DCCouncil / dcstat

DC Statutes at Large
https://dcstat.dccode.gov
3 stars 1 forks source link

Clarify copyright #2

Open stvnrlly opened 9 years ago

stvnrlly commented 9 years ago

Currently, the site includes two different copyright provisions:

On the main page: All documents contained on this site are available in the Public Domain. In the footer: All content contained on this site is available in the Public Domain. In both cases, the provision links to the CC0 license.

I'd recommend making this a little more in-depth for a couple of reasons, which I recognize are nitpicky. First, there are different possible interpretations of "content" and, to a lesser extent, "documents", such that users could think that the full source code and/or third-party libraries are included in that grant. Second, CC0 is not necessarily a public domain dedication, but rather an attempt to do waive rights to the maximum extent possible. A further wrinkle is that the current Copyright Compendium considers works by "an officer or employee" of DC to be ineligible for copyright protection in the same manner as a work of the federal government.

With all of that in mind, I think something like this would be clearer:

This work is dedicated to the public domain through a CC0 license. Works of the DC government and its officers or employees, such as the statutes at large themselves, are in the public domain. Third-party works incorporated into the source code of the site may retain copyright protection.

vdavez commented 9 years ago

How do you feel about this language?

The measures adopted by the Council and included in the Statutes at Large are dedicated to the public domain through a CC0 license. In addition, any original software and works developed by officer, employee, or agent of the Council of the District of Columbia are dedicated to the public domain through a CC0 license. Software and works created by third parties and incorporated into the source code of the site may retain copyright protection.

And then at the bottom:

The District of Columbia Statutes at Large are available in the Public Domain.

stvnrlly commented 9 years ago

:+1: