ContextLab / attention-memory-task

An experiment used to explore interactions between covert attention and recognition memory
Other
10 stars 5 forks source link

Check sitmulus presentation and data collection in (Updated Code) #91

Closed KirstensGitHub closed 4 years ago

KirstensGitHub commented 5 years ago

WHAT WE'RE CHECKING:

These tests check to make sure all stimulus presentation (order of stimuli, stimulus onsets, durations, etc) is as intended! (This check is just verifying that the experiment presents stimuli correctly).

INITIAL CHECKS (complete):

For this check, I ran myself on a presentation block and memory block of the Sustained Attention experiment and saved out log files. I then checked that the stimulus timings, durations, and orders were as desired.

Check A: We found that images displayed in the desired image order.

Check B: We found that images we intended to display together (cued and uncued composites, cued side and cued category, rating scale and memory image, etc) displayed simultaneously

Check C: We are using this check solely to verify the stimulus presentation; timings will be pulled from log files.

CHECK D: We visually checked that the cued composite images always appear on the cued side of the screen by replacing cued composites with images of fruit. You can see the videos and their corresponding stimulus dataframes below. You can see that the fruit images always appear in the cued location.

CHECK E: We also ran two runs of the experiment to fully explore how often the x and o stimuli appear on the cued versus uncued sides / verifying the attention probe validity.

CHECK F: We checked the attention cues and found that the code sometimes still presents the same cue in two runs back-to-back. Code has been updated so no two consecutive runs have the same cues (commit # XXX )

KirstensGitHub commented 5 years ago
Screen Shot 2019-10-05 at 9 15 46 PM
KirstensGitHub commented 5 years ago

video of single run, here: https://youtu.be/OCYHcviYjac

corresponding dataframe, here:

  Subject Trial Type Run Cued Composite Uncued Composite Cued Face Cued Place Uncued Face Uncued Place Memory Image Category Cued Side Cued Category Attention Response Time (s) Familiarity Reaction Time (s) Familiarity Rating Attention Level Cue Validity Post Invalid Cue Pre Invalid Cue Attention Button Rating History Stimulus Onset Stimulus End Attention Probe
50 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00754941201fa_sunaffgsyyvoqdlkmnk.jpg 00184940128fa_sunaavtbadenwnzeutj.jpg 00754941201fa.jpg sunaffgsyyvoqdlkmnk.jpg 00184940128fa.jpg sunaavtbadenwnzeutj.jpg . < Place 34.49615979 . . . 1 . . 3 . .   o
51 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00819940307fa_sunahqldjibofgsfdgb.jpg 00906960530fa_sunantryfbloeaomfta.jpg 00819940307fa.jpg sunahqldjibofgsfdgb.jpg 00906960530fa.jpg sunantryfbloeaomfta.jpg . < Place 39.59944701 . . . 0 . . 3 . .   o
52 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00793941205fa_sunagtjwilqjvxohypn.jpg 00791941205fa_sunagrmyoovzukhxmlo.jpg 00793941205fa.jpg sunagtjwilqjvxohypn.jpg 00791941205fa.jpg sunagrmyoovzukhxmlo.jpg . < Place 44.91952085 . . . 1 . . 1 . .   o
53 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00857940307fa_sunaiwfobocrruqznsv.jpg 00720960620fa_sunaecpkgfewqqreqwe.jpg 00857940307fa.jpg sunaiwfobocrruqznsv.jpg 00720960620fa.jpg sunaecpkgfewqqreqwe.jpg . < Place 49.72736692 . . . 1 . . 3 . .   o
54 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00208940128fa_sunaazzyhbvqjpmazjq.jpg 00884960530fa_sunakodkcslgqhqlgwl.jpg 00208940128fa.jpg sunaazzyhbvqjpmazjq.jpg 00884960530fa.jpg sunakodkcslgqhqlgwl.jpg . < Place 54.50351691 . . . 1 . . 3 . .   o
55 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00663941121fa_sunadnjjzohjhbohlwq.jpg 00314940422fa_sunabwmcbaxwioksdgw.jpg 00663941121fa.jpg sunadnjjzohjhbohlwq.jpg 00314940422fa.jpg sunabwmcbaxwioksdgw.jpg . < Place 58.9913888 . . . 1 . . 1 . .   x
56 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00266940128fb_sunabkngeblodihjvbk.jpg 00069931230fb_sunaaeowapdkwzqpgqr.jpg 00266940128fb.jpg sunabkngeblodihjvbk.jpg 00069931230fb.jpg sunaaeowapdkwzqpgqr.jpg . < Place 63.59940481 . . . 1 . . 1 . .   x
57 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00276940422fa_sunabmytpyhsgigllxu.jpg 00264940128fb_sunabjzyxcjnmztdonj.jpg 00276940422fa.jpg sunabmytpyhsgigllxu.jpg 00264940128fb.jpg sunabjzyxcjnmztdonj.jpg . < Place 68.26336193 . . . 1 . . 1 . .   x
58 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00070940307fa_sunaaeplwsfslcbtojr.jpg 00805941205fa_sunagwzdbtlixdhgolm.jpg 00070940307fa.jpg sunaaeplwsfslcbtojr.jpg 00805941205fa.jpg sunagwzdbtlixdhgolm.jpg . < Place 72.97535682 . . . 1 . . 3 . .   o
59 kirstenPractice Presentation 1 00773941201fa_sunafvcflzhlqloapyo.jpg 00985960627fa_sunbgklxeqjhdbyfhhy.jpg 00773941201fa.jpg sunafvcflzhlqloapyo.jpg 00985960627fa.jpg sunbgklxeqjhdbyfhhy.jpg . < Place 77.58329892 . . . 0 . . 1 . .   x
KirstensGitHub commented 5 years ago

