ConsumerDataStandardsAustralia / standards-maintenance

This repository houses the interactions, consultations and work management to support the maintenance of baselined components of the Consumer Data Right API Standards and Information Security profile.
41 stars 9 forks source link

Intention of the lastUpdated property within BankingProductV4 #564

Closed af-stayorgo closed 1 year ago

af-stayorgo commented 1 year ago

I would like to request clarification on the intention of the lastUpdated property within BankingProductV4 responses. The current description is:

“The last date and time that the information for this product was changed (or the creation date for the product if it has never been altered)“.

It seems clear that if the product changes, for example an increase to a fee or rate, then the lastUpdated property should be set to the time of change. What is not clear is, if the product doesn't change, however the formatting of information within the payload does, should the lastUpdated property be updated? Examples of this include:

Furthermore, are data holders permitted to arbitrarily set the lastUpdated property (e.g. each day), when there have been no changes to the data?

Thanks

nils-work commented 1 year ago

Hi @af-stayorgo

While it may be recommended for Data Holders to update the lastUpdated value when changes such as you have described are made, it is ultimately at their discretion to determine what constitutes an 'update' that could warrant a potentially more timely refresh by consumers of that data.

It would not be recommended for data holders to change the lastUpdated value if no changes have been made, as this could cause consumers (of the API) to make unnecessary requests.

Further questions such as this can be directed to the CDR Support Portal where it could become the basis for additional guidance.

nils-work commented 1 year ago

Hi @af-stayorgo

Guidance on the lastUpdated field is now available and it is also mentioned in further guidance related to the Compliance and Enforcement Policy.

This issue will be closed on 30 June 2023 if there are no further comments or changes to the Standards expected as an outcome.