search

DakuTree / manga-tracker

A cross-site manga-tracker.
https://trackr.moe
GNU General Public License v2.0
95 stars 15 forks source link

Chapter comments? #140

Open DakuTree opened 7 years ago

DakuTree commented 7 years ago

Would just be another button you can click on the topbar that would show an inline popup with discussion on the current chapter.

Would probably be best to just use one of the existing places to comment rather than our own. Either the sites own comments, /r/manga (only if active thread exists) or the MAL forums. Could give the user a choice on where to comment?
Also it might be good to have something like a disqus fallback in case none of the above exist.

Vesnyx commented 7 years ago

Here's another project that does something similar for KissManga: https://github.com/myh1000/RoKA

Vesnyx commented 7 years ago

Something else would we what we need to do for multiple chapter releases. There are usually batch release threads for reddit, so it might be difficult to match the chapters and comments properly.

DakuTree commented 7 years ago

Good point.

Rather than trying to auto-detect the reddit post it might be better to just display a list of possible search results to the user, then display the selected one to the user.

Vesnyx commented 7 years ago

I'm thinking that rather than do that all the time, it might be better to try to search for the chapter, and only if the chapter is not found/recognized, then display a set of results for the user.