We conducted one run with fruit images on the cued side AND all attention probes on the cued side (100% valid). We also conducted a run with fruit images all on the uncued side AND all attention probes on the uncued side (100% invalid).

You can view the movies at the links, and see the corresponding dataframes below :)

https://youtu.be/Sf9qBDR4Duw https://youtu.be/uNeC-7lz_sk

  Subject Trial Type Run Cued Composite Uncued Composite Cued Face Cued Place Uncued Face Uncued Place Memory Image Category Cued Side Cued Category Attention Response Time (s) Familiarity Reaction Time (s) Familiarity Rating Attention Level Cue Validity Post Invalid Cue Pre Invalid Cue Attention Button Rating History Stimulus Onset Stimulus End Attention Probe
50 KIRI Presentation 1 apple.jpg 00911960530fa_sunaooaqzputrowwbsw.jpg 00235940128fb.jpg sunabclssnoeuigtawp.jpg 00911960530fa.jpg sunaooaqzputrowwbsw.jpg . . < Face 21.05360293 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . x
51 KIRI Presentation 1 avo.jpg 00835940307fa_sunaijsqpvodplbwxkf.jpg 00507940519fa.jpg sunacacflqoyxhsqzhe.jpg 00835940307fa.jpg sunaijsqpvodplbwxkf.jpg . . < Face 25.54637098 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
52 KIRI Presentation 1 bbery.jpeg 00214940128fa_sunabbafjowbzcvbucc.jpg 00898960530fa.jpg sunamkmeblgteyggink.jpg 00214940128fa.jpg sunabbafjowbzcvbucc.jpg . . < Face 30.01146483 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
53 KIRI Presentation 1 cherry.jpg 00979960627fa_sunbdycacjfaujxitbw.jpg 00903960620fa.jpg sunanainkqdvktzoxyl.jpg 00979960627fa.jpg sunbdycacjfaujxitbw.jpg . . < Face 34.30715799 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
54 KIRI Presentation 1 grape.jpg 00935960627fa_sunaqbmgkgqucajzrkp.jpg 00882960530fa.jpg sunaknlirqjqiwbbeeg.jpg 00935960627fa.jpg sunaqbmgkgqucajzrkp.jpg . . < Face 38.61050582 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
55 KIRI Presentation 1 kiwi.jpg 00915960620fa_sunapileznnbbmrwoei.jpg 00841940307fa.jpg sunaisiwfgppimtnmxl.jpg 00915960620fa.jpg sunapileznnbbmrwoei.jpg . . < Face 42.91253901 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . x
56 KIRI Presentation 1 lemon.jpg 00749941201fa_sunaeuvjbmdpknaqqaj.jpg 00776941205fa.jpg sunafxokyavhgptyfye.jpg 00749941201fa.jpg sunaeuvjbmdpknaqqaj.jpg . . < Face 47.32007694 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
57 KIRI Presentation 1 pear.jpg 00745941205fa_sunaeouogqolxvggaoq.jpg 01004960627fa.jpg sunbwtlihsuptkrckid.jpg 00745941205fa.jpg sunaeouogqolxvggaoq.jpg . . < Face 51.82323599 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . x
58 KIRI Presentation 1 wmelon.jpg 00892960530fa_sunalntxqqadigcletd.jpg 00810941205fa.jpg sunahctntqrunhdxhtb.jpg 00892960530fa.jpg sunalntxqqadigcletd.jpg . . < Face 56.256109 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . o
59 KIRI Presentation 1 berry.jpg 00937960627fa_sunaqsolmfydodnakub.jpg 00063931230fa.jpg sunaaelyvurpntclgau.jpg 00937960627fa.jpg sunaqsolmfydodnakub.jpg . . < Face 60.6450398 . . . 1 . . 1 . . . x
