nicolasfranck
commented
2 years ago Well this is how we revised it:
- hide the tab of contributor
- for every collaborator, look for a contributor with the same email, and show its rights in column "Contribution"
User are confused about the difference between Collaborators and Contributors.
In the short term, we should improve wording of on-screen explanatory text to make this difference clearer.
In the long term, we should improve the workflow for adding Contributors and Collaborators. Is this difference worth two separate workflows? Who makes use of the information Collaborator vs Contributor? Most Contributors are likely to be Collaborators as well and may want to view/edit the plan. Note that neither Collaborators nor Contributors are listed on the full download (including the cover sheet) of the plan.
Please complete the following fields as applicable:
What version of the DMPRoadmap code are you running? (e.g. v2.2.0) latest
Expected behaviour: In DMPonline, there are two separate tabs, one for adding Contributors and a Share for inviting collaborators with varying rights (edit, read-only, etc).
In DMPTool, there is one tab called Collaborators, with two different buttons, one for 'Add contributor' and another for 'Invite collaborators'.
Users are expected to read instructions and understand the subtle difference between these two categories, Contributor vs Collaborator.
Actual behaviour:
The process of adding a collaborator is also prone to errors, at least on DMPonline.
It works smoothly for collaborators who already have a user account.
When collaborators who haven't already got user accounts on DMPonline/DMPTool get the notification message 'A Data Management Plan in DMPTool/DMPonline has been shared with you', they are taken through to the 'create an account' procedure. Users tend to type manually their organisation name rather than select from drop-down list and get error message 'The name you entered was not one of the listed suggestions'.
In the short run we could improve the wording to say, for example, 'Please select one of the listed organisations. If your organisation is not listed, select Other'.
In the long run, we should revise the whole procedure for adding Contributors/Collaborators.
Steps to reproduce: DMPonline: add contributors via the Contributors tab, add collaborators via Share plan tab DMPTool: go to Collaborators tab and follow 'Add contributors' and 'Invite collaborators' procedures
FAO DMPonline team: This is relevant to Salesforce case 00027086. Note: the case came via Unidesk so you won't be able to see the bulk of the correspondence if you don't have access to Unidesk. Read the summary notes.