siuc-nate
commented
1 year ago Terms proposal, based on https://docs.google.com/document/d/15ZXhI4jC-u5NKcuc4yRPz4SzjNoTAaf725HZHsB2_gY/edit
CTDL Changes
rdf:Property Changes
Create rdf:Property - ceterms:hasRubric
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Rubric" Definition - "Rubric related to this resource." Domain Includes - ceterms:AssessmentProfile, ceterms:Job, ceterms:LearningOpportunityProfile, ceterms:Course, ceterms:LearningProgram, ceterms:ApprenticeshipCertificate, ceterms:AssociateDegree, ceterms:AssociateOfAppliedArtsDegree, ceterms:AssociateOfAppliedScienceDegree, ceterms:AssociateOfArtsDegree, ceterms:AssociateOfScienceDegree, ceterms:BachelorDegree, ceterms:BachelorOfArtsDegree, ceterms:BachelorOfScienceDegree, ceterms:Badge, ceterms:Certificate, ceterms:CertificateOfCompletion, ceterms:Certification, ceterms:Credential, ceterms:Degree, ceterms:DigitalBadge, ceterms:Diploma, ceterms:DoctoralDegree, ceterms:GeneralEducationDevelopment, ceterms:JourneymanCertificate, ceterms:License, ceterms:MasterCertificate, ceterms:MasterDegree, ceterms:MasterOfArtsDegree, ceterms:MasterOfScienceDegree, ceterms:MicroCredential, ceterms:OpenBadge, ceterms:ProfessionalDoctorate, ceterms:QualityAssuranceCredential, ceterms:ResearchDoctorate, ceterms:SecondarySchoolDiploma, ceterms:SpecialistDegree, ceterms:Task Range Includes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:administrationProcess
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:administrationProcess
Remove rdfs:comment - "Entity describing the process by which a credential, assessment, organization, or aspects of it, are administered." Add rdfs:comment - "Entity describing the process by which a resource, or aspects of it, are administered." Add vann:usageNote - "For assessments and rubrics, this can be used to indicate the scoring algorithm."
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:audienceLevelType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:audienceLevelType
Remove rdfs:comment - "Type of level indicating a point in a progression through an educational or training context, for which the credential is intended; select from an existing enumeration of such types." Add rdfs:comment - "Type of level indicating a point in a progression through an educational or training context, for which the resource is intended; select from an existing enumeration of such types."
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:audienceType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:classification
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:ctid
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:deliveryType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:identifier
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:industryType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:instructionalProgramType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:latestVersion
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:latestVersion
Remove rdfs:comment - "Latest version of the credential." Add rdfs:comment - "Latest version of the resource."
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:lifeCycleStatusType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:nextVersion
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:occupationType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:offeredIn
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:previousVersion
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:subject
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:subjectWebpage
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:targetCompetency
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Remove rdfs:comment - "A competency relevant to the condition being described." Add rdfs:comment - "A competency relevant to the resource being described."
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:targetOccupation
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:targetTask
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion
Modify rdf:Property - ceterms:versionIdentifier
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Remove rdfs:comment - "Alphanumeric identifier of the version of the credential that is unique within the organizational context of its owner." Add rdfs:comment - "Alphanumeric identifier of the version of the resource that is unique within the organizational context of its owner." Remove dct:description - "The credential version captured here is any local identifier used by the credential owner to identify the version of the credential in the its local system." Add dct:description - "The resource version captured here is any local identifier used by the resource owner to identify the version of the resource in the local system."
CTDL-ASN Changes
rdfs:Class Changes
Create rdfs:Class - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Criterion Level" Definition - "An individual component or specific element within a criterion that defines a particular aspect or standard for evaluation."
Create rdfs:Class - ceasn:Rubric
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Rubric" Definition - "A structured and systematic evaluation tool used to assess performance, quality, and/or criteria." Equivalent Class - asn:Rubric
Create rdfs:Class - ceasn:RubricCriterion
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Rubric Criterion" Definition - "Resource providing explicit criteria for ensuring specific and measurable evaluation." Equivalent Class - asn:RubricCriterion
Create rdfs:Class - ceasn:RubricLevel
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Rubric Level" Definition - "Level or quality indicator used with Rubric Criteria."
