Closed kaavee315 closed 1 month ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Typo There is a typo in the method documentation: "tempalte" should be corrected to "template". Hardcoded Logic The code directly concatenates channel_id into a string which could lead to runtime errors if the channel_id is not properly formatted as expected. Consider validating or formatting the channel_id before using it. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Add error handling to prevent unhandled exceptions when file reading fails___ **Add error handling for potential failures when reading template files.** [python/swe/swekit/scaffold/_scaffold.py [26-28]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/359/files#diff-0a837dbf0fcdbe8c94526e4d4459043ac0b17b4f88a8ddfcf967de1fb05227d1R26-R28) ```diff -return { - file.name.replace(".template", ".py"): file.read_text(encoding="utf-8") - for file in (TEMPLATES_PATH / self.value).glob("*.template") -} +try: + return { + file.name.replace(".template", ".py"): file.read_text(encoding="utf-8") + for file in (TEMPLATES_PATH / self.value).glob("*.template") + } +except Exception as e: + raise SWEKitError(f"Failed to read template files: {str(e)}") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion**Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding error handling for file reading operations is crucial to prevent the application from crashing due to unhandled exceptions. This significantly improves the robustness of the code. | 9 |
Possible issue |
Validate the output directory before performing file operations___ **Ensure theoutdir parameter is validated to check if it's a valid directory path before proceeding with file operations.** [python/swe/swekit/cli.py [44]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/359/files#diff-82e98c671cd58b739deadbc714511c1276d9b49fc8873cf6c843e20f34aaa0e5R44-R44) ```diff outdir: t.Optional[Path] = None, +if outdir is not None and not outdir.exists(): + raise ValueError("The specified output directory does not exist.") ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Validating the output directory ensures that the directory exists before performing file operations, preventing potential runtime errors. This is an important validation step to ensure the reliability of the code. | 8 |
Validate
___
**Add a validation check for `agent_type` to ensure it receives a valid enum value.**
[python/swe/swekit/cli.py [45]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/359/files#diff-82e98c671cd58b739deadbc714511c1276d9b49fc8873cf6c843e20f34aaa0e5R45-R45)
```diff
agent_type: AgentType = AgentType.SWE,
+if not isinstance(agent_type, AgentType):
+ raise ValueError("Invalid agent type provided.")
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
| 8 | |
Enhancement |
Improve string formatting by using f-string___ **Replace the string concatenation with f-string for better readability andperformance.** [python/swe/swekit/scaffold/_scaffold.py [39-43]](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/pull/359/files#diff-0a837dbf0fcdbe8c94526e4d4459043ac0b17b4f88a8ddfcf967de1fb05227d1R39-R43) ```diff -code_review_assistant_prompt = ( - """ - You are an experienced code reviewer. - Your task is to review the provided file diff and give constructive feedback. +code_review_assistant_prompt = f""" + You are an experienced code reviewer. + Your task is to review the provided file diff and give constructive feedback. - Follow these steps: - 1. Identify if the file contains significant logic changes. - 2. Summarize the changes in the diff in clear and concise English, within 100 words. - 3. Provide actionable suggestions if there are any issues in the code. + Follow these steps: + 1. Identify if the file contains significant logic changes. + 2. Summarize the changes in the diff in clear and concise English, within 100 words. + 3. Provide actionable suggestions if there are any issues in the code. - Once you have decided on the changes, for any TODOs, create a Github issue. - And send the summary of the PR review to """ - + channel_id - + """ channel on slack. Slack doesn't have markdown and so send a plain text message. - Also add the comprehensive review to the PR as a comment. - """ -) + Once you have decided on the changes, for any TODOs, create a Github issue. + And send the summary of the PR review to {channel_id} channel on slack. Slack doesn't have markdown and so send a plain text message. + Also add the comprehensive review to the PR as a comment. +""" ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves readability and performance by using f-strings, which are more modern and efficient than concatenation. However, the improvement is minor and does not address a critical issue. | 7 |
