No PC Speaker Beep during boot on MSI Z790-P Wifi

[JanPrusinowski]

Component

Dasharo firmware

Device

MSI Pro Z790-P

Dasharo version

msi_ms7e06_v0.9.2_ddr5-rc3

Test case ID

ERR001.001, ERR002.001

Brief summary

There is no sound comming out of the PC Speaker

How reproducible

100%

How to reproduce

Reboot the platform and wait for a beep.

Expected behavior

There should be a beep.

Actual behavior

No sound is produced.

Screenshots

No response

Additional context

No response

Solutions you've tried

Reversing polarity of PC Speaker, Trying a different PC Speaker.

[miczyg1]

@JanPrusinowski our builds do not beep during boot on MSI platforms. That behavior is only present on Protectli platforms.

[JanPrusinowski]

Test for the beep is in the scope of testing.

[miczyg1]

it may beep but only for error paths, e.g. no memory modules present.

[miczyg1]

Is it in the scope? https://docs.dasharo.com/variants/msi_z790/test-matrix/ I don't see ERR test cases anywhere? Here https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/1/d/1wSE6xA3K3nXewwLn5lV39_2wZL1kg5AkGb4mvmG3bwE/edit?gid=1753841105#gid=1753841105 it was not tested previously and wasn't intended to probably. For sure ERR002.001 is not supposed to be tested on this platform.

ERR001.001 is for error beeps ERR002.001 is for boot beeps.

So per your issue description, only ERR002.001 should fail. For ERR001.001 to pass, you have to simulate an error path, e.g. remove memory modules.

[JanPrusinowski]

It is in the scope - just was not tested before. @BeataZdunczyk can we remove this test from the scope then? I'll re check the ERR001.001 to make sure and let know.

[JanPrusinowski]

@miczyg1 ok So there is a beep when the Ram is out