NeuralNote Review - Githubissues

mslinn commented 2 months ago

Just a little review I wrote.
I hope you read it note for note.
Don't worry,
Be happy.

You are welcome to leave a comment here, or contact me directly.

DamRsn commented 2 months ago

Thanks for the review! It's great to have a comparison of the different audio-to-midi solutions available out there!

Few comments:

See the other Github issues about the Windows sample rate locked at 48 kHz and the min note duration thing.
I think the term LLM (Large Language Model) is used incorrectly in the article. BasicPitch is a tiny neural network with ~16,000 parameters, while LLM usually have tens of billions of parameters. And BP is not doing any language modelling. Regarding AI-MIDI, I don't know what kind of ML model they're using.

mslinn commented 2 months ago

I will edit the article to be more precise. Thank you for the feedback :)

mslinn commented 2 months ago

Edits were published. Please let me know of any additional comments you might have.

mslinn commented 2 months ago

I noticed how similar NeuralNote looks to Decent Sampler:

decent_sampler

Is this because both are based on eyalamirmusic/JUCECmakeRepoPrototype?

DamRsn commented 2 months ago

No it's because they are both made with JUCE.

DamRsn / NeuralNote