  Subject Trial Type Run Cued Composite Uncued Composite Cued Face Cued Place Uncued Face Uncued Place Memory Image Category Cued Side Cued Category Attention Response Time (s) Familiarity Reaction Time (s) Familiarity Rating Attention Level Cue Validity Post Invalid Cue Pre Invalid Cue Attention Button Rating History Stimulus Onset Stimulus End Attention Probe
100 KIRI Presentation 2 00306940422fa_sunabueyoajufbkraki.jpg apple.jpg 00306940422fa.jpg sunabueyoajufbkraki.jpg 00836940307fa.jpg sunainqelldeebvxtcz.jpg . . > Place 30.52995014 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . o
101 KIRI Presentation 2 00071940128fa_sunaaexpnawiehinlpy.jpg avo.jpg 00071940128fa.jpg sunaaexpnawiehinlpy.jpg 00768941205fa.jpg sunafkmnlytenlsywia.jpg . . > Place 35.01060414 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
102 KIRI Presentation 2 00972960627fa_sunbbfqwjpdxniyhies.jpg bbery.jpeg 00972960627fa.jpg sunbbfqwjpdxniyhies.jpg 00780960530fa.jpg sunagetqixeypsysbpn.jpg . . > Place 39.45936108 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . o
103 KIRI Presentation 2 00834940307fa_sunaibnpvhkdpdnzcnz.jpg cherry.jpg 00834940307fa.jpg sunaibnpvhkdpdnzcnz.jpg 00481940519fa.jpg sunabxsuqbleluwczoy.jpg . . > Place 43.85481405 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
104 KIRI Presentation 2 00296940422fa_sunabrwnslxalcohfre.jpg grape.jpg 00296940422fa.jpg sunabrwnslxalcohfre.jpg 00564940928fa.jpg sunacmpqqfbsvlzinzl.jpg . . > Place 48.66503215 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
105 KIRI Presentation 2 00877960530fa_sunajxpkuhbizeveguy.jpg kiwi.jpg 00877960530fa.jpg sunajxpkuhbizeveguy.jpg 00838940307fa.jpg sunaiozxhxgtfrmoagh.jpg . . > Place 53.04831505 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
106 KIRI Presentation 2 00870940307fa_sunajrgtewnualfcerj.jpg lemon.jpg 00870940307fa.jpg sunajrgtewnualfcerj.jpg 00096931230fa.jpg sunaaiqiqcggrskoqgy.jpg . . > Place 57.58136106 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . o
107 KIRI Presentation 2 00947960627fa_sunasmmcxdddtmtazwx.jpg pear.jpg 00947960627fa.jpg sunasmmcxdddtmtazwx.jpg 00116931230fa.jpg sunaakqepfoeqomfgxf.jpg . . > Place 62.06843114 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
108 KIRI Presentation 2 00809960620fa_sunahbvlpavurqoxdeq.jpg wmelon.jpg 00809960620fa.jpg sunahbvlpavurqoxdeq.jpg 00108960530fa.jpg sunaajtnvzzpsjdzres.jpg . . > Place 66.53867316 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
109 KIRI Presentation 2 00829940307fa_sunahwgbqkqcrwprgvh.jpg berry.jpg 00829940307fa.jpg sunahwgbqkqcrwprgvh.jpg 00571940928fa.jpg sunacuatpqpqhyjhjqk.jpg . . > Place 71.01930523 . . . 0 . . 1 . . . x
KirstensGitHub commented 5 years ago

Full Checks of stimulus presentations (images, image proportions, etc), including Check F, with updated data.

check_behavioral_data (3).pdf compile_behavioral_data.pdf

Data collected with code on updates branch (commit fea9243bf5ae0a3b55e24bc2be16c39f137a9a2d) meets all checks except that some participants see same cue back-to-back.