search

ConnieGuan / YellowCow

A repo for Yellow Cow COGS 121 Group
3 stars 1 forks source link

Milestone 9 feedback #7

Open kandarpksk opened 7 years ago

kandarpksk commented 7 years ago

If duplicated, please ignore and close this issue.

nhasjim commented 7 years ago

Team GuoDaddy (A2)

Bahari Hasjim

I like how the app takes you to a feed of pictures. It is really cool to see the all of the graffiti in one list. It is kind of like an instagram for closeby graffiti. I wish we were able to contribute to the graffiti, like add onto somebody else's graffiti. Also, in the page with the feed of pictures, the pictures are quite large and I think it would be better UI wise if you made the pictures smaller.

Justine Lin

Cool app! I like that so much of the functionality is implemented or at least thought out. You can see the other players on the map really easily, which adds a great social aspect. I think it would be a fun thing to try - and a good excuse to hang out with people you haven’t seen in a while. I wish that the location was not as “jumpy”, and that the map didn’t have restaurants and other landmarks on it. I don’t need that when playing the game.

David Moll

Nice graffiti! I like how the submission process is already implemented. It’s cool that people are able to add things to the stream. Is the stream currently sorted by votes? If so, that’s great! I wish that the stream itself had more visually appealing buttons, and the vote feature was easier to use. (A button called “vote” isn’t too informative.) Also, it’d be cool if there was ways to decorate the picture besides just drawing lines! (i.e. emojis, shapes, etc)

Joshua Komala

I like how you can already add your own drawings onto the website. I also like how pictures are tagged with geolocation and added to the map. I wish you could upload a picture as a background to draw on. This would make the digital graffiti aspect of the application more interesting. Right now It just seems like pictures tagged with a location

christywong commented 7 years ago

Team A7 - ACME

Emily

I think this app is nice. I really like the ability to draw on a picture and create your own “graffiti” to post to others. Since graffiti is the main focus of the app, maybe you could also try different brush types? I’m not sure how feasible this would be to implement but it’s an idea. I think it’s cool that you included an exploration aspect to this app. The only part I’m not sure about is having to be in the vicinity to see the graffiti. Why don’t you make it so that you can continue seeing the graffiti once you’ve discovered it? Perhaps you can make it so that those who have already upvoted the graffiti get to continue seeing it, since they liked it. Since the app is image-based, I would like to be able to continue seeing graffiti that I liked in the past.

Christy

I think the functionality that you have implemented already is really cool. I like that users are able to take photos and have that integrated with your app already. I wish that when users get within the radius of an "undiscovered" marker (a question mark one), they would be able to see that even when they leave the radius, because they've already "discovered" it. I think it would be cool for users to be able to save their favorites and if users can see the ones they've discovered, it would make it easier for users to keep a list of their favorite posts and go back to it without walking to the location again. Also, I think having a map associated with each post might be redundant if the Home page lists all the ones in your vicinity. I think just having a geotag near the name of the post (like how Instagram does it) would be sufficient to indicate location.

Mohsin

The app is very fleshed out right now and there are a lot of interesting features! I like that you can take pictures and draw on them within the app. I also like that there are different icons on the map that indicate how popular a certain photo is. Currently, there is a small map display for each picture on the landing page. I didn't find this particularly useful since I could just go to the map page to see all the photos in the nearby area. I understand that people have to move within a hidden photo's visibility radius to see it but I wish there was another use for the map.

Arlen

There is an incredible amount of features for the time given so far - very cool. However, I do believe that the UI could be fleshed out a lot more - consider a lot more padding and whitespace (especially for the home page, on desktop an image covers and entire screen and it's not conducive for viewing). Excited to see what's next.

johnpallag commented 7 years ago

Team A9

John

I like the interactivity and the functionality a lot. I'd like a legend on the map so that I know what each of the markers mean. I'd also like to see just an address under the pictures instead of a map, it takes up quite a bit of space.

Alex

The red exclamation mark icon gives a sense of danger or urgency. Might wanna switch color and shape to make it stick out in a good way. A gold star maybe

Sophia

I like the idea but I feel like there should be a bit more information up front, definitely create a landing page if you haven't. I like the question marks but I feel like the red exclamation marks are a bad idea, I suggest a gold start instead. I also think that unless you are in map mode when you scroll through the images the map for that image does not need to show and only takes up space.