search

CrealityOfficial / Ender-3S1

This Source code for Creality Ender-3S1 Series,MCU and Screen
GNU General Public License v3.0
129 stars 53 forks source link

Continued Violations of Open Source Agreements #52

Open wizardkitty opened 1 year ago

wizardkitty commented 1 year ago

Creality. You appear to still be pushing out new firmware and denying people the source code.. This needs to stop.

You are violating the GNU General Public License v3.0 that you agreed to by not disclosing the source code.

To anyone else: If creality doesnt give source code upon request if its more up to date then here, report Creality by following the instructions here. https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-violation.en.html

wizardkitty commented 1 year ago

Aparently Creality thinks that the source code used to be confidential when it wasn't the moment the printer was released.

Claiming that the marlin source code used to be confidential over a year after printer release isn't a good excuse for delaying giving source code.

wizardkitty commented 1 year ago

Alright. I can confirm creality is in violation of parts of the lisence. They do not give out the gpl-3 lisence as they are required to with any download of the firmware.

kamoteshake commented 1 year ago

Claiming that the marlin source code used to be confidential over a year after printer release

This is confusing. So they think that the code after a year of release becomes confidential? 🤔

Even if that is true, then with that logic, they already broke their logic. Ender S1 Plus was released last year and there were a bunch of updates with in the first year and they didn't release the source code of those updates. 🤷🏼‍♂️ Either way. they're pretty much violating licenses.

wizardkitty commented 1 year ago

Claiming that the marlin source code used to be confidential over a year after printer release

This is confusing. So they think that the code after a year of release becomes confidential? 🤔

Even if that is true, then with that logic, they already broke their logic. Ender S1 Plus was released last year and there were a bunch of updates with in the first year and they didn't release the source code of those updates. 🤷🏼‍♂️ Either way. they're pretty much violating licenses.

Well they are still claiming it was confidential after this long of a time and it seems like a weird excuse.

wizardkitty commented 1 year ago

@CrealityTech This must be fixed.