Dash-Industry-Forum / Live

Collects issues about the Live document
5 stars 0 forks source link

differences with DVB DASH #58

Closed RufaelDev closed 4 years ago

RufaelDev commented 4 years ago

The low latency DASH spec at DASH-IF is not as well aligned with DVB DASH as mentioned in the spec text.

*chunked fragments and @availabilityTimeComplete=false : mandatory in DASH-F optional in DVB DASH ServiceDescription Element mandatory in both, but DVB also mandates the Scope element

PRFT MPD Element mandatory in DASH-IF but optional in DVB DASH

scoping urn to signal low latency content defined in DVB but not in DASH-IF

supplemental/essential property for annotating ll adaptationset available in DVB but not in DASH-IF

http chunked transfer encoding mandatory in DASH-IF but not in DVB

player behavior defined in DVB but not in DASH-IF (only limited)

requirements for encoder/packager RT behavior defined in DASH-IF but not in DVB

inband prft (file format prft) used in DASH-IF but not in DVB

It would be good consider aligning the two specifications as mentioned in the text. There are probably more differences/inconsistencies, but these were the ones that I found initially after going through the specifications. the two documents.

RufaelDev commented 4 years ago

I added this comment to #46