME=${_ssh_username} _SSH_PASSWORD=${_ssh_password} COMPOSIO_LOGGING_LEVEL=debug composio serve -h '0.0.0.0' -p ${this.port}`); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Centralizing command execution reduces redundancy and improves code clarity, making the code easier to maintain and understand. However, the improvement is more about code style than a critical fix. | 7 | |
Verify Node.js code compatibility with the
___
**The | 6 | |
Best practice |
Ensure consistent module loading and better environment handling___ **Replace the dynamic import ofpath and os modules with nodeExternalRequire to ensure consistency and potentially handle non-node environments better.** [js/src/env/docker/workspace.ts [97-98]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-32ee46b296bb6f8b6057a91d605dddb67bf44959fd07877e17e416e0dae339edR97-R98) ```diff -const path = require("node:path"); -const os = require("node:os"); +const path = nodeExternalRequire("node:path"); +const os = nodeExternalRequire("node:os"); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion ensures consistency in module loading and potentially improves handling in non-node environments, which is a good practice for maintainability and robustness. | 9 |
Update the Node.js version requirement to a supported version for better security and compatibility___ **Theengines field for @jridgewell/resolve-uri specifies a minimum Node.js version of 6.0.0 , which is outdated and no longer supported. It's recommended to update this to a more recent version to ensure security and compatibility with newer Node.js features.** [js/examples/ai-playground-main/pnpm-lock.yaml [218-219]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-52d637854db874e21b04c1a0b124cd991857ebf396920dbe5be4e0a5c965afeaR218-R219) ```diff '@jridgewell/resolve-uri@3.1.2': resolution: {integrity: sha512-bRISgCIjP20/tbWSPWMEi54QVPRZExkuD9lJL+UIxUKtwVJA8wW1Trb1jMs1RFXo1CBTNZ/5hpC9QvmKWdopKw==} - engines: {node: '>=6.0.0'} + engines: {node: '>=12.0.0'} # Updated to a supported version ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Updating the Node.js version requirement to a more recent, supported version enhances security and compatibility, which is crucial for maintaining a secure and stable environment. | 9 | |
Ensure consistent and predictable dependency management by using exact versions___ **It's recommended to use consistent versioning for dependencies to avoid potentialconflicts and ensure compatibility. The @cloudflare/workers-types dependency is specified with a caret (^) which allows minor updates. However, the version installed is a specific version without allowing minor updates. This could lead to inconsistencies or unexpected behavior if the dependencies are not fully compatible.** [js/examples/ai-playground-main/pnpm-lock.yaml [18-20]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/358/files#diff-52d637854db874e21b04c1a0b124cd991857ebf396920dbe5be4e0a5c965afeaR18-R20) ```diff '@cloudflare/workers-types': - specifier: ^4.20230419.0 + specifier: 4.20240620.0 version: 4.20240620.0 ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using exact versions for dependencies helps in maintaining consistency and avoiding potential conflicts. This suggestion addresses a best practice for dependency management. | 8 | |
Specify compatible versions in
___
**The | 7 |
**Action:** test (ubuntu-latest, 3.11) |
**Failed stage:** [Unittests](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/actions/runs/10040486262/job/27746701391) [โ] |
**Failed test name:** test_action_enum |
**Failure summary:**
The action failed because the test test_action_enum in the file tests/test_client/test_enum.py encountered a ValueError . GITHUB_ISSUES_LIST for Action ".GITHUB_ISSUES_LIST is not a valid entry for the Action enum. |
Relevant error logs:```yaml 1: ##[group]Operating System 2: Ubuntu ... 504: * [new branch] fix/rag-agent -> origin/fix/rag-agent 505: * [new branch] fix/readme -> origin/fix/readme 506: * [new branch] fix/readme-logo -> origin/fix/readme-logo 507: * [new branch] fix/swe-agent -> origin/fix/swe-agent 508: * [new branch] ft-add-better-help-text -> origin/ft-add-better-help-text 509: * [new branch] ft-apps-id -> origin/ft-apps-id 510: * [new branch] ft-bring-back-core-sdk -> origin/ft-bring-back-core-sdk 511: * [new branch] ft-did-you-mean -> origin/ft-did-you-mean 512: * [new branch] ft-error-tracking -> origin/ft-error-tracking ... 928: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_list_all[arguments3-exptected_outputs3-unexptected_outputs3] PASSED [ 17%] 929: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_tag_not_found PASSED [ 19%] 930: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_limit SKIPPED [ 21%] 931: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_copy PASSED [ 23%] 932: tests/test_cli/test_add.py::TestComposioAdd::test_no_auth PASSED [ 25%] 933: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestList::test_list PASSED [ 27%] 934: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestUpdate::test_update_not_required PASSED [ 29%] 935: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestUpdate::test_update SKIPPED (Needs 936: investigation, this test fails in CI) [ 31%] ... 944: tests/test_client/test_client.py::test_raise_invalid_api_key PASSED [ 48%] 945: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_trigger_objects_to_comma_separated_string PASSED [ 51%] 946: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_trigger_strings_to_comma_separated_string PASSED [ 53%] 947: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_mix_of_trigger_objects_and_strings PASSED [ 55%] 948: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::test_trigger_subscription PASSED [ 57%] 949: tests/test_client/test_endpoints.py::test_endpoint PASSED [ 59%] 950: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_tag_enum PASSED [ 61%] 951: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_app_enum PASSED [ 63%] 952: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_action_enum FAILED [ 65%] ... 961: tests/test_tools/test_local/test_workspace.py::test_stderr PASSED [ 85%] 962: tests/test_tools/test_local/test_workspace.py::test_workspace PASSED [ 87%] 963: tests/test_utils/test_decorators.py::test_deprecated PASSED [ 89%] 964: tests/test_utils/test_git.py::test_get_git_user_info PASSED [ 91%] 965: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_get_pydantic_signature_format_from_schema_params PASSED [ 93%] 966: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_json_schema_to_pydantic_field PASSED [ 95%] 967: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_json_schema_to_fields_dict PASSED [ 97%] 968: tests/test_utils/test_url.py::test_get_web_url PASSED [100%] 969: =================================== FAILURES =================================== ... 979: self = |
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix
Description
DockerWorkspace
andE2BWorkspace
classes to usenodeExternalRequire
for dynamic module loading.DockerWorkspace
andE2BWorkspace
.Shell
class by removingEventEmitter
inheritance.nodeExternalRequire
utility function inshared.ts
.Changes walkthrough ๐
workspace.ts
Refactor DockerWorkspace to use dynamic module loading and type
annotations
js/src/env/docker/workspace.ts
nodeExternalRequire
for dynamic moduleloading.
Docker.Container
type toany
forcontainer
property.cli-progress
.path
andos
imports inside thesetup
method.workspace.ts
Use dynamic module loading and null checks in E2BWorkspace
js/src/env/e2b/workspace.ts
nodeExternalRequire
for dynamic moduleloading.
!
operator forsandbox
property.base.ts
Simplify Shell class by removing EventEmitter inheritance
js/src/env/base.ts - Removed `EventEmitter` inheritance from `Shell` class.
shared.ts
Add utility function for dynamic module loading
js/src/utils/shared.ts - Added `nodeExternalRequire` function for dynamic module loading.
wrangler.toml
Enable Node.js compatibility in Wrangler configuration
js/wrangler.toml - Added `node_compat = true` to enable Node.js compatibility.
pnpm-lock.yaml
...
js/examples/ai-playground-main/pnpm-lock.yaml ...