CyberDiscovery / meta

This repository is for meta discussion of the Cyber Discovery Discord server.
https://discord.cyberdiscoverycommunity.uk
MIT License
8 stars 9 forks source link

Removal of Mee6 as response to NFT project. #397

Open picapi opened 2 years ago

picapi commented 2 years ago

Mee6, a Discord Bot utilised in the server has recently announced an NFT Project under the brand. The expansion plan includes the idea of creating a marketplace with every community being able to have a token that can then be traded in a decentralised way, presumably on the Ethereum Blockchain.

I feel the idea of community tokens that cannot be controlled effectively would be detrimental to the quality of discussion on the server, as seen by previous spam for on-server currencies. Personally, I also disagree with the principal that everything should be economised, but this is less relevant.

I also do not wish to implicitly support organisations doing this, and their presence in the server implicitly pads their stats and advertises the bot positively to other members, something that I feel should be avoided when dealing with NFT related companies and the environmental, social and other issues attached (https://www.theverge.com/2021/3/15/22328203/nft-cryptoart-ethereum-blockchain-climate-change, www.howtogeek.com/774410/heres-the-problem-with-nfts/, https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/04/nfts-werent-supposed-end-like/618488/ for just a few examples).

I would therefore like to propose that Mee6 is removed from the server, potentially being replaced with an alternative. This need not be a matter of urgency, but I would feel more comfortable with an alternative that doesn't explicitly participate in this fraught space.

I understand that the presence of an XP Leaderboard may be a draw for people to the server, and am unsure how portable that data may be, so would also like to hear from people how important they find that function.

RealJammy commented 2 years ago

I strongly agree with picapi, correlations to NFTs should never be permitted in this skid community.