search

DGtal-team / DGtal

Digital Geometry Tools and Algorithm Library
https://dgtal.org
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
370 stars 115 forks source link

Replace QGLviewer with QT3D framework ? #621

Closed kerautret closed 9 years ago

kerautret commented 11 years ago

I was wondering if we could try to change the dependancies of QGLViewer with QT5 3D possibility ? @mtola you mention it last year, but now since the version 5 is perhaps stabilized, it could be interesting to test ? The advantage is that it remove the dependancy of qglviewer which looks not updated since a year. The potential viewer looks comparable at first view. @mtola have you test it? By the way @dcoeurjo I don't remember if the OGRE branch was ready to be merged ?

mtola commented 11 years ago

Qt3d was removed from qt5 final (it was with qt5 alpha) and now delayed. Normally for the end of the year with qt 5.2... I will use it for another project so why not for dgtal... So, to be continued...

Le 21/05/2013 22:02, Kerautret a écrit :

I was wondering if we could try to change the dependancies of QGLViewer with QT5 3D possibility ? @mtola https://github.com/mtola you mention it last year, but now since the version 5 is perhaps stabilized, it could be interesting to test ? The advantage is that it remove the dependancy of qglviewer which looks not updated since a year. The potential viewer looks comparable at first view. @mtola https://github.com/mtola have you test it? By the way @dcoeurjo https://github.com/dcoeurjo I don't remember if the OGRE branch was ready to be merged ?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/DGtal-team/DGtal/issues/621.

kerautret commented 11 years ago

thank you, ha ok yes we will see perhaps for DGtal 1.0 ;) !

dcoeurjo commented 11 years ago

OGRE was ready couple of months ago.. I don't know if it is still the case..

kerautret commented 11 years ago

OK i check soon again and merge if fine ...

dcoeurjo commented 11 years ago

Wait... there was not a lot of motivation for OGRE during last meeting (despite its interactivity).. I could be hard to maintain both QGL and OGRE. Maybe we'd have to make a choice

kerautret commented 11 years ago

ok you are right, we can wait

mtola commented 11 years ago

after one year, libQGLViewer is finally always alive... see http://www.libqglviewer.com/

kerautret commented 11 years ago

Good news ;) and also available on github ;) https://github.com/GillesDebunne/libQGLViewer

dcoeurjo commented 9 years ago

Closing this issue, let's wait a little bit for QT5-QT3D

mtola commented 9 years ago

I'm not working on DGtal for now but just to tell you that qt3d is now out for the first time (Technology Preview) since this summer in qt 5.5: http://www.kdab.com/qt3d-technology-preview-released-qt-5-5-0/