It's unclear how exactly Distribution's 'rights' property interacts with 'license' and 'accessRights' (as well as 'accessRestriction', 'useRestriction', and 'cuiRestriction')

sofianef commented 11 months ago

Name: Carrie Comstock

Affiliation: USEPA Office of Research and Development (ORD), Cummings.Carrie@EPA.gov

Type of issue: Schema, Editorial

Section # / Table #: 5.18.2 Distribution's rights property

Issue:

Substantive Comment: It's unclear how exactly this interacts with 'license' and 'accessRights' (as well as 'accessRestriction', 'useRestriction', and 'cuiRestriction'). There's some documentation in DCAT 3.0 related to how some of the fields work together, but it's unclear whether DCAT-US 3.0 is aligned here.
Rationale: Clarity on documenting legal metadata would be helpful.
Proposed Disposition: Clarification of which fields are appropriate in which circumstances.

Original email submission: USEPA-ScienceHub-FAIRness.Project.-.DCAT-US-3-AP.-.Comment.Review.Matrix.xlsx

hkdctol commented 10 months ago

Seems like 171-174 are similar issues for discussion

fellahst commented 10 months ago

A section for legal metadata in usage guideline has been added in the specification. This section can be used as starting point for discussion and review by legal experts.

DOI-DO / dcat-us

It's unclear how exactly Distribution's 'rights' property interacts with 'license' and 'accessRights' (as well as 'accessRestriction', 'useRestriction', and 'cuiRestriction') #171