**Action:** test (ubuntu-latest, 3.11) |
**Failed stage:** [Unittests](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/composio/actions/runs/10040990778/job/27748212777) [โ] |
**Failed test name:** test_action_enum |
**Failure summary:**
The action failed because the test test_action_enum failed. The test failed due to a ValueError being raised in the Action class constructor. Specifically:GITHUB_ISSUES_LIST was not recognized as a valid value for the Action enum.composio/client/enums/base.py at line 112. |
Relevant error logs:```yaml 1: ##[group]Operating System 2: Ubuntu ... 505: * [new branch] fix/readme -> origin/fix/readme 506: * [new branch] fix/readme-logo -> origin/fix/readme-logo 507: * [new branch] fix/swe-agent -> origin/fix/swe-agent 508: * [new branch] ft-add-better-help-text -> origin/ft-add-better-help-text 509: * [new branch] ft-add-js-example -> origin/ft-add-js-example 510: * [new branch] ft-apps-id -> origin/ft-apps-id 511: * [new branch] ft-bring-back-core-sdk -> origin/ft-bring-back-core-sdk 512: * [new branch] ft-did-you-mean -> origin/ft-did-you-mean 513: * [new branch] ft-error-tracking -> origin/ft-error-tracking ... 929: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_list_all[arguments3-exptected_outputs3-unexptected_outputs3] PASSED [ 17%] 930: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_tag_not_found PASSED [ 19%] 931: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_limit SKIPPED [ 21%] 932: tests/test_cli/test_actions.py::TestListActions::test_copy PASSED [ 23%] 933: tests/test_cli/test_add.py::TestComposioAdd::test_no_auth PASSED [ 25%] 934: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestList::test_list PASSED [ 27%] 935: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestUpdate::test_update_not_required PASSED [ 29%] 936: tests/test_cli/test_apps.py::TestUpdate::test_update SKIPPED (Needs 937: investigation, this test fails in CI) [ 31%] ... 945: tests/test_client/test_client.py::test_raise_invalid_api_key PASSED [ 48%] 946: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_trigger_objects_to_comma_separated_string PASSED [ 51%] 947: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_trigger_strings_to_comma_separated_string PASSED [ 53%] 948: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::TestTriggerNamesSerialization::test_converts_mix_of_trigger_objects_and_strings PASSED [ 55%] 949: tests/test_client/test_collections.py::test_trigger_subscription PASSED [ 57%] 950: tests/test_client/test_endpoints.py::test_endpoint PASSED [ 59%] 951: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_tag_enum PASSED [ 61%] 952: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_app_enum PASSED [ 63%] 953: tests/test_client/test_enum.py::test_action_enum FAILED [ 65%] ... 962: tests/test_tools/test_local/test_workspace.py::test_stderr PASSED [ 85%] 963: tests/test_tools/test_local/test_workspace.py::test_workspace PASSED [ 87%] 964: tests/test_utils/test_decorators.py::test_deprecated PASSED [ 89%] 965: tests/test_utils/test_git.py::test_get_git_user_info PASSED [ 91%] 966: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_get_pydantic_signature_format_from_schema_params PASSED [ 93%] 967: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_json_schema_to_pydantic_field PASSED [ 95%] 968: tests/test_utils/test_shared.py::test_json_schema_to_fields_dict PASSED [ 97%] 969: tests/test_utils/test_url.py::test_get_web_url PASSED [100%] 970: =================================== FAILURES =================================== ... 980: self = |
PR Type
Enhancement, Other
Description
AgentType
option to the CLI for scaffolding different agent types.AgentType
enum withSWE
andPR_REVIEW
values.AgenticFramework.load_templates
andscaffold
function to handle different agent types.Changes walkthrough ๐
cli.py
Add agent type option to CLI scaffolding command
python/swe/swekit/cli.py
AgentType
option to CLI for scaffolding different agent types._scaffold
function to accept and useagent_type
.__init__.py
Include AgentType in scaffold module exports
python/swe/swekit/scaffold/__init__.py
AgentType
in the module.AgentType
to__all__
._scaffold.py
Extend scaffold function to support multiple agent types
python/swe/swekit/scaffold/_scaffold.py
AgentType
enum withSWE
andPR_REVIEW
values.AgenticFramework.load_templates
to handle different agenttypes.
scaffold
function to accept and useagent_type
.main.template
Add PR review agent template for CrewAI
python/swe/swekit/scaffold/templates/pr_review/crewai/main.template
ComposioToolSet.