rdf:Property Changes
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:benchmarkLabel
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Benchmark Label" Definition - "Label for the level achieved as defined by the Rubric Criterion." Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel Range Includes - rdf:langString
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:benchmarkText
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Benchmark Text" Definition - "Description of the level achieved as defined by the Rubric Criterion." Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel Range Includes - rdf:langString
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:evaluatorType
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Evaluator Type" Definition - "Type of evaluator; select from an existing enumeration of such types." Domain Includes - ceasn:Rubric Range Includes - skos:Concept Target Concept Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:feedback
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Feedback" Definition - "Predefined feedback text for the benefit of the subject being evaluated." Comment - "This may include guidance and suggestions for improvement or development." Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel Range Includes - rdf:langString
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasCriterionCategory
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Criterion Category" Definition - "Indicates a Concept for clustering logical sets of Rubric Criteria." Domain Includes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Range Includes - skos:Concept
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasCriterionCategorySet
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Criterion Category Set" Definition - "Indicates the Concept Scheme for clustering logical sets of Rubric Criteria." Domain Includes - ceasn:Rubric Range Includes - skos:ConceptScheme
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasCriterionLevel
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Criterion Level" Definition - "Criterion Level for this resource." Domain Includes - ceasn:RubricCriterion, ceasn:RubricLevel, ceasn:CriterionLevel Range Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasRubricCriterion
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Rubric Criterion" Definition - "Explicit criterion for ensuring specific and measurable evaluation." Domain Includes - ceasn:Rubric Range Includes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Subproperty Of - asn:hasCriterion
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasRubricLevel
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Rubric Level" Definition - "Resource describing a level or quality indicator used with Rubric Criteria." Domain Includes - ceasn:Rubric Range Includes - ceasn:RubricLevel
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:hasScope
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Has Scope" Definition - "Description of what the rubric's creator intended to assess or evaluate." Equivalent Property - asn:hasScope Domain Includes - ceasn:Rubric Range Includes - rdf:langString
Create rdf:Property - ceasn:isBinaryEvaluation
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Is Binary Evaluation" Definition - "Indicates whether the criterion level is evaluated as having been met or not." Usage Note - "A value of true does not mean the subject of evaluation has met this criterion level; it means that the criterion level itself only permits a binary evaluation such as "pass/fail", "checked/unchecked", "yes/no", and so on." Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel Range Includes - xsd:boolean
Modify rdf:Property - asn:hasProgressionLevel
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricLevel
Modify rdf:Property - asn:hasProgressionModel
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:altCodedNotation
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:codedNotation
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricLevel Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:conceptKeyword
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:creator
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:dateCopyrighted
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:dateCreated
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:dateModified
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:dateValidFrom
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Remove rdfs:comment - "Beginning date of validity of this competency framework." Add dct:description - "Beginning date of validity of this resource." Remove vann:usageNote - "Where the competency document is valid for a given period of time, use both the dateValidFrom and dateValidUntil properties." Add vann:usageNote - "Where the resource is valid for a given period of time, use both the dateValidFrom and dateValidUntil properties."
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:dateValidUntil
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Remove rdfs:comment - "End date of validity of this competency framework." Add rdfs:comment - "End date of validity of this resource." Remove vann:usageNote - "Where the competency document is valid for a given period of time, use both the dateValidFrom and dateValidUntil properties." Add vann:usageNote - "Where the resource is valid for a given period of time, use both the dateValidFrom and dateValidUntil properties."
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:derivedFrom
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:rangeIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:description
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricLevel
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:educationLevelType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:inLanguage
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:license
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:listID
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricLevel Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:name
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricLevel
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:publicationStatusType
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric Remove rdfs:comment - "The publication status of the of this resource." Add rdfs:comment - "The publication status of the resource."
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:publisher
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:publisherName
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:rights
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:Rubric
Modify rdf:Property - ceasn:weight
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:RubricCriterion
skos:ConceptScheme Changes
Create skos:ConceptScheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Evaluator Category" Definition - "Category of agents that perform evaluation."
skos:Concept Changes
Create skos:Concept - evalCat:Authority
Term Status - vs:unstable In Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory Preferred Label - "Authority" Definition - "Evaluator is an agent with authority over the person, group, or thing being evaluated in the relevant context." Comment - "Examples include teachers, supervisors, managers, or others with positions over the person or group being evaluated."
Create skos:Concept - evalCat:Automated
Term Status - vs:unstable In Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory Preferred Label - "Automated" Definition - "Evaluator is an automated agent or process."
Create skos:Concept - evalCat:External
Term Status - vs:unstable In Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory Preferred Label - "External" Definition - "Evaluator is an agent who is outside the context of the person, group, or thing being evaluated." Comment - "Evaluator is typically independent of the person, group, or thing being evaluated."
Create skos:Concept - evalCat:Peer
Term Status - vs:unstable In Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory Preferred Label - "Peer" Definition - "Evaluator is one or more peers of the person, group, or thing being evaluated." Comment - "Peers may be people taking the same course or in similar job roles."
Create skos:Concept - evalCat:Self
Term Status - vs:unstable In Scheme - ceasn:EvaluatorCategory Preferred Label - "Self" Definition - "Evaluator is the person or group being evaluated."
QData Changes
rdf:Property Changes
Create rdf:Property - qdata:maxPercentage
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Max Percentage" Definition - "The upper percentage of some characteristic or property." Usage Note - "Best practice is to treat the value of this property as a verbatim percentage; for example, a value of 1.5 should be interpreted as 1.5%" Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel, schema:QuantitativeValue, ceterms:ValueProfile Range Includes - xsd:float
Create rdf:Property - qdata:minPercentage
Term Status - vs:unstable Label - "Min Percentage" Definition - "The lower percentage of some characteristic or property." Usage Note - "Best practice is to treat the value of this property as a verbatim percentage; for example, a value of 1.5 should be interpreted as 1.5%" Domain Includes - ceasn:CriterionLevel, schema:QuantitativeValue, ceterms:ValueProfile Range Includes - xsd:float
Modify rdf:Property - qdata:percentage
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Modify rdf:Property - schema:maxValue
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Modify rdf:Property - schema:minValue
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
Modify rdf:Property - schema:value
Add schema:domainIncludes - ceasn:CriterionLevel
philbarker
This replaces closed issue #530. Also see the CTDL Rubric Github Repository for more information.
Draft CTDL Rubric Terms Proposal