Correction of principal edition biblio

[jcowey]

When a DCLP file has

<div type="bibliography" subtype="principalEdition">
            <listBibl>
               <bibl type="publication" subtype="principal">
<ptr target="http://papyri.info/biblio/\d+"/>

and the biblio file does not have

<note type="papyrological-series">
    <bibl>
<title level="s" type="short-Checklist" n="1">.+</title>

What sort of biblio files are we going to have to process? It will be necessary to try to be clear about the different categories.

[paregorios]

@wsalesky as discussed in our Skype call, can you write a script to hunt down some/any examples of this?

[wsalesky]

Here is a list of matching bibl records: https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/4/3034.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. I https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/4/3073.xml: P.S.I. X, 1 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/4/3335.xml: O. Mich. I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/4/3394.xml: P.S.I. XI - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/4/3889.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. III https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/5/4258.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. IV - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/5/4392.xml: P.Lugd.Bat. IV https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/5/4494.xml: P.S.I. XIII, 1 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/5/4667.xml: P.S.I. XII, 2 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/5/4919.xml: P.S.I. XIII, 2 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/6/5513.xml: P.S.I. XIV https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/8/7044.xml: Ch.L.A. IV https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/8/7585.xml: O. Wilcken - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/9/8062.xml: Pap.Graec.Mag. 1 - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/9/8361.xml: Papyri Graecae Magicae - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/9/8755.xml: O.Amst. - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/9/8888.xml: O. Saqqara https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/10/9035.xml: P.Tebt.Tait - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/10/9394.xml: O.Leid. - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/10/9672.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. XIII - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/11/10361.xml: O.D.N. I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/12/11617.xml: O. Ashm. Shelton - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/12/11862.xml: T.Varie - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/13/12016.xml: Suppl. Mag. I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/13/12673.xml: O. Claud. I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/13/12729.xml: Suppl. Mag. II - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/14/13296.xml: P.PalauRib.Lit. - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/14/13309.xml: O.G.N. I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/14/13367.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. XVII - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/15/14068.xml: P. Dublin - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/15/14684.xml: O. Claud. II - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/15/14778.xml: O.D.N. II - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/19/18001.xml: P. Paramone - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/19/18095.xml: P. Horak - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/19/18266.xml: Douch III https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/21/20297.xml: P.S.I. XV https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/21/20408.xml: M.P.E.R., N.S. XXXI - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/21/20517.xml: O. Abu Mina - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/22/21024.xml: O. Edfou I.F.A.O. - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/22/21045.xml: P. Narm. 2006 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/22/21498.xml: O. Frangé - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/22/21621.xml: P. Prag. III - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/35/34232.xml: P.S.I. X, 2 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/36/35110.xml: P. Lund I - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/77/76863.xml: P. Toronto Univ. Inv. F4107 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/81/80609.xml: O. Xer. Inv. 48 https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/81/80636.xml: P. Scholl - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/82/81797.xml: O. Did. - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/82/81813.xml: P. Pintaudi - DONE https://github.com/papyri/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/83/82190.xml: O. Petr. Mus. - DONE

[paregorios]

over to you for analysis @jcowey

[paregorios]

A note on how cases like this are currently (subsequent to changes now in review for #212) handled.

Consider TM 99590, where the following encoding is found:

<bibl type="publication" subtype="principal">
   <ptr target="http://papyri.info/biblio/11862"/>
   <biblScope unit="numbers">12</biblScope>
   <!--ignore - start, i.e. SoSOL users may not edit this-->
   <title level="s" type="abbreviated">T. Varie</title>
   <!--ignore - stop-->
</bibl>

Because biblio 11862 does not have <title level="s" type="short-Checklist">, we get the following in the HTML output:

<tr>
   <th>Principal Edition</th>
   <td>con i contributi di R.S. Bagnall, P. Cauderlier, A.E. Hanson e S. Pernigotti, appendice
      di C. Federici, L. Mita e M. Pezzano, Tavolette lignee e cerate da varie collezioni. 12
   </td>
</tr>

In these cases, current logic selects the first title found in the targeted biblio xml file.

I suspect @jcowey will eventually recommend different, perhaps more nuanced behavior.

[wsalesky]

@paregorios @jcowey This is why I added the bibl type parameter to the buildCitation template, this should make conditional displays a little easier.

[jcowey]

It does not help that in the particular case of https://github.com/DCLP/idp.data/blob/master/Biblio/12/11862.xml the entry of the data is messed up. That will not be the only case of messed up data. The best of XSLTs cannot make sense of bad data. ;) I will sort that particular biblio file.

[jcowey]

http://papyri.info/biblio/3034: M.P.E.R., N.S. I http://papyri.info/biblio/3073: P.S.I. X, 1 http://papyri.info/biblio/3889: M.P.E.R., N.S. III http://papyri.info/biblio/4392: P.Lugd.Bat. IV http://papyri.info/biblio/4494: P.S.I. XIII, 1 http://papyri.info/biblio/4667: P.S.I. XII, 2 http://papyri.info/biblio/4919: P.S.I. XIII, 2 http://papyri.info/biblio/5513: P.S.I. XIV http://papyri.info/biblio/7044: Ch.L.A. IV http://papyri.info/biblio/8888: O. Saqqara http://papyri.info/biblio/18266: Douch III http://papyri.info/biblio/20297: P.S.I. XV http://papyri.info/biblio/21045: P. Narm. 2006 http://papyri.info/biblio/34232: P.S.I. X, 2 http://papyri.info/biblio/76863: P. Toronto Univ. Inv. F4107 http://papyri.info/biblio/80609: O. Xer. Inv. 48

[paregorios]

XSLT modifications to display all this were implemented with issue #269.

[paregorios]

@jcowey have all the XML modifications you had in mind been implemented such that this ticket can be closed, or is there still work here to do?

[paregorios]

ping @jcowey please see query preceding