DandelionSprout / adfilt

The place where I, DandelionSprout, store my web filter lists for countless topics, including my Nordic adblock list. As simple as that, really.
Other
1.51k stars 149 forks source link

[Question] .gvt2.com #1071

Open nightznero opened 18 hours ago

nightznero commented 18 hours ago

Describe the problem below this line as meticulously and detailed as possible (incl. pagelinks if any)

Helloz Dandi,

I noticed that Your list (AdGuard Home List) includes @@://beacons*.gvt2.com^ While @StevenBlack on his List blocks all (i guess) *.gvt2.com I would like to know; it's especially made @@:// instead of @@|| to not collide with each other ? If its not about the syntax I would like to know why it's unblocked,does it's breaks anything in Android/Google? Bcs we know that Steven blocks adware and guess its any Analytics but if it's unblocked is there any sync or so underneath? Best regards, NIGHTZNERO.

Add screenshots below if needed

Screenshot_20241108_074725_Brave

Which filterlists did you use? Failing to tell this with at least 10 letters or 1 image, will close the report until it has been told.

AdGuard Home List

Which OS(s) did you use when testing this?

Android

StevenBlack commented 6 hours ago

@nightznero to clarify ⬆️ my hosts files don't block *.gvt2.com because wildcards are not a thing in hosts files. So domains must be blocked individually, and explicitly.

The domains explicitly blocked by my hosts files are:

beacons.gcp.gvt2.com
beacons.gvt2.com
beacons2.gvt2.com
beacons3.gvt2.com
beacons4.gvt2.com
beacons5.gvt2.com
DandelionSprout commented 4 hours ago

Furthermore (and about the OP's specific question), :// is to specify that the domain starts with that text.

:// would cover beacons*.gvt2.com, but not for example johnmadden.beacons*.gvt2.com.

|| would cover both.

:// would be in theory be possible to replace with a single | line, which'd have the same effect in AdGuard DNS tools (incl. the DNS modes of AdGuard for Android/Windows) but which'd make the entry useless in regular adblockers, though that list of mine is strongly discouraged from use in regular adblockers except in the most hardcore of debugging situations.

nightznero commented 1 hour ago

@nightznero to clarify ⬆️ my hosts files don't block *.gvt2.com because wildcards are not a thing in hosts files.

Included screen to avoid misunderstanding,also i think Dandi know what i mean if he works with filter lists but still thanks for clarify Steven,its very nice 🫱🏻‍🫲🏼

:// would cover beacons*.gvt2.com, but not for example johnmadden.beacons*.gvt2.com.

|| would cover both.

Thanks for explaination 🫡 but i still have a one tiny question 😅

though that list of mine is strongly discouraged from use in regular adblockers except in the most hardcore of debugging situations.

Does that mean that beacons*.gvt2.com & beacons.gcp.gvt2.com (or just whole gvt2.com) can be freely blocked if i dont mind Debug? Or its necessary for something to not break and You know smthg that Steven doesn't?🤔 If can be blocked one last question,how to overwrite Your whitelisted rules? Cause there is no specific modifies like $important or $badfilterthat would be higher than simple whitelist,am I right? (We don't talk about deleting ur list,it's stays with me,looking for another "exit" from that scenario)

DandelionSprout commented 1 hour ago

Essentially:

1) Do not use the list in regular adblockers unless it is to test out how to fix a problem caused by the list. 2) $important does override whitelistings. 2b) For $badfilter it gets a bit different, but @@||example.org^$badfilter will make the adblocker decide to not use @@||example.org^. It will however continue to use entries that are spelled even slightly differently, like @@example.org|