DavidXanatos / priv10

Privacy tool for windows with a built in firewall
https://xanasoft.com/
Other
616 stars 86 forks source link

custom window, default improvement #53

Closed whismerhill closed 4 years ago

whismerhill commented 4 years ago

When the software is configured in whitelisting mode, the custom window could default to "allow" which would save a few clicks As their is basically no reason to "block the connection" since you could instead use the "BLOCK ACCESS" rule or just ignore it which will block the connection anyway in whitelisting mode

Thanks.

DavidXanatos commented 4 years ago

I think there are two things to consider, first I don't want users accidentally giving access to something.

Second there are cases where you may want to switch to blacklist mode as its more expedient when installing software that creates a lot of temp files that need internet access. During that you don't want software on you system that was supposed to be blocked gaining access to the internet.

So its advisable to create bock rules even when in white listing mode.

whismerhill commented 4 years ago

indeed you can & should create block rules even in white listing mode I agree but then I would just use the easier : "BLOCK ACCESS" profile the amount of times where one needs a custom rule to block access, must be extremely rare ?

also as far as accidental giving access, FULL ACCESS is much easier and quicker to give

Anyways, was just my 2 cents

whismerhill commented 4 years ago

51

I guess if we get more profiles, this becomes not as much needed, so closing this.