search

DaGenix / rust-crypto

A (mostly) pure-Rust implementation of various cryptographic algorithms.
Apache License 2.0
1.4k stars 298 forks source link

Create an organization or move under another organization #387

Open Arcterus opened 8 years ago

Arcterus commented 8 years ago

I think it would be better for this repository to be under the control of an organization so that pull requests and issues can be dealt with even while @DaGenix is busy. Currently there are 21 pull requests that need to be sorted through.

Thoughts?

burdges commented 8 years ago

Agreed. Alternatives like ring or sodiumoxide expose way too little.

burdges commented 8 years ago

Can rust-lang-nursery take it over? Anyone know their criteria for inclusion?

FredericJacobs commented 8 years ago

@burdges: Why not have it in an org that interested contributors would manage?

burdges commented 8 years ago

Yes that's fine of course. I kinda confused a github "org" with more meat space things for a moment there. :)

Razican commented 8 years ago

@FredericJacobs I would say the nursery makes sense due to the relevance of the project. Having a complete crypto library could be considered as important as having a libc interface.

DaGenix commented 8 years ago

It is clear that I've not been able to give the project the time it needs over the last few months. I'm amenable to the idea of exploring a move under rust-lang-nursery, but, I don't know who would even be the right person to ask if that organization would be interested.

I do want to apologize for being an absent maintainer over the last few months. I'm still quite interested in helping the success of rust-crypto and discussing all options that would help with that goal.

Razican commented 8 years ago

Now that you are here, there is probably no need to move it to another organization, but it would be wise IMO to add at least one more maintainer to the repo, so that the project does not stall when one of the maintainers can't work on it for some time.

burdges commented 8 years ago

In any case, there are a few of us who could try to review and/or tweak patches so as to reduce the time @DaGenix needs to spend on them himself.

newpavlov commented 8 years ago

I've created RustCrypto organization for my work on making rust-crypto modular. Currently only hash functions more or less ready (I recently wrote on reddit about it), work on other crates is ongoing.

If @DaGenix is interested he is welcome to become its another owner. Also there is open questions about how to properly organize work in this organization and about repositories structure. So if you have suggestions or can share your experience I will be happy to hear you.

P.S.: I would like to rename this organization to rust-crypto if possible, but this name was already occupied by someone, so if you are owner or know this person, please contact me.