Change the way we encode responsibilities

DARIAH-ERIC / lexicalresources

Data space of the DARIAH Lexical Resources Working Group

https://dariah-eric.github.io/lexicalresources/

BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License

18 stars 24 forks source link

Change the way we encode responsibilities #187

Open ttasovac opened 1 year ago

ttasovac commented 1 year ago

This is a placeholder from the Lexical Resources Summit 2023.

We've agreed not to recommend anymore respSatement but to go for the more elaborate use of author, principal, editor:

<editionStmt>
    <edition></edition>
    <author></author>
    <principal></principal>
    <editor role="encoder">
        <!-- researcher, encoder-->
        <persName>
            <forename></forename>
            <surname></surname>
        </persName>
        <affiliation>Actual place of affiliation</affiliation>
        <affiliation>2nd affiliation</affiliation>
    </editor>
</editionStmt>

Toma fixed the schema for this in 0.9.2
Toma to create GH issue to gather ideas for values of @role
this needs proper documentation
if a person has multiple roles (can be principle and edtior), we repeat the person, and as editor we can assign multiple roles in space-separated list

ttasovac commented 1 year ago

Just a reminder — we need to agree on suggested values for @role here. We can finalize this on Wednesday during our meeting.

xlhrld commented 1 year ago

I'm not sure how to operationalize the distinction between roles that are encoded by use of dedicated elements such as editor, principal, sponsor etc. and those that we are going to provide via @role. On first sight, @role seems to specify sub-roles for certain main level roles. Seems a bit arbitrary to me and reminds me to the discussion of pos, gen etc. vs. gram@type="pos", gram@type="gender" etc.

JessedeDoes commented 1 year ago

Just for comparison, an example from the ParlaMint listPerson:

    <person xml:id="AvontroodtYolande">
        <persName>
            <forename>Yolande</forename>
            <surname>Avontroodt</surname>
        </persName>
        <sex value="F"/>
        <birth when="1950-03-09">
            <placeName>Antwerpen</placeName>
        </birth>
        <affiliation from="2003-06-05" to="2007-05-02" ref="#OpenVld" role="member"/>
        <affiliation from="2007-06-28" to="2010-05-07" ref="#OpenVld" role="member"/>
        <affiliation from="2003-06-05" to="2007-05-02" ref="#be_federal_parliament" role="member"/>
        <affiliation from="2007-06-28" to="2010-05-07" ref="#be_federal_parliament" role="member"/>
        <figure>
            <graphic url="https://www.dekamer.be//site/wwwroot/images/cv/894.gif"/>
        </figure>