CyberDiscovery / meta

This repository is for meta discussion of the Cyber Discovery Discord server.
https://discord.cyberdiscoverycommunity.uk
MIT License
8 stars 9 forks source link

Make Volcano a No Hint Zone™️🙅⛔⚔️ #341

Closed JX-CW closed 4 years ago

JX-CW commented 4 years ago

Too many people are getting past 3.4 on volcano base. This scares me. I propose we make volcano as a whole a No Hint Zone™️🙅⛔⚔️, so I have time to catch up to the 5.6 chads in peace.

lightspeedana commented 4 years ago

I completely agree on this being unfair, but unfortunately people will still give away solutions and hints in DMs and that's something out of our jurisdiction. Do you have an idea as to how to accomplish this on the server? :D

JX-CW commented 4 years ago

I do! Making #volcano a discussion only channel would be a start, and warning people who ask for help there, but I feel we could also extend this to people who flagbeg in DMs if screenshots are provided. Sadly there will never be a way to prevent willing people from giving out answers, but this is as close as we can reasonably get.

ir0nstone commented 4 years ago

I think one of the biggest problems is how many hints there are in the channel history, personally I don't think deleting it and recreating would necessarily be a bad thing.

JX-CW commented 4 years ago

Yeah sure, let me go extract all of those first, of course ;)

ir0nstone commented 4 years ago

Jokes aside, searching for the challenge number essentially gives you the answer for the vast majority. 4.4, for example, had the exact technique mentioned until I pointed it out to Linus and it got removed. Wouldn't be surprised if that became a bottleneck now.

R0w4nS commented 4 years ago

Weekly purge of all game channels?

ir0nstone commented 4 years ago

Why not. Or perhaps a similar thing to quotes where everyone can react with a specific emoji if they find it a spoiler and it gets removed. Or maybe when it gets marked as so by at least one person, after a day it automatically gets removed so people can't find it a month later.

github-actions[bot] commented 4 years ago

This issue is stale because it has been open 30 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 5 days

thebeanogamer commented 4 years ago

Given that there is less than a week left on Game and Essentials, this issue feels like it has run its course. Obviously, if there is an extension and people still feel strongly about this, then we are happy to raise it again.

RealJammy commented 4 years ago

I think that the weekly purge of Cyberstart channels would be a good idea for next week, and would literally only take a few seconds of a mod's day. Furthermore, the spoiler down vote system from earlier would also be a good idea as it can remove and punish people who spoil challenges

Sh3llcod3 commented 4 years ago

@RealJammy I think considering that the intake for this year is pretty much over, purging for the last few days probably wouldn't be worth it, since, before a new year with assess begins, the old channels will be retired and new ones will be created as Game 2021 comes around.

The spoiler vote down system sounds good, but there will need to be set limit on how many downvotes it takes, to prevent abuse.

R0w4nS commented 4 years ago

Revive

Skiller9090 commented 4 years ago

if we are making volcano only talk channel why dont we scan each message for two numbers in a row eg: 3 4 and if the message has the numbers in it referring to a level on volcano instead of being general then we delete the message stopping people getting advice on a certain level making it very hard to beg, furthermore we can also detect "l 3 c 4" or anything referring to a level. it is easy to do and makes it hard to beg or hint

ir0nstone commented 4 years ago

Not as if people will find a way around that. Purging the channels is probably the better option. Spoiler votes would be good too, I hate pinging mods for spoilers because it's so trivial yet there's no other way.